The issue of DNA and the Book of Mormon flared up again today thanks to the LA Times. Our own Bloggernacle Times initiated some discussion on the matter. The story prompted the Church to re-release its position:
Continue Reading
The Book of Mormon: Another Testament of Jesus Christ is exactly what it claims to be — a record of God’s dealings with peoples of ancient America and a second witness of the divinity of the Lord Jesus Christ. The strongest witness of the Book of Mormon is to be obtained by living the Christ-centered principles contained in its pages and by praying about its truthfulness.
Recent attacks on the veracity of the Book of Mormon based on DNA evidence are ill considered. Nothing in the Book of Mormon precludes migration into the Americas by peoples of Asiatic origin. The scientific issues relating to DNA, however, are numerous and complex. Those interested in a more detailed analysis of those issues are referred to the resources below. [Links to FARMS publications follow.]
Elder Dallin H. Oaks wrote the following in his book, The Lord's Way:[The need to develop a testimony from the Holy Ghost and have faith] helps us to understand why the methods of science are not applicable to establishing the truthfulness of the gospel, the fact of the Restoration, or the origin and truth of the Book of Mormon. President Ezra Taft Benson has declared: "It never has been the case, nor is it so now, that the studies of the learned will prove the Book of Mormon true or false. The origin, preparation, translation, and verification of the truth of the Book of Mormon have all been retained in the hands of the Lord."
Some Latter-day Saints have not accepted this reality and are preoccupied with evidences to prove the Book of Mormon...The lack of decisive scientific proofs of scriptural truths does not preclude gospel defenders from couterarguments of that nature. When opponents attack the Church or its doctrines with so-called proofs, loyal defenders will counter with material of a comparable nature to defend. As Elder Neal A. Maxwell has said, "We can be assured that enough plausible, supporting data and external evidence will come forth to prevent scoffers from having a field day with the scriptures, but not enough to remove the requirement of faith." (p. 91-92)
I appreciate the need for spiritual conversion. I distinctly remember meeting a less-active woman on my mission who apparently joined the Church because, in dealing with missionaries, all of her intellectual concerns had been neutralized--what choice did she have but to join? There was apparently no real spiritual conversion though, and she had drifted off into New Age. I doubt she has come back.
On the other hand, (intellectually) living largely in the negative space created by positive findings is not very satisfying to me--eg. recasting the Book of Mormon into a genetically untestable position. The "limited geography theory" notwithstanding, I think we're in for some tough hits for a while--at least until external evidence of a "comparable nature" comes forth (or revelation that adjusts our expectations.) In the meantime I guess we're just going to have to be patient, but let us also be careful. To quote Elder Oaks again, "...truth is better served by silence than by a bad argument."
Continue reading...