I don't know how long it has been available online, but I noticed a few days ago that FARMS Review 19:2 (2007) is on the FARMS website. It seems new to me, but perhaps I just missed it. Anyway, only one review is directly related to science and that is David Grandy's "Ideology in the Guise of Science," a review of The God Delusion by Richard Dawkins. Having recently read the book, I was interested to read this review. FARMS Review is gradually attempting to address secular anti-Mormonism--something I think is important, and this review is part of that effort. [Also of note, don't miss Daniel Peterson's take-down of Christopher Hitchens.]
David Grandy is a professor of philosophy at BYU (my inference). For someone who has taught courses on the history and philosophy of science (Grandy, not me), I have to admit that I was disappointed with his review. I think the whole thing could be summed up with the response, "Oh yeah?!"
A central argument of The God Delusion is that the existence of a supernatural personal God is--in principle--a scientific question, and that although current science cannot disprove his existence, it allows us to say that such a God probably does not exist. In addition, Dawkins makes these additional "consciousness-raising" points (as summarized at Wikipedia):- Atheists can be happy, balanced, moral, and intellectually fulfilled.
- Natural selection and similar scientific theories are superior to a "God hypothesis" — the illusion of intelligent design — in explaining the living world and the cosmos.
- Children should not be labelled by their parents' religion. Terms like "Catholic child" or "Muslim child" should make people flinch.
- Atheists should be proud, not apologetic, because atheism is evidence of a healthy, independent mind.
None of this is really addressed by Grandy. He demurs at the idea that natural selection has as much explanatory power as Dawkins argues it does, but does not provide a basis for thinking otherwise other than to point to holes in our knowledge and play games with analogies. He charges that the book "is ideology poorly disguised as science." I think it would be more accurate and fair to say that it is ideology informed by science. His introductory story insinuates that Dawkins has attacked a caricature of God, and that the book is not threatening, but he does not elaborate.
Certain passages make me wonder how much attention Grandy paid to what he was reading. For example, he writes,In the latter part of the book, Dawkins offers an explanation for religion. Believing that only Darwinian evolution can get to the bottom of this matter, he weaves an interesting story. But this is not to say that others, working from different principles, could not weave equally interesting but very different stories.
In fact, Dawkins argued that religion was not directly selected by natural selection, but is a by-product of something else that was. Further, Dawkins wrote,If, then, religion is a by-product of something else, what is that something else?... I shall offer one suggestion by way of illustration, but I must stress that it is only an example of the kind of thing I mean, and I shall come on to parallel suggestions made by others. I am much more wedded to the general principle that the question should be properly put, and if necessary rewritten, than I am to any particular answer.
In other words, it sounds to me like Dawkins is proposing a hypothesis.
Perhaps I am being too critical. After all, taking on The God Delusion properly would probably require a book of its own; no doubt Professor Grandy has other interests, and this was just a quick summary of his opinion. Further, you ask, "if you're so critical, why don't you write a better review?" My reply would be what I wrote previously: "I do not want to add my voice to those of his critics who obviously miss his point or offer up lame counter-arguments, nor am I equal to the task of taking him on."
I hate to end on a negative note, so I will close with a passage I agreed with.The goal of harmonizing faith and reason is an old one, but there are pitfalls along the way; and to his credit, Dawkins does a good job of pointing some of them out. If we invest faith in, say, intelligent design, irreducible complexity, or certain versions of the anthropic principle, all of which lean on God to make sense of things, what happens when persuasive naturalistic explanations emerge?
Continue reading...