Thursday, January 06, 2022

Bateman's Only Real Sin Was Blaming the Jews

Dave Bateman, founder and (now former) chairman of a Utah tech company, made a splash this week when he sent out an email to Utah tech and political leaders blaiming Jews for the pandemic and accusing them of trying to kill the American people (apparently with both the virus and the vaccine). I haven't been able to find the full text of the email, but various reports quote the following excerpts.

I write this email knowing that many of you will think I'm crazy after reading it. I believe there is a sadistic effort underway to euthanize the American people. It's obvious now. It's undeniable, yet no one is doing anything. Everyone is discounting their own judgment, and dismissing their intuition.
I believe the Jews are behind this. For 300 years the Jews have been trying to infiltrate the Catholic Church and place a Jew covertly at the top. It happened in 2013 with Pope Francis. I believe the pandemic and systematic extermination of billions of people will lead to an effort to consolidate all the countries in the world under a single flag with totalitarian rule. I know, it sounds bonkers. No one is reporting on it, but the Hasidic Jews in the US instituted a law for their people that they are not to be vaccinated for any reason.
The spike protein in both the vaccine and the illness are [sic] attacking the reproductive systems of women, and will eventually erode the number of T cells in our bodies that can ward off infections. Don’t get the illness and don’t get vaccinated.
I pray that I'm wrong on this. Utah has got to stop the vaccination drive. Warn your employees. Warn your friends. Prepare. Stay safe.
When the local FOX station followed up with him, he responded:
"Yes. I sent it. I have nothing but love for the Jewish people. Some of my closest friends are Jews. My heart breaks for their 2500 years they’ve been mistreated by nearly every country on earth. But I do believe Scottish Rite Freemasons are behind the pandemic (overwhelmingly Jewish)," he wrote. "And I fear billions of people around the globe right now are being exterminated."
That Bateman would believe this, not to mention broadcast it, is horrifying and he deserves all the public denunciation that he is receiving, which is primarily focused on his antisemitism. But I couldn't help but notice that most of what he said is fairly non-controversial in right-wing circles [1]. His downfall (thus far) was blaming "the Jews". That's still a bridge too far (for now), so it's the easiest part to denounce. But if he had only blamed a single Jewish person (e.g. George Soros), his ideas wouldn't be any more controversial than what is said by right-wing commentators and politicians every day.

Bateman may seem down and out at the moment, but if he hangs in there and plays his cards right [2], he will go from pariah to right-wing hero with surprising speed.

Notes:
1. Maybe not the Catholic part, but I don't know. There are fundamentalist strains of protestantism that don't accept that Catholics are even Christian, and there are conservative Catholics who don't like Pope Francis, so it's possible the Catholic part is more widesrpead than I realize. But the rest is pretty garden-variety and easy to find. Examples on this blog alone are here and here.
2. Don't apologize; get on a speaking/media tour; narrow to a single prominent Jewish person or family; blame the whole controversy on the liberal media and cancel culture; remind everyone that HE is the victim.

Continue reading...

Monday, January 03, 2022

Differences Between the Creation Accounts

This is a slightly updated version of something I posted four years ago.

The focus of Come, Follow Me this year is the Old Testament. The second lesson covers the Creation in a very cursory way, but asks what is similar and what is different between the various scriptural accounts. Good question! There are lots of subtleties that escape even a careful reading. We miss them, in part, because we have been conditioned by familiarity to not see things staring us right in the face. We also lack contextual understanding about their composition. I thought I would lay out the differences I have collected over the years. You may find that this side-by-side comparison is helpful for following along.

Who does the creating?
Genesis 1: God (Hebrew = Elohim)
Genesis 2: LORD God = Jehovah God (Hebrew = Yahweh Elohim)
Moses 2: God
Moses 3: Lord God
Abraham 4-5: the Gods (likely reflecting the literal Hebrew meaning of elohim, which is plural)

What is the overall story?
Genesis: God creates the heavens and the earth, and life on it, in six days and rests on the seventh day. Then for some reason we get a second story where the LORD God creates man, vegetation, animals, and then woman [1].

Moses: God creates the heavens and the earth in six days and rests on the seventh day. Then we are told that everything previously mentioned was a spiritual creation, and on the seventh day the Lord God creates man, vegetation, animals, and then woman.

Abraham: The Gods create the inanimate portions of the heavens and the earth (expanse, oceans, dry land, lights in the sky) and prepare the earth to bring forth life, in six days/times. At the beginning of the seventh time, the Gods carry out their plan for creating life by creating man, vegetation, woman, and then animals.

Elements unique to The Book of Moses:
- The account is changed to first person from God's point of view
- God speaks to his Only Begotten
- Sea and water are singular in some cases
- The sun and the moon are specifically named
- 'green herb' becomes 'clean herb'
- Moses 2:4: "I, the Lord God, made the heaven and the earth." The order of heaven and earth is reversed to match the reference earlier in the same verse.
- The mist is called forth by God
- Extended explanation of spiritual creation
- Man is the 'first flesh' or first creation
- Animals have the breath of life
- "This I know now is bone of my bones..."

Elements unique to the Book of Abraham
- Everything is done by 'the Gods'
- Different vocabulary including: organized, empty and desolate, brooding, and expanse. Some of these reflect Sexias's Hebrew grammar, which Joseph had studied.
- In Abraham 4:1 and 5:1, 'heavens' is plural, which reflects the plural Hebrew word
- References to both days and 'time'
- 'breath of life' is replaced with 'spirit'
- The rivers in Eden are not named
- Reference to Kolob and the Lord's time
- Woman is created before the animals
- "This was bone of my bones, and flesh of my flesh; now she shall be called Woman..."
- "and for Adam, there was found an help meet for him." Since woman was already created, the word 'not' has been removed.

The Harmonization Instinct
I want to go back to what I said about familiarity causing us to miss things. The harmonization instinct is very strong within the Church and we sometimes have difficulty allowing passages to speak for themselves because we want them to say what they are supposed to say. For example, the Abraham 4 and 5 chapter headings say that the plans for the six days of creation are set forth and then implemented. However, a careful reading shows that there is actually a mixture of creating and preparation going on. The Gods actually do create light, create the expanse, create dry land, and organize the luminaries. The planning part has to do with the eventual creation of life. The six days describe the preparation of conditions for life to be created, and then life is created in the following chapter, beginning with Adam.

Similarly, Moses describes six days of spiritual creation, followed by physical creation on the seventh day. Although this runs against the grain of mainstream interpretation, several elements of the story fall into place when the account is read that way, including the fact that Adam is described as the 'first flesh.' And as a matter of fact, that appears to have been the predominant (or at least an acceptable) interpretation around the turn of the nineteenth to twentieth century (see First Flesh). This interpretation also makes sense of the following passage from the Doctrine and Covenants:

Q. What are we to understand by the sounding of the trumpets, mentioned in the 8th chapter of Revelation?
A. We are to understand that as God made the world in six days, and on the seventh day he finished his work, and sanctified it, and also formed man out of the dust of the earth, even so, in the beginning of the seventh thousand years will the Lord God sanctify the earth...
(D&C 77:12)

If you are thinking, "Well, that's not how it's described in the temple or in Church publications," you are making my point. We tend to force all four creation accounts (Genesis, Moses, Abraham, temple) to tell the same story rather than taking them on their own terms.


Notes:
1. The explanation from scholars of the Hebrew Bible is two separate stories have been merged together. The change in God's name is one prominent clue.


Continue reading...

Tuesday, December 21, 2021

Brigham Young: Don't Expect God to Save You From Your Own Folly

In July of 1868, the Saints in Utah were struggling with grasshoppers destroying their crops. Twenty years prior had been the miracle of the seagulls, but it wasn't a permanent solution. Brigham Young spoke and noted that the Saints had been counseled for years to store up grain and hay, but had instead sold it to ouside markets for cheap. Below are some extracts from his lengthy speech [1].

I believe the Latter-day Saints are the best people on the earth of whom we have any knowledge. Still, I believe that we are, in many things, very negligent, slothful and slow to obey the words of the Lord. Many seem to act upon the faith that God will sustain us instead of our trying to sustain ourselves...

Some try to exercise faith and ask the Lord to remove this destructive power. I remember saying in the School of the Prophets, that I would rather the people would exercise a little more sense and save means to provide for themselves, instead of squandering it away and asking the Lord to feed them...

But some may say, "I have faith the Lord will turn them away." What ground have we to hope this? Have I any good reason to say to my Father in heaven, "Fight my battles," when He has given me the sword to wield, the arm and the brain that I can fight for myself? Can I ask Him to fight my battles and sit quietly down waiting for Him to do so? I cannot. I can pray the people to hearken to wisdom, to listen to counsel; but to ask God to do for me that which I can do for myself is preposterous to my mind...

[The people] are in want and in trouble, and they are perplexed. They do not know what to do. They have been told what to do, but they did not hearken to this counsel...

Let crickets, or grasshoppers, or frosts, or anything else come and destroy our crops, and we feel it then; but just as soon as prosperity comes we forget what has happened...

Take the people and I am proud of them; but there is a feeling with them that they must not be counseled in their temporal matters. I call this a sectarian notion, for we will find yet that God is Dictator in everything...

How much credit was due to [the children of Israel led out of Egypt]? Just as much as to us, for not saving our grain when we had an abundance, and, when the grasshoppers come, crying, "Lord turn them away and save us." It is just as consistent as for a man on board a steamboat on the wide ocean to say, I will show you what faith I have, and then to jump overboard, crying, "Lord save me!" It may not seem so daring; but is it any more inconsistent than to throw away and waste the substance the Lord has given us, and when we come to want, crying to Him for what we have wasted and squandered? The Lord has been blessing us all the time, and He asks us why we have not been blessing ourselves...

Who are deserving of praise? The persons who take care of themselves, or the ones who always trust in the great mercies of the Lord to take care of them? It is just as consistent to expect that the Lord [will] supply us with fruit when we do not plant the trees; or that, when we do not plow and sow and are saved the labor of harvesting, we should cry to the Lord to save us from want, as to ask Him to save us from the consequences of our own folly, disobedience and waste [2].


Notes:
1. Journal of Discourses, Vol 12, pp 238-245
2. This paragraph was quoted in the manual, Teachings of Presidents of the Church: Brigham Young

Continue reading...

Sunday, December 05, 2021

Initial Thoughts on Omicron and Vaccines

You've no doubt seen discussion in the news and social media about the emerging coronavirus variant called Omicron. It was first detected in South Africa, but is now in many countries including the U.S. Because it is fairly new, it's hard to say much definitive about it. I recommend keeping an eye on knowledgable commentators (a few links below).

Initial data from South Africa suggest that it is spreading very fast, and that prior infection with COVID does not give protection (at least robust protection) against Omicron. How well the vaccines protect remains to be seen, but we will likely see a lot more breakthrough cases than with Delta. The reason, simply put, is that the Omicron spike protein has changes that will prevent some of the antibodies that were previously generated from recognizing the Omicron spike. It's not all or nothing; rather, it's degradation by degree.

I made the following figure to illustrate how I think about COVID vaccines. Ideally, most people stay in the first stage, and very few people proceed to the bottom stages. With Omicron, we will probably see more people (either vaccinated or previously infected) go further down than they would if this was just another Delta wave. People with no COVID or vaccination history are simply at the mercy of nature.

What can you do? The same kinds of things you've already been doing. However, you need to be fully vaccinated, including the booster. For one thing, the Delta variant is still very prevelant and we are heading into winter [1]. So you want to be as protected as possible against it. But even if the vaccine isn't as potent against Omicron, there is every reason to expect that it will still be helpful. Whether you have previously had COIVD or not, get fully vaccinated so that your immune system is as prepared as possible for Omicron. Even if the antibodies are not as good as they could be, having them at higher concentration will help. Also, there's more to the immune system than antibodies (namely, T cells), and they need to be on high alert too.

A Few Suggested Information Sources [2]:
Your Local Epidemiologist (Katelyn Jetelina) (Twitter / Substack)
Scott Gottlieb (former FDA commissioner)
Carl Zimmer (science reporter - one of the best in the business)

Notes:
1. As our family was leaving for our Thanksgiving trip, we learned of deaths in the extended family of some friends. The friends were vaccinated, but their rural relatives refused to get vaccinated (for the reasons you can imagine), even though an uncle had died of COVID. A birthday party for the father became a superspreader event, resulting in four hospitalizations. The father died, and at the last update a 31 year-old cousin was on a ventilator and expected to die [update: confirmed dead]. You make your choices, but you don't choose the consequences.
2. I've chosen a few relatively non-technical resources. Keep your eyes on these professionals and those they recommend. Beware of contrarians.

Continue reading...

Friday, November 12, 2021

Sure, Go Ahead and Undo Your Vaccine

I have to admit that I got a bit of a chuckle from an NBC News article about people giving in and getting vaccinated, and then "undoing" it.

In a TikTok video that has garnered hundreds of thousands of views, Dr. Carrie Madej outlined the ingredients for a bath she said will “detox the vaxx” for people who have given into Covid-19 vaccine mandates.

The ingredients in the bath are mostly not harmful, although the supposed benefits attached to them are entirely fictional. Baking soda and epsom salts, she falsely claims, will provide a “radiation detox” to remove radiation Madej falsely believes is activated by the vaccine. Bentonite clay will add a “major pull of poison,” she says, based on a mistaken idea in anti-vaccine communities that toxins can be removed from the body with certain therapies.
Look, unless you are under the care of a physician--probably at the emergency room, it's a virtual guarantee that anything that claims to 'detox' you is utter baloney. In fact, I'll go so far as to say that the word 'detox' is a bright red signal that you are probably dealing with a charlatan.

That's why I thought the article was funny. People who are into 'detoxing' themselves have already left the realm of medical/scientific reality. Why would they care about a news article that tells them that they can't undo or "detox the vaxx"? Excuse me, TikTok says otherwise.

But, since getting a high proportion of the population vaccinated is a good thing, there's a part of me that wants to go along with this. Here's what I might say:
Oh, no! Don't you dare get the vaccine and then take a bath and smear mud on your skin! You'll ruin everything, and the government can't do anything about it! Now you know why doctors are so mad and don't want you to know about this one wierd trick!
That kind of marketing has to be good for something.

Continue reading...

Saturday, October 09, 2021

Anti-Vaccine Sentiment is Not Uncommon Among Chiropractors

Following my last post on anti-vaccine lies told by a chiropractor, I came across two news articles (one new, the other from last May) that highlight that chiropractors seem to be a concentrated source of vaccine mis-information, something that existed before COVID but that has become more prominent in the wake of COVID.

AP News: Anti-vaccine chiropractors rising force of misinformation
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution: Some Ga. chiropractors are stoking fears of COVID vaccines

Both articles state that anti-vaccine sentiment comes from a minority of chiropractors, but they seem to have outsized influence. How much of a minority? It's hard to say, but the AP News article offers this:

AP could find no national numbers of vaccination rates among chiropractors, but Oregon tracks vaccine uptake among all licensed health providers, and the numbers show chiropractors and their assistants are by far the least likely to be vaccinated -- and far less than the general public.

Just 58% of licensed chiropractors and 55% of chiropractic assistants in Oregon were vaccinated as of Sept. 5. That’s compared to 96% of dentists, 92% of MDs, 83% of registered nurses, 68% of naturopathic physicians, and 75% of the general public.
Of course, mainstream medicine has its share of quacks and hucksters, and although I have never sought treatment from a chiropractor, I am willing to believe that most of them provide useful medical services [1] in the vein of physical therapy. The problem is that pseudoscience is baked into the history, philosophy, and sometimes the training of chiropractic. The AJC article is particularly interesting here because the largest chiropractic school, Life University, is in Georgia and it is still rooted in outdated 19th century medical ideas.
Such beliefs trace back to the founder of chiropractic, D.D. Palmer, who postulated in the late 19th century that most diseases and maladies are caused by spinal or joint misalignments, and therefore chiropractic adjustments can boost immunity.

Life University still embraces this concept of “vertebral subluxation,” though there is no scientific basis for it. During the height of the pandemic, the school’s guidance for faculty and students on how to prevent getting coronavirus included, “Get your spine checked and adjusted regularly to ensure your nerve system is able to optimally adapt to these external stressors.”
This is such unadulterated horse crap. The notion that an adjusted spine could protect you from contracting COVID is just as stupid as if I were to tell you that the COVID vaccine can protect you from getting a herniated disc. The problem here is that if your beliefs about health are wrapped around notions of mystical energies and "natural healing," then your diagnoses and treatments are going to be primarily concerned with unlocking said mystical energies [2] and promoting "natural healing". But healthy living, good nutrition, and great posture can only take you so far [3].

And yet, graduates of Life University who absorb these views are seen as doctors (with accompanying authority) in the eyes of the public, which is reinforced by their licensure by the state. This in spite of the fact that they are not licensed to prescribe drugs or perform surgeries. In Georgia, they aren't allowed to puncture the skin, so they presumably couldn't offer vaccination even if they wanted to.

Look, I'm not trying to demean any chiropractors out there in my readership, or their friends and loved ones. If they provide genuinely useful treatments to people and stick to their sphere of training and licensure, then God bless them. But the public should know that a chiropractor's sphere of medical authority is rather narrow, and the opinions of chiropractors on vaccines should hold commensurate weight.

Notes:
1. Some patients may also find social/psychological benefit from their visits.
2. An old chiropractor I knew once said that he had to understand quantum mechanics for his job. I was too dumbfounded and incredulous to ask questions.
3. As an extreme example, rabies virus travels up the peripheral nerves to the central nervous system. Once there, it is virtually always fatal in humans. No vitamin juice to aid "natural healing" or spinal adjustment to optimize nerve adaptation to such an "external stressor" has changed that. Vaccination or passive antibody treatment after a bite is your only real hope.

Continue reading...

Sunday, September 26, 2021

A Chiropractor Tells Blatant Lies that Feed COVID Craziness

Apparently there is a movement on Facebook by anti-vaccine groups to discourage sick people from going to the hospital. Via NBC News:

Anti-vaccine Facebook groups have a new message for their community members: Don’t go to the emergency room, and get your loved ones out of intensive care units.

Consumed by conspiracy theories claiming that doctors are preventing unvaccinated patients from receiving miracle cures or are even killing them on purpose, some people in anti-vaccine and pro-ivermectin Facebook groups are telling those with Covid-19 to stay away from hospitals and instead try increasingly dangerous at-home treatments, according to posts seen by NBC News over the past few weeks.
Where does this kind of craziness come from? I'll show you an example. I recently came across a video of a chiropractor named Bryan Ardis giving a presentation at a right-wing event. He was spinning some yarn about how the death toll of COVID in the U.S. is a result of the drug remdesivir (among the treatments given to President Trump), which Anthony Fauci knew to be fatal, and how this is part of a murderous plot Fauci and the government have been carrying out. He compared the use of remdesivir to--and I am not making this up--the gas chambers of Nazi Germany.

This is all crazy enough [1], but the evidence he presented was what caught my interest. He referenced a study published in the prestigious New England Journal of Medicine from 2019 where remdesivir was one of four treatments tested against Ebola virus. Ardis emphasized that HE actually read the study, and alleged that remdesivir was pulled early because it killed 54% of the people who received it. This, he said, is why Dr. Fauci pushed using the drug for COVID--so that it would kill lots of people.

To prove that he wasn't lying, Ardis showed Table 2 from the Ebola study, drawing attention to the number I have highlighted.

Sure enough, 53.1% of the remdesivir recipients died. And it is true that both the remdesivir and ZMapp (triple monoclonal antibody) treatent groups were stopped early because more people were dying. There's just one problem: THESE PEOPLE HAD EBOLA!

In case you live in a cave and haven't heard of the Ebola virus, it's only one of the most deadly viruses on earth. The virus, not the drugs, was killing people. The remdesivir and Zmapp treatments were halted because the other two treatments were saving more lives, so it would be unethical to continue using inferior treatment [2].

Ardis's spin is such an egregious distortion of the study that we should be excused from bothering with his other claims, most of which are equally bonkers. He has clearly marked himself as an idiot, a lunatic, or liar. I mean, for heaven's sake, the table even breaks the death rate down between high vs low viral load, so that should be a big clue as to what's going on. He made the same claim on a podcast I found while checking into his background, so this isn't an isolated incident.

Ardis went on to show an internal Powerpoint slide from the FDA, drafted prior to the vaccine rollout, that listed a variety of possible adverse events to be monitored. According to him, the slide is proof that the FDA knew that the vaccine would cause such adverse events. This is so obviously stupid, but people eat this stuff up. He also made a plea for people to avoid ICUs and keep their loved ones out of hospitals because they will be subjected to this genocide. Instead, you should go to his website and get HIS recommendations.

It's worth noting, again, that Ardis is (or was [3]) a chiropractor, which means that he is not licensed to prescribe ANY drugs. And heaven knows that there is a lot of quackery that operates under the banner of chiropractic [4]. So by all means, let's take this guy's advice on medical issues he has no training in.

But if you do want to get his recommendations, you have to give him your email address. Why? Probably so that he can market his line of health products to you. In other words, in my opinion he is a health huckster seeking to create customers and build his public brand, and his value proposition is that he can save you from the tyranny of government-medical industry conspiracies. But first he needs to convince you that there is such a conspiracy [5]. But whatever the case, he is clearly not someone with any relevant training. And even if he did have relevant training, his claims would still be wrong.

At the risk of spreading misinformation, I am recommending that you watch his video here. You need to see how confidently and charasmaticly this guy speaks. Then look at who is promoting him and the other things they promote. Perhaps it will help you to develop your own BS detector.

Notes:
1. But sadly becoming routine enough that we hardly notice any more. Ironically, Ardis is only one step away from agreeing with China's baseless accusation that it was the U.S. that leaked the virus into the world.
2. Similarly, from a purely scientific point of view it would be preferable to have a placebo control group to compare to. However, Ebola is so deadly that it wouldn't be ethical to do that. Instead, there is an evolvoing 'king of the mountain' of treatments. A prior study suggested that ZMapp was superior to the prior standard of care, so in this study the ZMapp treatment was considered the benchmark for measuring the others against.
3. During my drafting of this post, I found this fact-check by AP News, which refers to Ardis as "a former chiropractor."
4. I tried to be careful with my wording because I don't mean to imply that all chiropractors are quacks, but the profession sure seems to tolerate a lot of them.
5. Isn't it funny that, if Ardis is to be believed, the government so casually publishes the evidence that it is trying to kill or damage you?

Continue reading...

Monday, September 20, 2021

Example of a COVID Chart Crime

A chart crime is when a chart is used in a misleading way [1]. It could be that the data are manipulated, cherry-picked, or the chart is simply designed such that true data lacks correct context.

Recently the cynical side of me was imagining how I could use COVID data to commit a chart crime. Here is what I came up with.

This chart showing U.S. COVID deaths per capita is extremely misleading, but I haven't monkeyed with the data at all. Can you tell why it is misleading?

Think about it this way: who are the people dying in this chart--especially in the peak on the right? Are they vaccinated or unvaccinated? If you are reading the news at all, you know the answer is that the vast majority of people dying of COVID have not been vaccinated. In fact, according to CDC data, as of Sep 13 there have been 3,040 total fatal breakthrough cases (i.e. vaccinated people who nevertheless died of COVID). By comparison, just since Aug 1 there have been about 60K COVID deaths (U.S. data only). So the mere fact that there is a spike in COVID deaths occuring in the face of the vaccine rollout means nothing for whether vaccines are efficacious or who is at risk of dying. You need more granular data to draw those conclusions.

Assuming the data are good, population-level data are useful for making comparisons between populations, and for developing hypotheses for further investigation. But you need to be careful about what conclusions you draw about particulars from population data alone because even if it is accurate, it masks complications in sub-groups going on underneath.

A word to the wise.

Notes:
1. The term was coined in the finance industry, where apparently chart crimes are common.

Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP