Wednesday, March 30, 2005

The Birds and the Snails

Carl Zimmer has a post discussing the evolution of love darts in snails. You may not be particularly interested in the sexual practices of snails--I can understand that. But you should read the post anyway because it is an interesting example of an evolutionary sexual arms race.

Continue reading...

Tuesday, March 29, 2005

With the Discovery Institute, Who Needs Cable?

I don't have cable, so I miss out on such entertainment as the Discovery Channel. I do have internet access so I get a different kind of entertainment--the Discovery Institute. Their Center for Science and Culture operates a blog, which appears to mainly be used for complaining about media coverage of intelligent design "theory." One of their consistent complaints of late is that they are being unfairly and inaccurately lumped together with creationists. They know that it will be difficult for them to make any scientific or legal headway as long as they are associated with creationism.

Continue Reading


Now I can appreciate the challenge of trying to have others define your beliefs as you define them. I recognize that it must be frustrating to always be catagorized with a movement you are trying to distance yourself from. Recently one exasperated ID advocate challenged anybody to find a leading ID intellectual that did not accept the Big Bang or the age of the earth. The Panda's Thumb accepted the challenge, with humorous results. (Read the whole thing--including comments.)

The latest from the CSC is a complaint about how they were portrayed in a segment of PBS's The Newshour with Jim Lehrer. The post tries to draw a clear distinction between creationism and intelligent design.

The theory of intelligent design and creationism are different. Let me make this point very clear:

Creation Science is defined by the following six tenets, taken together:

-The universe, energy and life were created from nothing
-Mutations and [natural] selection cannot bring about the development of all living things from a single organism.
-The earth is young, in the range of 10,000 years or so.
-Humans and apes have different ancestries.
-Created kinds of plants and organisms can vary only within fixed limits.
-Earth's geology can be explained by catastrophic events, primarily a worldwide flood.

Intelligent design on the other hand, involves only two basic sceintific assumptions:

-Intelligent causes exist for origins of life.
-These cause[s] can be empirically detected.

First let's take the assumptions of ID. The first one is not very specific. Are we only talking about ID vs abiogenesis, or does the origin of any species fall under ID? The second assumption is really a hypothesis--one that is yet to be demonstrated convincingly. Now, I thought that the main way of detecting design was to find irreducibly complex systems. But earlier in the post there is talk of molecular machines. So is any and every enzyme without a clear precursor designed? After all, enzymes do some pretty specific chemical reactions.

Now what is interesting to me is that the tenets of creationism were not denied here. In fact, ID proponents hold to several of them. You don't have to search hard to find ID support for the second, fourth, and fifth creationist tenets. Not only are some of these tenets necessary assumptions for many of their arguments, but ID advocates often argue them explicitly.

They try hard to distance themselves from religious conservatives:
The story moves quickly to the typical stereotype of religion vs. science saying that is an issue mostly focused on religion and faith. To bolster that they have lots of high school students who express their doubts about Darwinism in overtly religious terms. The story leaves no doubt that evolution is under an attack led "mostly by religious conservatives." Interesting. David Berlinski would be surprised to hear that. So would Stanley Salthe. Or, Giuseppe Sermonti. Or any number of other non-religious scientists skeptical of the claims of Darwinism. Contrary to the Newshour's premise at the outset, doubting Darwinism is not solely a consequence of religious belief.


The interesting thing here is that the Scientific Dissent From Darwinism document is subject of the link. It is portrayed here as though the scientists on the list are non-religious. While some may be, many (probably most) certainly are religious. I once picked an actual biologist on the list, at random, and looked to see at what institution they were a professor. Answer: A Christian college.

Finally, the reason such superficial treatment of ID is given in the piece is: "because the issue for the media isn't about the science involved, it's about making this a culture war issue." Ooohhh, I see. So it's all about the science for the Discovery Institute. In that case, they may want to quit putting out books like Defeating Darwinism where the call to culture war is blatant and the attack on evolutionary theory is unabashedly about its conflict with Christianity.

With entertainment like this, why should I want cable?

Note: be sure to see update in comments.

Continue reading...

Publishing Pecking Order

My last post on dinosaur flesh reminded me that many of you are not familiar with scientific literature so I thought I would give a quick tutorial. First there is a distinction between popular science publications and primary journals. They are not necessarily easy to differentiate by name. For example, Scientific American is a popular science magazine--it is geared toward the educated lay person. It does not publish actual research, though it may report on research published elsewhere in the primary literature.

Primary research articles are contained in innumerable journals. This is where the nuts and bolts of research are reported. Each discipline has its own hierarchy of journals. Some journals are bread-and-butter journals. However there are several publications that form a sort of hub. Nature Magazine, Science Magazine, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)--are all prestigious journals (probably in that order) that cover a wide range of scientific disciplines. Nature has several more specialized journals that are also prestigious. Some people go their whole career without publishing in one of these journals. Really good researchers publish there repeatedly. Now this doesn't mean that every article in these publications is flawless--you can find bad papers in any journal. But when you see the names Nature, Science, or PNAS, a little flag should go up and remind you that these are journals that are pretty selective in what they publish.

Continue reading...

T. rex Flesh Recovered

I'm late to blog on this but if you are not aware of it already, the recent issue of Science Magazine has a paper discussing the recovery of soft tissue from a Tyrannosauraus rex fossil. The tissue was taken from a femur and demineralized which resulted in tissue that is stretchy and appears to have pretty good preservation of microscopic structures. My understanding is that there is a slim to none chance of obtaining any genetic material. Nevertheless it is interesting and amazing. You can read a little more about it at Scientific American.com.

Continue reading...

Monday, March 28, 2005

Polygamy is Pretty Mild By Comparison

They're talking about polygamy over at BCC and T&S. It's certainly a topic that raises many questions with few real answers. Compared to what's going on elsewhere, however, it's pretty mild.

Purely by coincidence I've been reading about the evolution of sex in Evolution: The Triumph of an Idea, by Carl Zimmer. It's a really good book and I plan to review it here when I finish it. Anyway, when it comes to sex and reproduction, it's a strange and twisted world out there. If you view nature as fundamentally fallen and antithetical to God's plan and purposes, then this will not suprise you. If, on the other hand, you view nature as more or less an expression of God's glory and purposes--well the puritan in you may be shocked.

I'll get into more details later. But for now you can read a little about Bonobos, a type of chimpanzee. (I'm just giving you the article link. What internal links you follow are your own business.)

To get ahead of myself, I'll pose a question: To whatever extent polygamy operates in time or eternity, is God trying to effect (yes, I mean effect, not affect) a biological purpose?

Continue reading...

Thursday, March 24, 2005

Approach to the Masculine

[This topic has explosive potential, but I wan to raise it anyway. My purpose is to ask questions rather than give answers. Nothing in my post should be interpreted as pertaining to specific situations and circumstances, nor should it be interpreted as excusing sin or casting judgment.]

Recently my bishop decided that we would devote one of our priesthood lessons to Pres. Hinckely's talk from last conference dealing with p0rn0graphy. The Relief Society, instead, were to use the 13th Article of Faith as the basis for their lesson. I couldn't help but wonder if women should be excused from discussions of this issue. (None of this should be construed as criticism of my bishop--I think he does a great job.)

Continue Reading


This approach seems to carry a subtle message: sexual interest is a male problem and it's wrong. ("We're sorry, dear sisters, that your husbands are so carnal and devilish. Their interest in sexuality clearly runs counter to the gospel message. We're whacking them on the knuckles for it again--hopefully they'll get the message. You sisters are as pure as spring flowers and we hope you'll continue in your virtuous ways.")

Now I don't dispute that we men need some whacks to the knuckles from time to time. Some need them often. But I want to dig a little deeper. What is it about the male brain that makes it so susceptible to this problem? Is the circuitry in the brain responsible for this a product of pathology and only detrimental, or is it possible that it can be used in good ways? What things can wives do to help bind their husbands to them?

Pres. Hinckley's talk last conference included part of a letter from a woman whose husband had this addiction. She said, "All I ever wanted was to feel cherished and treated with the smallest of pleasantries . . . instead of being treated like some kind of chattel." Getting men to understand and remember what women want is a huge challenge. Maybe we should talk about it in our lessons more. But is there something that men want that is going unfulfilled and contributes their development of this problem?

In The Miracle of Forgiveness, Pres. Kimball makes the point that Jesus recognized that sin was often a symptom of deeper unmet needs. Of course sex is part of the issue, but it is more than that. Emotional and intimacy issues are involved. Can these be addressed in a way that minimizes, as much as possible, the risk for men? Is it possible that in trying to get men to behave, masculinity has been denigrated in the process and as a result neither men nor women understand what the legitimate needs of men are? Yes, men need to exercise self-control, but are there things that women need to do? If there are, should they hear about it in Relief Society?

I don't know what light science (both the hard and social) can shed on the problem, but to the extent that there is any I think we ought to discuss it. Let's understand what makes us tick. LDS Social Services has professional counseling for this addiction, but the only real advice that most of us hear is "don't touch it." It seems to me that the more men and women understand what's going on in the psychological roots, the better they can address this issue.

Continue reading...

IMAX: Culture Wars in 3-D

I'm late getting to this but this news article reminded me of the issue. Apparently there are IMAX theaters in the south that have decided not to show the film "Volcanoes of the Deep Sea." The reason is that they are afraid that references to evolution in the film will result in poor ticket sales.

I haven't seen the film so I don't know how extensive the discussion of evolution is. However the reason for the reference is that there are microbes that live in some of the most inhospitable places on earth, including deep sea vents. Some scientists think that given the inhospitable place the earth used to be, maybe these microbes hold clues to the development of life on earth. I guess this drew complaints from test-screening audiences.

Well, what can I say? It's the free-market system at work. I can't blame the theater owners for worrying about their bottom line. At least the public schools still teach science...

Continue reading...

Tuesday, March 22, 2005

Adam and Eve: How?

[The following is a cross-post from Mormons and Evolution.]

The year following the First Presidency's statement, "Origin of Man," the following was published in the Improvement Era, April 1910:

Origin of Man.-"In just what manner did the mortal bodies of Adam and Eve come into existence on this earth?" This question comes from several High Priests' quorums.

Continue Reading


Of course, all are familiar with the statements in Genesis 1:26, 27; 2: 7; also in the Book of Moses, Pearl of Great Price, 2: 27; and in the Book of-Abraham 5:7. The latter statement reads: "And the Gods formed man from the dust of the ground, and took his spirit (that is, the man's spirit) and put it into him; and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and man became a living soul." These are the authentic statements of the scriptures, ancient and modern, and it is best to rest with these, until the Lord shall see fit to give more light on the subject. Whether the mortal bodies of man evolved in natural processes to present perfection, through the direction and power of God; whether the first parents of our generations, Adam and Eve, were transplanted from another sphere, with immortal tabernacles, which became corrupted through sin and the partaking of natural foods, in the process of time; whether they were born here in mortality, as other mortals have been, are questions not fully answered in the revealed word of God. For helpful discussion of the subject, see IMPROVEMENT ERA, Vol. XI, August 1908, No. 10, page 778, article, "Creation and Growth of Adam;" also article by the First Presidency, "Origin of Man," Vol. XIII, No. 1, page 75, 1909. [emphasis added]

For more discussion about this passage see Duane Jeffery's article here.

Since Joseph F. Smith was one of two editors at the time, this passage has been attributed to him and although it probably did not reflect his own opinion it shows that no specific creation process was officially endorsed. Although the creation of Adam and Eve has been the topic of continued discussion in the years since this statement, the lack of official clarification has been maintained.

Some cite certain scriputures was well as statements by Joseph Smith, Brigham Young, and others, to argue that Adam (and presumably Eve) was physically born of Heavenly Parents and later became mortal in the manner described in Genesis. This would seem to contradict the scriptural teaching that Jesus was the only physical son of God. Elder Bruce R. McConkie resolves the contradiction this way:
Father Adam, the first man, is also a son of God (Luke 3:38; Moses 6:22), a fact that does not change the great truth that Christ is the Only Begotten in the flesh, for Adam's entrance into this world was in immortality. He came here before death had its beginning, with its consequent mortal or flesh-status of existence. ("Son of God" in Mormon Doctrine)

However Stephens, Meldrum, and Peterson in their book, Evolution and Mormonism, rightly point out that the phrase "Only Begotten in the flesh" is not contained in the scriptures.

For some, the idea of a divine origin of our physical bodies presents a significant impediment to accepting the concept of common descent as being applied to mankind. And yet investigation of the anatomy, genome, and development of humans does not reveal any marks of special creation. Rather they strongly support that we and other primates have common ancestors. Stephens et al. write:
The unsupported notion that our physical bodies must be in some way special, i.e., apart from nature, and directly descended from God's immortal body is a major source of conflict with evolution theory. There are no scientific data to support any of these supernatural hypotheses; in fact, the body of accumulated scientific evidence stands against them. If our physical bodies are in some way "special," in that our ancestors' physical bodies came from some other planet or directly from God, then we could predict that the physical nature of our bodies should be in some way different from those of life forms originating on this earth.

Regardless of whether Adam was a literal son of God or was "transplated from another sphere," the basic conflict with science remains the same. Whatever the truth is regarding the origin of our physical bodies, it must explain the evidence that we see for common descent. The following are two hypothetical scenarios that might resolve this discrepancy:

1. Stephens, Meldrum, and Peterson propose a theistic evolution scenario where Adam and Eve's physical bodies were the result of hominid evolution. However, at some point after their spirits were placed into their physical bodies, they became immortal by partaking of the fruit of the tree of life in the Garden of Eden. (Perhaps they experienced something similar to translation.) This is the immortality that they later fell from. Variations on this scenario are possible, including the geographical and organismal range involved.

2. Another scenario might be a compromise between theistic evolution and the idea of a divine origin of our physical bodies. Perhaps Adam and Eve were born (physically) of Heavenly Parents. Their Fall entailed taking on the physiology of the most similar hominids by some sort of tissue transplantaion. Although I am not sure whether it can be reliably traced to Joseph Smith (I cannot trace it past Joseph Fielding Smith), a common doctrinal concept is that Adam and Eve did not have blood while in the Garden of Eden. Since blood is derived from bone marrow, perhaps something like a bone marrow transplant occured where the donors were the most similar mortal (non-children of God) hominids. Certainly this scenario is highly speculative, but something like it allows for our close genetic relationship to other animals while retaining our spiritual and physical relationship with God. Adam and Eve thus fell by taking mortal physiology and genetics into their bodies, and our relationship to other animals is therefore a partial illusion.

Comment at Mormons and Evolution

Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP