Friday, February 27, 2009

George Will Responds; Sinks Deeper

George Will published a defensive editorial today regarding his much criticized recent column on global warming. His defense, as contained in the column and as articulated by his editor, basically boils down to this: "I can interpret the data how I want to. That, and reporters at the New York Times are jerks."

In addition, in an attempt to shore up his credibility Will further injures it by writing:

On Feb. 18 the U.S. National Snow and Ice Data Center reported that from early January until the middle of this month, a defective performance by satellite monitors that measure sea ice caused an underestimation of the extent of Arctic sea ice by 193,000 square miles, which is approximately the size of California. The Times ("All the news that's fit to print"), which as of this writing had not printed that story, should unleash Revkin and his unnamed experts.
Problem: The sensor problem did not affect the ACRC's data--the data on which Will staked his claim. Further, taken on its own it still doesn't help him because Arctic sea ice is still down. Also, Revkin has taken up Will's challenge.

My last post, George Will, Global Warming, and Accuracy, gave an overview of the controversy that remains relevant in light of Will's latest column.

For Carl Zimmer's summary and analysis of the latest, see Unchecked Ice: A Saga in Five Chapters, and Ice, Ice Baby: When Fact-Checking Is Not Fact-Checking.

Andrew Revkin of the New York Times responds in Experts: Big Flaw in Will’s Ice Assertions.

Slate also has a helpful article that explains the significance of Arctic ice, and why it is considered separately from that of the Antarctic: Is the Cryosphere Crying Wolf?



2 comments:

rameumptom,  3/02/2009 03:17:00 PM  

I don't think that George Will's data was wrong. I've also read the reports at Science News that detail how the ice is almost back to where it was in 1979, with the exception that it might not be as dense.
Meanwhile, NY Times has been a forefront for every liberal cause, and has demonstrably been shown time and again to ignore inconvenient truths and details that show that climate change and its cause are not as easy to prophecy about as the NYT, Al Gore and others would report.

Jared*,  3/02/2009 08:15:00 PM  

Rameumptom,

The issue is more about trends and context. See my previous post for more on that.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP