Before Richard Dawkins, There Was Orson Pratt
At By Common Consent, writer WVS shared an excerpt of Wilford Woodruff's journal, which captured a speculative explanation that Orson Pratt gave for the origin of God. After referring to the trial-and-error process that chemists often go through, Pratt said:
An eternity was filled as it were with particules of intelligences who had their agency, two of these particles in the process of time might have joined their interest together exchanged ideas & found by persueing this course that they gained double strength to what one particle of intelligence would have & afterwards were joined by other particles & continued untill they organized a combination or body though through a long process...Pratt's process is that of an individual advancing in organization. But if you look at it from a slightly different angle and apply his process to populations, then you're not very far from 'the replicators' in Richard Dawkins' The Selfish Gene. (The 'replicators' chapter defies a concise summary quote, so you'll just need to click through and read it.)
This all reminds me of something that Terryl Givens recently wrote [1]:
Mormons ironically find an unlikely (and surely unwilling) ally in the arch-atheist Richard Dawkins. In his controversial critique of religion, he wrote that: “Any creative intelligence of sufficient complexity to design anything comes into existence only at the end product of an extended process of gradual evolution.” Elaborating this point, he said thatyou have to have a gradual slow incremental process [to explain an eye or a brain] and by the very same token, God would have to have the same kind of explanation. … God indeed can’t have just happened. If there are Gods in the universe, they must be the end product of slow incremental processes. If there are beings in the universe that we would treat as Gods, … that we would worship … as gods, then they must have come about by an incremental process, gradually.
It's fun when the 'new atheism' sounds like the old Mormonism!
Notes:
1. Givens, Terryl L. (2014). Wrestling the Angel: The Foundations of Mormon Thought: Cosmos, God, Humanity (p. 216).

7 comments:
Of course Pratt's atoms were intelligent whereas Dawkin's replicators are ruled by efficient causation.
I just recently got Given's book. It's much better than I expected. I'd argue it's among the best books of Mormon theology I've read. It's not as detailed as Blake's stuff but does an amazing job in terms of breadth yet somehow remaining terse. Very well done.
Yes, of course. But even today it's amazing to think that a polymerase can replicate nucleic acid--and sometimes proof-read it too. It's all chemistry and physics, but to the man on the street is sure seems like intelligence (and that's putting aside entirely the issue of intelligent design). Given the infancy of chemistry and physics at the time, it's not surprising to me that Pratt and his brethren thought in terms of intelligence.
A horrible comparison. Dawkins was doing science. Pratt was not.
Dawkins was doing science. Pratt was not.
Yes, but so what?
The assertion that humanity has an understanding of chemistry or physics at all is problematic in light of the discovery of non-local particles. There is conflict between Newtonian physics, the general theory of relativity and the implications of non-local particles. Consequently, humanity's understanding and conception of the universe and physics is incorrect.
What that understanding needs to be replaced with is a harder question to answer. But it may have something to do with Dr. Bohm's and Pribram's work regarding a theory of a holographic universe. The implications could unify the views both Dawkin and Pratt.
Given the infancy of chemistry and physics at the time, it's not surprising to me that Pratt and his brethren thought in terms of intelligence.
I've become convinced that Pratt probably was influenced by Emerson and likely loose neoplatonism. He may also have been exposed to Leibniz although that's perhaps a harder sell. So I'm not sure it makes sense to say they thought in terms of intelligence. Remember the Pratts start off with a neoplatonic emanation theory of creation of spirits until the "all spirit is matter" revelation. So I think they start with intelligence and then slowly merge Priestly's ideas of atoms into it.
Anonymous non-locality is but one of three interpretations. It'd definitely the one I favor but it's not the only one. In any case even with non-locality you don't get FTL information flow so I don't think that's the problem between QM and GR. Rather the problem is simply quantizing gravity in a full sense.
There's of course problems with Newton, but Newton's physics didn't really address E&M at all (thus Maxwell). And of course it didn't deal with QM and thus the basics of chemistry either. But I think we know chemistry pretty well at this stage. Physics we have some huge gaps in, of course. No explanation of dark matter/energy and no quantum gravity.
Post a Comment