The Creationification of America
In this strange era of 'fake news,' where truth is discounted as lies, and lies are accepted as truth [1], I've found myself wondering how we got to this point. There are many factors, to be sure. However, my mind has been drawn to the long history of creationism. Perhaps a quick review is in order.
Although belief in a creator God extends back millenia, creationism in the modern context refers to a reactive movement within conservative religions to scientific fields dealing with the origin of the earth and life on it. It is historically rooted in fundamentalist Christianity, and in the U.S. the two are usually associated together [2]. A century ago, the Seventh-day Adventist, George McCready Price, pioneered creationist arguments against evolution and geology and published widely. Coming from a somewhat marginalized Christian tradition, his influence was less than it might otherwise have been. (It was enough, however, that Joseph Fielding Smith cited him in his own writings [3].)
John Whitcomb and Henry Morris are credited with successfully injecting modern creationism into Christianity with the publication of their book, The Genesis Flood in 1961. Whitcomb and Morris built on the foundation that Price had laid to argue that, not only is the Bible inerrant and accurate in its description of Creation and the Flood, but that science itself supports the Bible and that scientific arguments to the contrary are based on false and biased presuppositions. This basic thesis has been the dominant theme of creationist arguments ever since, and their writings have labored to show the scientific legitimacy of creationism. And while most of the court battles over the role of creationism in public education were settled decades ago, support for creationism remains strong, as evidenced by two creationist-themed parks in Kentucky.
As a result of this history, generations of conservative Christians have been trained to believe that mainstream scientists hold to ideas that are transparently stupid and are therefore either themselves evil, or dupes of the forces of evil. Adding insult to injury, the purveyors of these ridiculous ideas are upheld by public institutions and even the State. This training has put these Christians at odds with an increasingly secular culture--not just (or even primarily) in terms of how one should act in the world, but in understanding how the world works. Arguments over the age of the earth may seem quaint and unimportant, but they quickly impact decisions of which authorities we should trust and with whom we identify. (That, to me, explains why so many conservative Christians are also hostile to the concept of anthropogenic global warming, where virtually no theological beliefs are at stake.)
We may worry about the way in which media outlets, reinforced by social media, have divided us into bubbles of alternative facts and realities. And we may wonder how Evangelical Christians (and some of their fellow travelers) can have such strong support for a President from whom falsehoods so freely flow. However, if the history of creationism has shown anything it is that the very categories of truth and falsehood are contestable because they exist within a context of assumptions and prior beliefs [4]. Moreover, the resilient creationist bubble has existed for a long time. Perhaps we should not be that surprised that the insurgent bubble has expanded to other areas of science, economics, and any other subject where prevailing authority runs counter to group identity. Facts, especially complicated facts, are often no match for a simple story [5], and persecution narratives and conspiracy theories spread easily.
When it comes to your cause, accuracy and consistency is of less importance than utility. That's one of the lessons of creationism, and a lot of people seem to have learned that lesson.
Notes:
1. Actually, this problem is as old as humanity. I think it's just more noticeable right now.
2. Christian creationism has been imported and adapted into the Islamic world as well.
3. James E. Talmage tried in vain to warn him against accepting Price as an authority on geology.
4. If that sounds like the kind of relativism that conservative Christians hate so much, welcome to one of the ironies of creationism.
5. Creationism is but one manifestation of this very human problem.
Continue reading...
