Thursday, June 01, 2017

On Paris and Tribal Politics

I don't have much to say about President Trump's announcement today that the U.S. will pull out of the Paris climate agreement. It's certainly not surprising. It was a campaign pledge, and one that he could easily keep. Plus, it's another easy way for him to feel superior to Obama. Thus, the urging of many leading businesses to stick with it was not enough to change his mind. Trump is going to be Trump, and this decision is frankly not at the top of my list of political worries these days.

On the broader issue of climate change, I think Jonathan Chait is basically right.

The dominant spirit of conservative thought — or, more precisely, verbal gestures that seek to resemble thought — is not even skepticism but a trolling impulse. The aim is not so much to reason toward a policy conservatives would favor as to pierce the liberal claim to the moral high ground....

[The predominant conservative argument on climate change] contains a defiant refusal to take the policy questions seriously, combined with a gleeful reproach of the urgency with which liberals view the issue. A crude tribalistic impulse overrides any reckoning with the problem. The proximate issue in conservative minds is not climate change itself but the fact that liberals are concerned about all these things. Disintegrating ice shelves, extinctions, or droughts are abstractions.
Let me provide one modest supporting example: Back in 2009 on this very blog, I highlighted the following quote from Rush Limbaugh about climate change.
The whole thing's made up. And the reason I know it is because liberals are behind it. When they're pushing something, folks, it's always bogus.
If that's not the driving sentiment behind current conservative politics, I don't know what is. This mindset, it seems to me, has spread far beyond climate change, and is manifested by the increasing dismissal of experts, outside of conservative-approved sources, on a variety of topics (not to mention the propensity of conservatives to turn against their own policies when adopted by Democrats).

As a young Limbaugh-listening lad in the 1990s, I believed that Republicans were the party of smart policies. Whatever the truth of that proposition back then, for my money the party has increasingly become regressive, selfish, angry, and afraid of the future. (There are exceptions, of course.) I'm not sure what the driving reason for this is, though I am certainly not the first to suspect that the consumption for hours a day of conservative media that constantly tells people that they are being victimized is a big factor.

Donald Trump will not be the president forever, and many commentators see the trend of greening the economy (and the death of coal) as inevitable. The larger questions in my mind are how long conservative politics will be driven by tribalism combined with a sense of grievance, and how long will it be a winning combination?



4 comments:

Ardis,  6/01/2017 10:41:00 PM  

We are become a reproach to our neighbours, a scorn and derision to them that are round about us. How long, LORD? wilt thou be angry for ever? shall thy jealousy burn like fire? Pour out thy wrath upon the heathen that have not known thee, and upon the kingdoms that have not called upon thy name. For they have devoured Jacob, and laid waste his dwelling place.

Anonymous,  6/06/2017 12:02:00 PM  

You nailed it. There is no such thing as conservative thought these days. After eight years of simply opposing anything Obama proposed, the GOP has forgotten that there is such a thing as intellectual rigor, facts, real lives that are affected by policy, and a real earth that, yes, can be affected by what we humans do. Republicanism has turned into empty sloganeering, listening to voices in the conservative echo chamber, and hatred of both government and anyone who dares suggest that it can be a tool to accomplish good in the world (in other words, liberals).

What lengths will the Republicans go to to implement their "ideology," which can be defined in three words: enrich the wealthy?

Clark Goble,  6/13/2017 06:59:00 PM  

There is still conservatism, but the right wing entertainment establishment makes it very hard to get the conservative message out. Conservatism has become defined not in terms of the different conservative traditions like Hayek, Kirk, Reagan or Burke. Rather conservatism has been redefined as being against liberals. That's why Trump, a lifelong Democrat who has espoused no conservative principles and whose political career developed out of trolling Obama over a fabricated birth certificate "scandal." It's completely depressing for people who espouse thoughtful conservative ideas to see what has happened.

It's starting to happen on the left as well with a faux-populism divorced from facts. When I point this out they are convinced it's just a Republican problem. But to me it's a broader problem besetting the west in general due to being more focused on ones enemies or out-group than ideas as such. So ironically the opposition to Trump, which is so easy to embrace, in some ways lays the very seeds of more Trump like figures appearing.

Jared*,  6/15/2017 07:36:00 PM  

There are certainly elements of the left that are problematic, but I'm not ready to concede that it's as much of a problem as on the right. Otherwise I think I mostly agree with you, though I'm not so sure about opposition to Trump leading to more Trumps.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP