Wednesday, February 22, 2006

Why Did the Chicken Loose Its Teeth?

This news article describes an interesting finding--a mutant chicken growing teeth. The particular mutation is lethal to the developing chicken embryo, but it lives long enough to begin developing teeth.

"They don't make a molar," explains development biologist John Fallon, who oversaw Harris's work. "What they make is this conical, saber-shaped structure that is clearly a tooth. The other animal that has a tooth like that is an alligator."

Previous efforts to produce teeth in chickens had relied on introducing genetic information from mice, resulting in chickens growing mammalian molars. But a chicken's underlying ability to grow teeth derives from a common ancestor with alligators--archosaurs--that is more recent than the one linking birds and mammals. Nevertheless, the underlying genetic mechanism that produces teeth in mice, alligators and mutant chickens remains the same.
I think this little historical bit is also interesting:
In the early 19th century, Saint-Hillaire observed that developing parrots have tiny bumps on their beaks that resemble teeth, something he ascribed to modern animals deriving from more basic primitive forms. But due to his developing battles with Georges Cuvier over evolution, the finding was forgotten until Harris, a graduate student, re-discovered it nearly 200 years later.

The details will need to be teased out, but it appears that birds do not make teeth, not because the deveopmental pathways do not exist, but because the regulation of those pathways has been altered in a manner that prevents tooth development.

(via Pharyngula.)

Continue reading...

Friday, February 17, 2006

Review of At the Water's Edge

In the public debate over evolution few people argue about the occurance of microevolution--it has been so clearly demonstrated that most anti-evolutionists conceed this level of change in species. Much more contentious is the debate over macroevolution--the process that gives rise to major groups. What is the evidence for such transitions, how do they happen, and why? These questions are addressed by Carl Zimmer in his first book, At the Water's Edge.

Continue Reading


Zimmer, a respected science journalist, takes us on a journey from water to land, and back to water again. The first half of the book deals with the transition of water-dwelling lobe-fined fish to terrestrial tetrapods almost 400 million years ago, while the second half describes the origin of cetaceans (whales, dolphins, etc.) around 50 million years ago. There are lessons in history, anatomy, physiology, cladistics, and development that are smoothly explained and easy to take in. These mini-lessons are often set in larger narratives that explain the history and progression of scientific discovery. Sometimes Zimmer takes us out on digs where we get to watch paleontologists at work discovering dramatic examples of transitional fossils.

There are certainly questions still to be answered and this book will not be the last word on the subjects it covers. It is nevertheless a good introduction to the issues at hand. The writing is not all third person; Zimmer's interviews with scientists allow us to hear their perspective in their own words. The book also has a number of illustrations that help to convey concepts and suggest what some of the extinct transitional animals may have looked like. There is also a small glossary to help with some of the scientific terminology.

Read the book--what more can I say?

Continue reading...

Thursday, February 16, 2006

Trouble at NASA

NASA has had a tough couple of weeks in the news. First, a NASA scientist claims that the Bush administration tried to silence him about global warming, then a 24-year old public affairs worker appointed by Bush resigns after allegations that he tried to make scientists add the word "theory" every time the Big Bang was mentioned because of a perceived conflict with religion--and it turned out that he had not graduated from college like his resume said. Then a press release was altered to remove a reference to the sun burning out in five billion years so as not to scare people. (?)

Now there are more reports of political pressure on NASA to tone down findings conflicting with administration policy. New York Times:

Top political appointees in the NASA press office exerted strong pressure during the 2004 presidential campaign to cut the flow of news releases on glaciers, climate, pollution and other earth sciences, public affairs officers at the agency say.

Continue reading...

Elder Oaks, DNA, and the Book of Mormon

The issue of DNA and the Book of Mormon flared up again today thanks to the LA Times. Our own Bloggernacle Times initiated some discussion on the matter. The story prompted the Church to re-release its position:

Continue Reading


The Book of Mormon: Another Testament of Jesus Christ is exactly what it claims to be — a record of God’s dealings with peoples of ancient America and a second witness of the divinity of the Lord Jesus Christ. The strongest witness of the Book of Mormon is to be obtained by living the Christ-centered principles contained in its pages and by praying about its truthfulness.

Recent attacks on the veracity of the Book of Mormon based on DNA evidence are ill considered. Nothing in the Book of Mormon precludes migration into the Americas by peoples of Asiatic origin. The scientific issues relating to DNA, however, are numerous and complex. Those interested in a more detailed analysis of those issues are referred to the resources below. [Links to FARMS publications follow.]


Elder Dallin H. Oaks wrote the following in his book, The Lord's Way:
[The need to develop a testimony from the Holy Ghost and have faith] helps us to understand why the methods of science are not applicable to establishing the truthfulness of the gospel, the fact of the Restoration, or the origin and truth of the Book of Mormon. President Ezra Taft Benson has declared: "It never has been the case, nor is it so now, that the studies of the learned will prove the Book of Mormon true or false. The origin, preparation, translation, and verification of the truth of the Book of Mormon have all been retained in the hands of the Lord."

Some Latter-day Saints have not accepted this reality and are preoccupied with evidences to prove the Book of Mormon...The lack of decisive scientific proofs of scriptural truths does not preclude gospel defenders from couterarguments of that nature. When opponents attack the Church or its doctrines with so-called proofs, loyal defenders will counter with material of a comparable nature to defend. As Elder Neal A. Maxwell has said, "We can be assured that enough plausible, supporting data and external evidence will come forth to prevent scoffers from having a field day with the scriptures, but not enough to remove the requirement of faith." (p. 91-92)
I appreciate the need for spiritual conversion. I distinctly remember meeting a less-active woman on my mission who apparently joined the Church because, in dealing with missionaries, all of her intellectual concerns had been neutralized--what choice did she have but to join? There was apparently no real spiritual conversion though, and she had drifted off into New Age. I doubt she has come back.

On the other hand, (intellectually) living largely in the negative space created by positive findings is not very satisfying to me--eg. recasting the Book of Mormon into a genetically untestable position. The "limited geography theory" notwithstanding, I think we're in for some tough hits for a while--at least until external evidence of a "comparable nature" comes forth (or revelation that adjusts our expectations.) In the meantime I guess we're just going to have to be patient, but let us also be careful. To quote Elder Oaks again, "...truth is better served by silence than by a bad argument."

Continue reading...

Sunday, February 12, 2006

Darwin Day

Charles Darwin's 197th birthday is today. A lot of blogs have commented on it in one way or another--here is a good sampling. (See also the contribution at Dave's Mormon Inquiry.)

My father remembers taking a zoology class at BYU from Duane Jeffery where doughnuts were served on this day.

Continue reading...

Duane Jeffery on SB96

The Salt Lake Tribune published an opinion article by Duane Jeffery regrading Sen. Buttars' bill, SB96. He briefly deals with three claims. I quote the claims below; you'll have to read the article for his answers. (An additional nine Utah scientists signed on to the opinion.)

1. Claim: Since the bill itself does not mention "intelligent design," "divine design" or anything relating to "faith-based interests," the bill is therefore immune to legal challenge.

2. Claim: There are no transitional fossils.

3. Claim: Evolutionists cling to their theory because they don't wish to believe in a Creator.

In addition to his faculty status at BYU, Jeffery is a director for the National Center for Science Education, an organization that defends the teaching of evolution.

Continue reading...

America's Future?

An article in the Los Angeles Times describes the work of Ken Ham, the leader of Answers in Genesis.

Evangelist Ken Ham smiled at the 2,300 elementary students packed into pews, their faces rapt. With dinosaur puppets and silly cartoons, he was training them to reject much of geology, paleontology and evolutionary biology as a sinister tangle of lies.

"Boys and girls," Ham said. If a teacher so much as mentions evolution, or the Big Bang, or an era when dinosaurs ruled the Earth, "you put your hand up and you say, 'Excuse me, were you there?' Can you remember that?"
The completion of that line of argument is that God was there, and we have his account in the Bible. It is a slick argument with subtle assumptions that pits man against God.

Continue Reading


He urges students to offer creationist critiques of their textbooks, parents to take on science museum docents, professionals to raise the subject with colleagues. If Ham has done his job well, his acolytes will ask enough pointed questions — and set forth enough persuasive arguments — to shake the doctrine of Darwin.
Unfortunately the persuasive arguments are actually persuasive propaganda based on sound bites and distortion.
When pastors dismiss the creation account as a fable, he says, they give their flock license to disregard the Bible's moral teachings as well. He shows his audiences a graphic that places the theory of evolution at the root of all social ills: abortion, divorce, racism, gay marriage, store clerks who say "Happy Holidays" instead of "Merry Christmas."
Nice--it's all neat and tidy. Evolution the root of racism? Oh, I see. All those years of slavery and segregation owe their existence to a book published in 1859. If only there had been literalist fundamentalists in the South to talk some sense into people.

You can see Ham at work here.

(via Erying-L)

Continue reading...

Thursday, February 09, 2006

Formatting and Recent Comments

I downloaded Firefox and I seem to have the formatting fixed. Please let me know if it is not fixed in your browser. I can't guarantee I'll be able to fix it, but I'll try.

As I mentioned before, I've added a "recent comments" feature to my right sidebar. I'm basically using the blogger hack, which lists the comments in each post with the most recent comment on the bottom. It's not quite how I would like it, but it seems to serve its purpose, and it's not too shabby.

I'm open to suggestions. Hate it? Like It? Alter it?

Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP