Tuesday, April 24, 2007

What Einstein Said

Sunday, in sacrament meeting, a speaker related a story about an atheist college professor that belittled a student's belief in God because, the professor said, God must have created evil. Another student then replied with a line of questioning that led to the embarrassment of the professor. That other student, we were told, was Albert Einstein.

That sounded fishy to me because (i) the story was sent to the speaker by a friend (presumably via email), (ii) although I haven't read a lot about Einstein, my understanding was that he did not believe in a personal God, and (iii) difficult issues like the problem of evil are rarely solved by a couple of simple witty arguments.

As expected, the top hits on my Google search say that the story is a modern legend (here and here). The second site claims that Einstein's name was appended to an already circulating story in about 2004. Of course, if anybody can show that the story is authentic, I would be interested.

Speaking of spurious Einstein quotes, there is one circulating to the effect that Einstein thought James Talmage was one of the smartest men alive. This is also not true [1].

Here is an authentic quote from Einstein, that I like.

The Albert Einstein Memorial Statue is located in Washington D.C., at the National Academy of Sciences. I have visited the monument.



The statue is accompanied by this quotation (among others):

The right to search for truth implies also a duty; one must not conceal any part of what one has recognized to be true.




1. The Essential James E. Talmage - I don't own this book, but my recollection is that the story is debunked in it.


Continue reading...

Friday, April 13, 2007

Premortal Spirit Speculation

It's been slow here lately because, in my real life, things are moving quickly. I've landed a job that I am excited about, so it's time to sell the house and begin relocating. Speaking of moving, much of our stuff will be moving into storage tomorrow because we hope to put our house on the market at the end of next week. I'm sure you can see why blogging must take a backseat to life for a while.

Having said that, let me draw your attention to "Premortal Spirits: Implications for Cloning, Abortion, Evolution, and Extinction", by Kent Condie. This essay was published in Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought last year, but I don't remember it getting any discussion in the bloggernacle.

Premortality is a distinctive and important LDS doctrine, but we really don't know much about it. This essay represents Dr. Condie's attempt to make sense of the spirit world in light of some things we know about the natural world, as well as to solve some theological dilemmas. Dr. Condie's idea is basically summarized as follows:

...a premortal spirit is really a nonspecific spirit in that it is not intended for any specific organism but can be placed in any one of many different organisms in a similar taxonomic group at approximately the same degree of complexity within this group.

Although it is clearly an exercise in speculation, I think the essay is worth considering. I am not persuaded by all of the particulars--in fact, several times I thought a premise was being rush past too quickly--but if the knowedge we have gained from science regarding the natural world is any indication, many of our perceptions of the premortal world are likely to be overthrown when facts are made known. It makes sense to me that spirit creation (whatever it is) is a more elastic and automatic process than we usually think of.

As I indicated above, some of the reasoning proceeds a little too quickly, I think. And I didn't like references to his hypothesis being testable. Sure, they can be compared to the scriptures, but they certainly are not testable scientifically[1]. Also, I squirmed a little at references to evolution as a "random" process. There are certainly random components to it, and I see what he's getting at, but evolution is more than chance. But speaking of chance, I would have included some discussion of Mendelian genetics and conception. After all, chance plays a large role in reproduction. Unless the times and seasons of each gamete are known and ordained by God (something I find highly doubtful), there has to be some flexibility in the correspondence between the physical and spiritual.

Speculative though it may be, Dr. Condie's essay is food for thought.



1. Yes, I know he doesn't mean "scientifically testable," but as much as possible, I would like to keep religion separate from pseudo-science.

Continue reading...

Thursday, April 05, 2007

The Marginalization of Earth

Tuesday's post of the picture of galaxy NGC 1672 reminded me of a quote from The Whole Shebang: A State-of-the-Universe(s) Report, by Timothy Ferris, that I've been intending to post. So now seems like as good a time as any.

The Local Group stands toward the outer edge of a large cloud, variously called the Local or Coma-Sculptor cloud, which itself lies toward the edge of the Virgo Supercluster. So once again we find ourselves on the fringe of things. Not only does the earth not occupy the center of the solar system...and the solar system reside far from the center of the Milky Way galaxy...and the Milky Way galaxy take second place to Andromeda as the dominant spiral of the Local Group, but the Local Group is situated toward the outer limits of the Virgo Supercluster. Cosmography is discomfiting to anthropomorphists.

Continue reading...

Tuesday, April 03, 2007

Hubble: NGC 1672

Hubble’s View of Barred Spiral Galaxy NGC 1672

(click for larger view)

Continue reading...

Monday, April 02, 2007

Book Online: The Search for Harmony

The Search for Harmony: Essays on Science and Mormonism, published by Signature Books, is one of the best single books on science and Mormonism. Though incomplete and a little dated (published in 1993, with many of the articles published much earlier), it contains a number of classic essays and original research articles (some slightly modified from their original published form). I purchased my copy about five years ago, and am glad to have it. The book is now out of print, but Signature Books has now made the contents available online! I previously assembled the essays and articles that were online, but this is a better resource. Kudos to Signature Books!

The Search for Harmony: Essays on Science and Mormonism


(hat-tip to Justin B.)

P.S. I just noticed that Brigham Young University: A House of Faith is also available; I purchased a used copy two years ago. This book contains an extensive chapter on evolution that should not be missed. Kudos again!


Continue reading...

