Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Ontogeny, Phylogeny, and the First Presidency

[The following is a re-edited and somewhat expanded version of an older post. It seems like an appropriate addition to my recent series.]

The 1909 First Presidency statement, "The Origin of Man," contains a sentence that seems odd when considered in light of modern science:

True it is that the body of man enters upon its career as a tiny germ or embryo, which becomes an infant, quickened at a certain stage by the spirit whose tabernacle it is, and the child, after being born, develops into a man. There is nothing in this, however, to indicate that the original man, the first of our race, began life as anything less than a man, or less than the human germ or embryo that becomes a man. [emphasis added]
What idea were they trying to counter with that sentence? Perhaps we can affirmatively restate it as the following:
The first human began life as a lesser species, or as an embryo of a lesser species that became a human.
No modern science textbook would state such a thing, so where did this idea come from? I believe that the sentence highlighted above was a response to the Biogeneic Law (also known as recapitulation) of Ernst Haeckel (1834-1919).

According to Haeckel, embryonic development involved passing through the adult stages of "primitive" organisms in one's evolutionary lineage, and this concept was encapsulated in the phrase "ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny". Each evolutionary innovation added another stage onto the developmental process, which also compressed the earlier stages--otherwise development would take more time than was observed. Thus, the addition of another stage of development resulted in the creation of a new species higher up on the chain of being. Applied to humans, this would mean that the first human was created when a stage was added to the development of a non-human embryo.

Although Haeckel viewed humans as the pinnacle of nature's creation, it was conceivable that there might be another step up on the chain of being. Although he many not have been reacting to Haeckel, the potential for further progress up the chain of being seemed to be a concern for James E. Talmage (who, by the way, helped draft the First Presidency statement) in his 1931 speech "The Earth and Man" when he said,
Were it true that man is a product of evolution from lower forms, it is but reasonable to believe that he will yet develop into something higher. While it is a fact that eternal progression is a characteristic of man's Divine birthright, as yet we have learned nothing to indicate that man shall develop physically into any other form than that in which he now appears.
The idea of progress up the chain of being was not new or exclusive to Haeckel; however, he tightly tied it to embryology, heavily promoted it, and combined ideas from Darwin, Lamarck, and others. Although comparative embryology does shed light on evolution, Haeckel's scheme began to be undermined in the 1890's and was ultimately discarded. Also as a secondary issue, at least since the modern synthesis speciation is generally understood to be a gradual process of reproductive isolation of populations rather than a one-step event (although some exceptions are known).

Unfortunately, modern readers of "The Origin of Man" may come away with an incorrect notion regarding what evolution is and how it occurs. The passage above was relevant in its time, but has become anachronistic. Like the writings of earlier LDS commentators on evolution, readers of "The Origin of Man" should keep the history of science in mind.

For more of on Haeckel see here and here.



Continue reading...

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

LDS Commentators and the Eclipse of Darwinism

This post is a follow-up to Understanding Talmage, Widtsoe, et al.

Through his publication of The Origin of Species, Charles Darwin established that evolution occurred and argued that natural selection was the chief process of evolution. By 1870 most biologists were convinced that evolution occurred, however there was a lot of doubt about natural selection, which would not be re-established as the dominant force of evolution until the modern synthesis of the 1930's and 40's. The intervening time has been called "the eclipse of Darwinism." (Note that the term Darwinism has had several different meanings through history. This post uses the term with reference to evolution with an emphasis on natural selection.) There were several reasons for this eclipse, not the least of which was that many people thought natural selection was too materialistic.

The main historical rivals of natural selection follow below. (For convenience, unless otherwise noted, quotes are from wikipedia.)

1. Orthogenesis: "the hypothesis that life has an innate tendency to move in a unilinear fashion due to some internal or external 'driving force'." In other words, evolution moved along predetermined trends. Orthogenesis was popular with some paleontologists, who saw trends in the fossil record (e.g. horses) which were interpreted in a straightforward manner of A -> B -> C. This theory collapsed because no mechanism could be found to drive such trends, and the very existence of the trends was undermined by a more complete fossil record, which showed multiple branching lineages that lacked an overall directed trend.

2. Neo-Lamarkism: "Lamarckian evolution refers to the once widely accepted idea that an organism can pass on characteristics that it acquired during its lifetime to its offspring." This idea was easily hitched to the notion of progress--that species could improve themselves through behavior. However, experimental support was lacking, and with the rise of genetics it became apparent that there was no way for acquired characteristics to be transmitted to the genome.

3. Mutationism: Historically, the word "mutation" has been used differently than our current scientific use (a change in genotype). In the early years of genetics the word was associated with saltations, or jumps. Genetic traits were often discontinuous (think of the simple either/or traits that Gregor Mendel studied), and it was thought that new species arose through sudden saltations. For decades mutations were seen as the chief alternative to natural selection (orthogenesis and neo-lamarkism having been refuted, in part, by genetics). However, as understanding of the complex interactions between genes grew, it seemed increasingly unlikely that radical changes could result in surviving organisms, and the many failures that would be expected were missing. The modern synthesis finally brought the two concepts together with mutations providing the variation upon which natural selection acts (so to speak). All of this preceded the elucidation of molecular genetics (i.e. determination of the structure of DNA, how it codes for proteins, etc).

It is also important to consider the Great Chain of Being, or scala naturae. We intuitively see that life-forms vary in complexity and intelligence, and the chain of being was a medieval concept that organized life on earth into an ascending ladder-like hierarchy that culminated with humans at the top. According to Bowler (p. 63) [1],

The attractions of the chain of being came not from its practical applications but from its articulation of certain key assumptions. It was conceived as a static plan of nature: all the links in the chain were created together by God. It was a highly structured system in which every species had an unambiguous position, with its closest relatives placed one above and one below it in the sequence. It was a complete system: every link in the chain from amoeba to human, had to exist, and God's perfection was displayed by the fact that He had created every link in the chain...
The alternatives to natural selection listed above were sometimes linked (at least implicitly) to the hierarchal chain of being, thus giving a sense of progress through time as organisms climbed the ladder. In addition, the historical evolution of life was sometimes likened to the development of a fetus (in fact there are evidences for evolution in fetal development), which at the very least gave a sense of progress and goal-oriented development. However, these notions of evolutionary progress rely on human values and subjective judgments rather than objective criteria or mechanistic laws, and there is no evidence that mutations occur in anticipation of the future.

In summary, much of LDS commentary on evolution by General Authorities or other prominent members occurred before the evolutionary synthesis, and although some argue that current biology has outgrown that synthesis (e.g. here), the ideas that flourished during the eclipse of Darwinism have not been vindicated in any significant degree. This history of science should be kept in mind when reading such commentary.



References:
It is difficult enough to keep up with current science without trying to understand science of the past. I primarily consulted the following references in drafting this post.

1. Bowler, Peter J. Evolution: The History of An Idea.
2. Mayr, Ernst. What Evolution Is.


Continue reading...

Tuesday, April 15, 2008

Scientific American on Expelled

The editors at Scientific American watched a screening of Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed and have posted their reviews. Surprisingly, associate producer Mark Mathus actually sought out the SciAm staff and brought the movie to them.

The reviews and the podcast are interesting, but what I really enjoyed was the spirited hour-long conversation between the SciAm folks and Mark Mathus. Mathus was certainly not a shrinking violet, and I give him credit for taking the heat, but I have to say that I really enjoyed editor in chief John Rennie. (Steve Mirsky was good too.)

Neither side was flawless, but I thought the propaganda-like nature of Expelled was made apparent. Listen and decide for yourself.

In other news, Expelled Exposed has gone live.


Continue reading...

Monday, April 14, 2008

Understanding Widtsoe, Talmage, et al

Reading through the writings of some of our earlier brethren regarding evolution, one finds some strange passages. These passages are found in the writings of John A. Widtsoe, James E. Talmage, Sterling Talmage, and even Joseph Fielding Smith. Rather than try to catalog them, a couple of examples may suffice.

In Evidences and Reconciliations, John A. Widtsoe wrote, "The law of evolution or change may be accepted fully. It is an established fact so far as human power can determine. It is nothing more or less than the gospel law of progression or its opposite."


In Can Science Be Faith-Promoting (pg. 154) Sterling Talmage wrote:

...the scientists who have followed Darwin and tested out his theories have found that natural selection has some bearing on the minor changes but that the great changes come about through mutations or the relatively sudden appearance of characteristics that cannot be ascribed to either heredity or environment. Many of these mutations seem to prepare the species for a succeeding environment in a way that suggests a foreshadowing of function.... The cause of mutations is as mysterious as is the origin of life; but many scientists are ascribing it to the design of some controlling intelligence, and the strict materialists are losing ground in scientific circles.

Two concepts are represented in the above passages: First, that evolution is a form of progress, and second, that mutation is more important than (and even refutes) natural selection. (As an aside, notice also Sterling Talmage's God-of-the-gaps comment on mutation. Alas, the materialists lived to fight another day.)

Most people probably would not notice such passages, however, they should seem strange to anyone familiar with evolution. What in the world are they talking about? How are mutations antagonistic to natural selection? The answer is in the history of science and in forthcoming posts I will briefly discuss that history.

Other posts in this series:
1. LDS Commentators and the Eclipse of Darwinism
2. Ontogeny, Phylogeny, and the First Presidency


Continue reading...

Tuesday, April 08, 2008

Monkeys and Monty Hall

An article in the New York Times, And Behind Door No. 1, a Fatal Flaw, reports on a forthcoming paper that argues that the outcome of experiments dealing with monkey choice of M&M color are due to statistics rather than psychology. The article relates this to the Monty Hall Problem, which is a fun counterintuitive mental exercise.

Here’s how Monty’s deal works, in the math problem, anyway. (On the real show it was a bit messier.) He shows you three closed doors, with a car behind one and a goat behind each of the others. If you open the one with the car, you win it. You start by picking a door, but before it’s opened Monty will always open another door to reveal a goat. Then he’ll let you open either remaining door.

Suppose you start by picking Door 1, and Monty opens Door 3 to reveal a goat. Now what should you do? Stick with Door 1 or switch to Door 2?
It is easy to think that the choice boils down to a 50-50 shot. However, if you switch you will win 2/3 of the time. My way of thinking of it is this:

By choosing one door, you only have a 1/3 chance of choosing the correct door. This means that there is a 2/3 chance that you are wrong. Now let's say that it is your policy to always switch when given the option. When you switch you are, in effect, choosing the other two doors--you just get to discard the incorrect door.

I wish I was perspicacious enough to have seen that when I first encountered the problem, but I fell into the 50-50 trap. Anyway, the monkeys and M&Ms are interesting too. There is a nice graphic that explains that issue quite clearly.


Continue reading...

Tuesday, April 01, 2008

Expelled Exposed

Have you been following the story of the forthcoming movie, Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed?

Here's the short version: It's a documentary, hosted by Ben Stein, that has two major themes: (i) that "Darwinists" persecute and discriminate against anybody that questions Darwinian orthodoxy (i.e. espouses Intelligent Design), and (ii) that Darwin is basically responsible for the atrocities of Stalin, Hitler, and eugenics [1]. Last year a number of prominent science and evolution defenders were asked for interviews for the film under false pretenses, and now the film is being shown in a number of private screenings around the country. At one recent screening, biologist-professor-atheist-blogger PZ Myers (who is interviewed and thanked in the film) was denied admittance to a screening for which he had legitimately signed up. However, the rest of his party was allowed in, including Richard Dawkins, who apparently was not recognized. The filmmakers have tried to spin this ridiculous and rather ironic episode, but it remains ridiculous.

Anyway, the NCSE has set up a website, Expelled Exposed, that will be their official response page. For now, it is a collection of links to news stories and film reviews. I'll keep the link on the sidebar for a little while for easy reference.


1. Mormons were not immune to eugenic ideas. In fact, George Q. Cannon espoused such ideas before Charles Darwin or Francis Galton published their major works, and eugenics served as an apologetic argument for polygamy. See Eugenics at By Common Consent.



Continue reading...

Sunday, March 30, 2008

Two GA Quotes on Concordism

The following are two (relatively obscure) quotes with a bearing on concordism:

First from Brigham Young (see also this one) [1]:

When the Lord had organized the world, and filled the earth with animal and vegetable life, then he created man. . . . Moses made the Bible to say his wife was taken out of his side--was made of one of his ribs. As far as I know my ribs are equal on each side. The Lord knows if I had lost a rib for each wife I have, I should have had none left long ago. . . . As for the Lord taking a rib out of Adam's side to make a woman of, it would be just as true to say he took one out of my side.

But, Brother Brigham, would you make it appear that Moses did not tell the truth?

No, not a particle more than I would that your mother did not tell the truth when she told you that little Billy came from a hollow toadstool. I would not accuse your mother of lying any more than I would Moses. The people in the days of Moses wanted to know things that [were] not for them, the same as your children do when they want to know where their little brother came from, and he answered them according to the level of their understandings, the same as mothers do their children.

The second is from former Apostle (1917) and counselor in the First Presidency (1951-59), Stephen L. Richards [2]:
What if Hebrew prophets, conversant with only a small fraction of the surface of the earth, thinking and writing in terms of their own limited geography and tribal relations did interpret [God] in terms of a tribal king and so limit His personality and the laws of the universe under His control to the dominion with which they were familiar? Can any interpreter, even though he be inspired, present an interpretation and conception in terms other than those with which he has had experience and acquaintance? Even under the assumption that Divinity may manifest to the prophet higher and more exalted truths than he has ever before known and unfold to his spiritual eyes visions of the past, forecasts of the future and circumstances of the utmost novelty, how will the inspired man interpret? Manifestly, I think, in the language he knows and in the terms of expression with which his knowledge and experience have made him familiar. So is it not therefore ungenerous, unfair and unreasonable to impugn the validity and the whole worth of the Bible merely because of the limited knowledge of astronomy and geography that its writers possessed?


1. Brigham Young, October 8, 1854, in Leonard J. Arrington, Brigham Young: American Moses, pg. 197-98, as quoted in Philip L. Barlow, Mormons and the Bible, pg 92.
2. Stephen L Richards, "An Open Letter to College Students," Improvement Era 36:451-453, 484-485. June 1933.




Continue reading...

Thursday, March 27, 2008

Rejecting Concordism

I occasionally stroll over to American Scientific Affiliation to have a look at some of their free articles. The ASA is an organization of Christians interested in science, and their arguments and discussions over science and religion are frequently transposable to an LDS context. Although I'm not really sure who he is, I have enjoyed the more recent articles written by Paul Seely.

Today I want to highlight "Concordism and a Biblical Alternative: An Examination of Hugh Ross’s Perspective" (pdf). It is a book review and opens with discussion of the Flood, but my interest here is with the discussion that follows beginning on page 42 under the heading, "A Biblical Approach to Science and Scripture."

Concordism is the expectation that scriptures and science/history should match. This is a natural expectation; why would we expect anything else? Seely lays out some reasons why we should expect otherwise, and some of his arguments are quite at home in Mormonism. His main points are as follows:

1. In giving man dominion over the earth, God delegated discovery of natural truths to all people (i.e. believers and unbelievers) and therefore does not give such details in his revelations.

2. When the biblical writers rely on human sources, mistakes may be incorporated into scripture. "The idea that inspiration will correct or avoid all factual errors in a biblical historian’s sources is not taught in Scripture nor borne out by the phenomena of Scripture."

3. "God’s revelation is organically related to the people to whom it is given and consequently is sometimes accommodated to culturally pre-ingrained ideas." Examples include the permissibility of divorce and slavery.

4. Such accommodation is needed in order facilitate communication, and even belief.

5. "God is not lying or erring, therefore, when his Word does not agree with the findings of modern science because the science per se which he has incorporated into Scripture is not a revelation from God but is simply an accommodation to the science of those times."

To Mormons most of this is uncontroversial, although the specific application may be. Things get a little more tricky when the teachings of ancient prophets are refracted through the revelations of Joseph Smith (e.g. Moses and Abraham). We have to wonder, do the revelations reflect (i) ultimate scientific/historical truth, (ii) accommodation to the ancient prophet's culture, or (iii) accommodation to Joseph's culture (or maybe a mixture of the three)? Committed LDS scholars are of divergent opinions on this question.

Seely again:

By the time of the writing of Genesis, the Israelites already had these ideas about creation, the flood, and the post-flood world deeply ingrained in their culture. As with their ingrained beliefs about easy divorce and slavery, these beliefs about early human history were too imbedded to be summarily contradicted. The original false theology in these traditions was radically revised in the light of the revelation given to Abraham and his descendants, and historical details could be altered in part, but the pre-embedded historical outline could not be changed.
These things were also ingrained in Joseph Smith's culture, and that may explain why our additional scriptures also do not contradict them (see 1-5 above). If Joseph had no reason to question the accuracy of these traditions (e.g. Biblical chronology was still thought to apply to human civilization until around 1860), should we expect his revelations to overturn or alter them?

Thus, Seely argues that we need not twist scripture or science to make them match, nor need we reject one in order to accept the other.
We are reading the divine revelation given to a people from a historically distant and far different cultural background. We need to appreciate the cultural context of those first readers and of God’s condescension to them. Instead of insisting that God and Scripture live up to our expectations that the Bible fit the findings of modern science, we would do better to accept and learn from what God has actually done, read the Bible strictly for the purposes for which it was given, and pursue science with an eye to uncovering the truths of creation to the glory of God.


[Note: For previous posts that touch on concordism, see my new category label, scriptural concordism.]


Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP