Thursday, November 08, 2007

Lamanite Claims Scaled-back

As has been covered by other blogs already, an article in the Salt Lake Tribune revealed that the Church is updating the Introduction of the Book of Mormon in a way that scales back claims for Lamanite ancestry.

After thousands of years, all were destroyed except the Lamanites, and they are the principal among the ancestors of the American Indians.
In a comment at Times and Seasons, Kevin Barney points out that there are probably more changes coming based on Royal Skousen's work examining the original and printer's manuscripts.

The new Juvenile Instructor blog also notes another modest change in the Introduction.

I think it is great that the Church is making a change that is more in harmony with compelling scientific findings. I applaud the decision and hope it is a trend that will continue. "That which is demonstrated, we accept with joy."



Continue reading...

Wednesday, November 07, 2007

Opposition Bias or Lehi's Law

Confirmation bias is the tendency to seek confirmation of one's beliefs or ideas, and to ignore or not seek refuting evidence. For example, I have heard--although I don't know how common it is--that Emergency Room staff or police sometimes believe that a full moon = busy night (the lunar effect). Apparently most studies have failed to find an actual correlation, so why would someone think such a thing? The answer seems to be that once they are led to believe it is true, a person will tend to notice the chance correlation of a busy night with the full moon (or perhaps, nearly full), but fail to notice exceptions (ie. a slow night with a full-moon, or an equally or more busy night without a full moon). The same kind of principles can apply to racial stereotypes, or the ubiquitous invocation of "Murphy's Law" when an inconvenient problem arises.

I was reminded of this recently at church when someone said that good things in life are always opposed by problems/bad things. We have all heard such sentiments and supportive stories--such as cars breaking down on the way to the temple, etc--and 2 Nephi 2:11 is often cited for support.

First of all, I think that is a mistaken--if dominant--interpretation of scripture. But more to the point: Do we remember or account for all of the cars that made it to the temple without trouble, or the other times we made it to the temple without incident?

I do not dispute that good and evil struggle for domination, and that struggle may play out in ways I don't appreciate or understand. I do hypothesize that much of the invocation of what we might call "Lehi's Law" is actually confirmation bias.



Continue reading...

Monday, November 05, 2007

Sidney Sperry and Peanuts

I ran across the following quote from Sidney B. Sperry:

Too many persons in every generation, including our own, hope for things—fantastic things—in the name of faith and religion, but give little thought as to whether or not they are based on truth.
I had been kind of hanging on to this quote, but I thought it went well with the Peanuts strip of Nov 1.

Linus complains,
I believed in the "Great Pumpkin" with every fiber of my being!

Charlie Brown:
In all the world there is nothing more upsetting than the clobbering of a cherished belief.


Continue reading...

Friday, November 02, 2007

Transforming the Tree of Life


When you think of representations of speciation, you probably think of a tree--with species splitting off here and there. It's a metaphor that goes back to Darwin. Representing all life, this pattern is often referred to as the Tree of Life, with modern species represented at the tips of the branches, and the last universal common ancestor (LUCA) at the base of the trunk.

At first blush, "Pattern pluralism and the Tree of Life hypothesis" by W. Ford Doolittle and Eric Bapteste looks like one of those papers that is about to upset the apple cart.

...other evolutionists, ourselves included, question even this most fundamental belief, that there is a single true tree.
It turns out that this is not crazy-talk; rather it is a discussion about whether the data support our preconceptions about evolution--especially among prokaryotes. As I read him, Doolittle argues that down at the base of the "tree," there has been so much swapping around of genes (lateral gene transfer--LGT) that there is no one true tree--based on gene sequences--that represents the real relationship of microbial groups. In other words, as he has written elsewhere,
...lateral gene transfer simply means that there is no unique tree that can describe the history of genomes. The lineages of cells harboring those genomes can still be thought of as having a unique, treelike history, even though our ability to reconstruct it may be compromised by transfer.
So the way to the cellular Tree of Life remains guarded, while the genome Tree of Life may not even exist.

Now for some clarification.
To be sure, much of evolution has been tree-like and is captured in hierarchical classifications. Although plant speciation is often effected by reticulation (80) and radical primary and secondary symbioses lie at the base of the eukaryotes and several groups within them (81, 82), it would be perverse to claim that Darwin's TOL hypothesis has been falsified for animals (the taxon to which he primarily addressed himself) or that it is not an appropriate model for many taxa at many levels of analysis.
And,
Holding onto this ladder of pattern is an unnecessary hindrance in the understanding of process (which is prior to pattern) both ontologically and in our more down-to-earth conceptualization of how evolution has occurred. And it should not be an essential element in our struggle against those who doubt the validity of evolutionary theory, who can take comfort from this challenge to the TOL only by a willful misunderstanding of its import. [italics added]
It looks like this is an issue that is still being hammered out. But in the meantime, don't confuse the base of the tree with the branches.

Reference:

Doolittle WF, Bapteste E. Pattern pluralism and the Tree of Life hypothesis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2007 Feb 13;104(7):2043-9.



Continue reading...

Wednesday, October 31, 2007

MTA Review of Dawkins's Delusion

Lincoln Cannon, of the Mormon Transhumanist Association, is embarking on a multi-post review of Richard Dawkins's The God Delusion. I have not yet read the book, though I am broadly familiar with his arguments. Anyway, I'm betting that Lincoln's treatment will be interesting. The link to the first post is below, and I may collect the others here as well.

Part 1
Part 2

Continue reading...

Monday, October 29, 2007

Ghosts, Vampires, and Zombies

In time for Halloween, Skeptical Inquirer has an article that takes a critical look at ghosts, vampires, and zombies of folklore and film. Here is something I learned: the concept of zombies has some surprising (for me) reality behind it.

Happy Halloween!


Continue reading...

Sunday, October 28, 2007

The Kind of Thing Not Found in the Scriptures

It may surprise you, but the phrase "after their own kind" is not found in the scriptures. I can't find it anywhere; not in Genesis or anywhere else. For all of the talk about the scriptures teaching that all life was to reproduce after its own kind, you would think that the phrase would exist, but it doesn't. You can find "after [their/his] kind," but never "own kind." (I am happy to be corrected, if anybody finds it.)

Am I nit-picking? The scriptures teach the basic idea, right? Well, the best examples come in the discussions of grass and trees with their seeds and fruit. The most explicit is Abraham 4:11-12 with

"...the fruit tree yielding fruit, after his kind, whose seed in itself yieldeth its own likeness upon the earth...

...whose seed could only bring forth the same in itself, after his kind;"
But when it comes to animal life, it is always the earth or waters bringing forth the animals "after [their/his] kind." Does this mean the same thing?

Maybe, but I think there are several reasons to think otherwise. First, I think the phrase could easily be read to mean "according to their similar varieties." In support of this I quote from Genesis 7:14 regarding animals entering Noah's ark:
They [Noah's family], and every beast after his kind, and all the cattle after their kind, and every creeping thing that creepeth upon the earth after his kind, and every fowl after his kind, every bird of every sort.
(See also Genesis 6:20) This language clearly refers to groups of similar animals rather than the perpetuation of essential types.

Second, as I've said before, these passages seem to be at home with spontaneous generation. Whether or not the ancient Hebrews believed in spontaneous generation is irrelevant. The point is that our mind fills in the unstated assumption that the animals accumulated via reproduction. It seems quite possible that an ancient mind would fill in different assumptions.

Third, if you follow the Smith/McConkie school of thought, these passages cannot refer to reproduction. This is because both Joseph Fielding Smith[1] and Bruce R. McConkie[2] claimed that, like humans, animals could not reproduce until after the Fall. Given that, Moses and Abraham were apparently not describing the reproduction of animals.

Actually, this whole discussion seems superfluous because nobody--including biologists--disputes the basic observation that offspring are like their parents, and I view Genesis (and related scriptures) as a representation, rather than an account, of Creation. My main point is that a phrase commonly attributed to the scriptures does not exist, and--secondarily--that some passages presumed to be equivalent to that phrase can be easily interpreted differently.



References:

1. Joseph Fielding Smith, Answers to Gospel Questions, Vol. V, p. 116.
IF there was any creature increasing by propagation before the fall, then throw away the Book of Mormon, deny your faith, the Book of Abraham and the revelations in the Doctrine and Covenants!

2. Bruce R. McConkie, "Christ and the Creation", Ensign, Jun 1982, p. 9.
This command [be fruitful and multiply]—as with a similar decree given to man and applicable to all animal life—they [fish and fowl] could not then keep, but they soon would be able to do so.

Continue reading...

Thursday, October 25, 2007

BYU and Dr. Sites: A Complaint

Speaking of BYU professor Jack Sites, he was profiled in the Winter 2003 (as Justin pointed out) and Winter 2004 issues of BYU Magazine. Back in June 1986 his research was highlighted in BYU Today (a forerunner of BYU Magazine), and the article mentioned evolution. Paul C. Richards, a former director of Public Communications at BYU, recalled a letter that the university received in response.

I am not only embarrassed but concerned almost to anger that our church university would support the activities and theories such as those of Dr. Jack W. Sites whose article appears on page 15. His work is funded in part by the church, meaning by the members' tithing.

How can an activity antagonistic to the gospel truth of reproduction only after its own kind, as well as the very clear teaching of our Latter-Day Prophets...be sanctioned by BYU.
The editor responded with a polite and somewhat conciliatory letter. Unsatisfied, the complainant responded with a letter containing the usual arguments of, creation took 6,000 years, no death before the Fall, and reproduction of life-forms after their own kind.
Truth is truth, whether simplistic and perhaps naive to "the world" or not. Why shouldn't Dr. Sites and BYU rather be using our church resources to disprove evolution?
The writer also sent a letter to the president of the Church (Ezra Taft Benson).
Since I cannot understand, accept, nor resolve in my mind what BYU is doing in this area, my Priesthood leader, not understanding it either, suggested I write to you.... How can BYU conduct research to prove speciation through "evolution" when the scriptures and our Prophets and Apostles teach that these are erroneous philosophies of men?

President, I thoroughly support the inspired leadership of the Church by yourself and all general authorities.
Although there may have been others, Richards only remembered complaints from this one individual.

Reference:

Paul C. Richards, "Does Paying Tithing Make You a Voting Shareholder? Brigham Young University's Worldwide Board of Trustees," Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought, Volume 26, Number 3, Fall 1993.



Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP