On Being Certain: An Overview
On Being Certain: Believing You Are Right Even When You're Not, by Robert Burton, is an exploration of where certainty and related feelings--feelings of knowing--come from and what they mean.
"Despite how certainty feels, it is neither a conscious choice nor even a thought process. Certainty and similar states of "knowing what we know" arise out of involuntary brain mechanisms that, like love or anger, function independently of reason." [p. xi]
"The message at the heart of this book is that the feelings of knowing, correctness, conviction, and certainty aren't deliberate conclusions and conscious choices. They are mental sensations that happen to us." [p. 218]
Burton is a neurologist and in early chapters he uses his background to illustrate what happens when certainty is missing, or pathologically present. One fascinating example is a syndrome where, as a result of brain damage, people believe that body parts are missing, or even that they are dead. Demonstration that their heart is beating is not sufficient to overcome the feeling that they are dead. To them it simply shows that one's heart can beat after death.
Burton argues that we should split thoughts into two components: the information of the thought, and the brain's unconscious assessment of the thought which comes in the form of a feeling. Viewed in this way, the feeling does not, in itself, constitute evidence of correctness or incorrectness. This makes sense; we've all had the experience of being quite certain about something only to be confronted with incontrovertible evidence that we were wrong.
An example in the book comes from a study where, within a day following the space shuttle Challenger explosion, a psychologist asked his class to write down details about where they were when they heard about it, and so forth. Two and a half years later the students were interviewed again. Twenty-five percent of the subsequent accounts differed significantly from the original written account, with only 10 percent getting all of the details correct. Many students were convinced that their memories were correct, even when confronted with their own written account. Not only are our memories surprisingly unreliable, the feeling that they are absolutely correct, even when they are wrong, can be hard to overcome.
I didn't get the sense that Burton is particularly religious, but he is sympathetic toward religious people. He argues that our unconscious is the real foundation of our thinking and motivations, only a small part of which bubbles up into consciousness. Given the complexity of our motivations and desires, he thinks that asking people to give up religion for pure rationality is (i) unrealistic because it ignores how our brains work, and (ii) impossible because pure rationality is itself an illusion that is based on unconscious desires and motivations. (As an aside, in The God Delusion Richard Dawkins dismissed Pascal's wager in part by dismissing the notion that you can will yourself to believe something. I wondered why the opposite does not apply--that you can't will yourself to not believe something.)
If science is to carry on a meaningful dialogue with religion, it must work to establish a level playing field where both sides honestly address what we can and cannot know about ourselves and the world around us. We need to back away from perpetuating the all-knowing rational mind myth that makes real discussion impossible. At the same time, we need to acknowledge that the evidence for a visceral need for a sense of faith, purpose, and meaning is as powerful as the evidence for evolution. And we must factor in that irrational beliefs can have real adaptive benefits--from the placebo effect to a sense of hope. Insistence upon objectivity and reason should be seen within a larger picture of our biological needs and constraints. [p. 196]Feelings and science both have their place, but we should be careful not to confuse them. Ideally, they should work together.
The issue I have with gut feeling, intuition, and split-second decisions is in believing that we can know when to trust them without having any criteria for determining this trust. A feeling that a decision is right is not the same as providing evidence that it is right. [p. 154]
The book is an easy read; it's neither philosophical nor overly scientific. Many of the examples Burton draws upon in his discussion come from real life and common experience.
For more on the book, see an interview with the author at Scientific American.
Still to come... the Mormon connection.
Continue reading...



