Ontogeny, Phylogeny, and the First Presidency
[The following is a re-edited and somewhat expanded version of an older post. It seems like an appropriate addition to my recent series.]
The 1909 First Presidency statement, "The Origin of Man," contains a sentence that seems odd when considered in light of modern science:
True it is that the body of man enters upon its career as a tiny germ or embryo, which becomes an infant, quickened at a certain stage by the spirit whose tabernacle it is, and the child, after being born, develops into a man. There is nothing in this, however, to indicate that the original man, the first of our race, began life as anything less than a man, or less than the human germ or embryo that becomes a man. [emphasis added]What idea were they trying to counter with that sentence? Perhaps we can affirmatively restate it as the following:
The first human began life as a lesser species, or as an embryo of a lesser species that became a human.No modern science textbook would state such a thing, so where did this idea come from? I believe that the sentence highlighted above was a response to the Biogeneic Law (also known as recapitulation) of Ernst Haeckel (1834-1919).
According to Haeckel, embryonic development involved passing through the adult stages of "primitive" organisms in one's evolutionary lineage, and this concept was encapsulated in the phrase "ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny". Each evolutionary innovation added another stage onto the developmental process, which also compressed the earlier stages--otherwise development would take more time than was observed. Thus, the addition of another stage of development resulted in the creation of a new species higher up on the chain of being. Applied to humans, this would mean that the first human was created when a stage was added to the development of a non-human embryo.
Although Haeckel viewed humans as the pinnacle of nature's creation, it was conceivable that there might be another step up on the chain of being. Although he many not have been reacting to Haeckel, the potential for further progress up the chain of being seemed to be a concern for James E. Talmage (who, by the way, helped draft the First Presidency statement) in his 1931 speech "The Earth and Man" when he said,
Were it true that man is a product of evolution from lower forms, it is but reasonable to believe that he will yet develop into something higher. While it is a fact that eternal progression is a characteristic of man's Divine birthright, as yet we have learned nothing to indicate that man shall develop physically into any other form than that in which he now appears.The idea of progress up the chain of being was not new or exclusive to Haeckel; however, he tightly tied it to embryology, heavily promoted it, and combined ideas from Darwin, Lamarck, and others. Although comparative embryology does shed light on evolution, Haeckel's scheme began to be undermined in the 1890's and was ultimately discarded. Also as a secondary issue, at least since the modern synthesis speciation is generally understood to be a gradual process of reproductive isolation of populations rather than a one-step event (although some exceptions are known).
Unfortunately, modern readers of "The Origin of Man" may come away with an incorrect notion regarding what evolution is and how it occurs. The passage above was relevant in its time, but has become anachronistic. Like the writings of earlier LDS commentators on evolution, readers of "The Origin of Man" should keep the history of science in mind.
For more of on Haeckel see here and here.
Continue reading...