Sunday, March 25, 2007

FARMS: Abraham, Astronomy and Cosmology

FARMS has made the text of one of their books, Astronomy, Papyrus, and Covenant, available online. The book was brought to my attention by Kevin Barney in his BCC post, Kolob as Sirius. Several of the chapters deal with scientific issues, so I'll give a brief summary of what I've read and then add my two cents.



"Astronomy and the Creation in the Book of Abraham" by Michael D. Rhodes and J. Ward Moody.

This chapter takes a concordist view between the scriptures and science. I tend to think that concordism is a mistaken approach (see here and here), but I still found the chapter refreshing to read because it takes the sciences seriously on the age of the earth, death before the fall, and faunal succession. The authors essentially punt on the topics of pre-Adamites and evolution.
Since the authors of this paper have received their advanced degrees in physics and astronomy, with no formal training in biology, we will take the prudent course and let those who are more knowledgeable on the subject deal with evolution.
Good move on their part. Michael Rhodes is a faculty member of the BYU religion department, and taught my Pearl of Great Price course. (I specifically took it from him for the Facsimiles.) His views on evolution are about what you would expect from a BYU religion professor.


"'And I Saw the Stars': The Book of Abraham and Ancient Geocentric Astronomy," by John Gee, William J. Hamblin, Daniel C. Peterson.

This chapter argues that the astronomy revealed to Abraham was from a geocentric perspective. I think they make a pretty good case; they certainly caused me to see some passages in a different light. We often think of the Book of Abraham as being the most science-friendly of the LDS creation accounts, however, paradoxically, there is an apologetic function served in eschewing concordism for the geocentric perspective. Doing so helps to bolster the notion that the Book of Abraham really reflects ancient teachings rather than nineteenth-century views.

In the appendix, the authors write:
We believe that a careful examination of early cosmologies from LDS scriptures revealed within a few years of each other shows a wide range of conflicting astronomical ideas.
I would like for them to expand on that.


"The Creation of Humankind, and Allegory?: A Note on Abraham 5:7, 14–16," Richard D. Draper.

This chapter essentially argues that the Book of Abraham is the most ancient of the creation accounts, and so it (or an earlier source, or God) is responsible for the apparently allegorical nature of the text, rather than Moses.
Genesis, Moses, and Abraham preserve the "official" account of humankind's entrance into the world as revealed by God. He has not seen fit to reveal more. No official statement of the First Presidency or public revelation by church leaders annuls the story as told in the scriptures. Does that force us to accept the account as historically accurate, or is there some room that God himself has given us an allegoric account?
Draper discusses Brigham Young and Parley Pratt as viewing at least parts as allegorical, but one should also add Spencer Kimball and Bruce McConkie.

Interestingly, Draper argues that Joseph Smith never taught anything other than a literal reading of Adam and Eve's creation. In doing so, he is at odds with others who attempt to connect the idea that Adam and Eve were God's children, physically, to Joseph Smith (usually via Moses 6:22).


Some things I disagree with, and others I am unsure of. However I think that these chapters each contain valuable elements for informing discussions of science and scripture in an LDS context.

Continue reading...

Saturday, March 24, 2007

Blogger Triumphant

Yesterday was my dissertation defense. First I gave a 50 min public presentation regarding my work, followed by a Q&A. Then I met privately with my committee for--I guess it was an hour and a half or so. We discussed my work further and they made me dance and roughed me up a little, but in the end they passed me. Then I went to a ward dinner that my wife was in charge of. How Mormon.

It only feels somewhat triumphant; I've heard from others that the experience is anti-climactic. In spite of the fact that I don't want to read through my dissertation for a long time, I have to do some revisions--a couple of which give me a little bit of heartburn. The worst part is definitely over, but it isn't total relief yet. And I don't feel a whole lot smarter yet; maybe that comes when they put the hood on me.

Aside from finishing the revisions, in the next couple of weeks I will finalize my next job (a postdoc). This will all but certainly involve moving, requiring us to sell our house. Along with the efforts to get our house ready to sell, I still have experiments to do so that I can publish some of my latest work. So it's going to be a busy spring.

And here I thought that I would be able to spend all of my time blogging. I guess I'll have to settle for some.

Continue reading...

Sunday, March 18, 2007

Book Received: Man, His Origin and Destiny

I acquired a copy of Joseph Fielding Smith's Man, His Origin and Destiny, and have begun making my way through it. The book has long been out of print (although it is included in Deseret Book's "Gospelink" collection), however used copies are available for a pretty reasonable price.

My copy has the name of a former owner written on a cover page and contains a number of highlights and markings. These markings are predominantly found in chapters primarily devoted to the exposition of doctrine. In addition, strips of what look like newspaper or mail ads have serve as bookmarks in several places. Again, these are in doctrinal chapters and the bookmarks have been in place long enough to stain the pages brownish.

The copyright page contains this handwritten note:

SaVEOR ATONed in the Spirit World[,] Page. 330.
The passage of interest to this person is actually a quotation of Moses 6:54.
Hence came the saying abroad among the people, that the Son of God hath atoned for original guilt, wherein the sins of the parents cannot be answered upon the heads of the children, for they are whole from the foundation of the world. [underlining by previous owner/reader]
It will be interesting to see what other passages stood out to the former owner/reader.

I expect that the book will serve as future bloging material. I have not yet decided how I want to approach it--whether to give chapter summaries and analysis or just point out and respond to tidbits along the way. Maybe something in between. I'm open to suggestions.


Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP