Friday, January 16, 2015

NASA: 2014 Hottest Year on Record

NASA and NOAA have officially declared 2014 as the warmest year on record. This in spite of parts of the United States being colder than usual, and the lack of El Niño. Here is the NASA temperature record with El Niño-La Niña cycles shown:


And here is the difference from average for 2014. Did you know that part of the U.S. can be cool while most of the rest of the planet is warmer than usual? I know it sounds crazy, but it's true!


Think about this for a second and let it sink in. That blue spot over the eastern U.S. is what makes people say, "What ever happened to global warming?" It's like residents of Detroit wondering what happened to global population growth.


6 comments:

rameumptom,  1/17/2015 07:15:00 PM  

And yet I'm troubled by the models they use to forecast global warming. Yes, it is the warmest on record, but is only rising slightly. The models predict a much greater rise in temperature, which suggests we need better models. It doesn't make sense to make changes based on models that do not work. Instead, the actual changes show we may have more time than the models suggest

Matt Thorley,  1/19/2015 02:14:00 PM  

Jared,

As you are no doubt aware, the surface temperature record significantly disagrees with the satellite data sets. The NOAA NCDC and NASA GISS land based data sets show the mean global temperature for 2014 to be about 0.02 degrees Celsius higher than 2010, which is very slightly higher than 2005. However, all of these variances are well within the margin of error, so the only truly honest statement is that 2014 roughly tied for the hottest year on record according to these two data sets.

According to the RSS AMSU satellite data set there is no question that 1998 was 0.3 degrees Celsius hotter than 2014, and that variance is greater than the margin of error, so there is little doubt that 2014 was not the hottest year according to that data set. The satellite data set only contains 38 years of data, but over the past 18 years there has been no statistically significant increase in global mean temperature.

When Gavin Schmidt (the head climate guy at NASA) announced that 2014 was the hottest year on record he included a little table showing the probabilities that 2014 was the hottest year according to the two land based data sets. In the NOAA set the probability was 48%, and in the NASA set the probability was 38%, so if I did my math correctly, that means that there was a 52% or 62% probability that 2014 was not the hottest year on record. So if by their own data there is a better than 50% probability that 2014 was not the hottest year, and all these variances are meaningless because they are within the margin of error, why did Gavin Schmidt even hold a news conference?

The satellite system was developed specifically to be a more accurate method of recoding global temperature. It avoids some of the problems with land based records such as heat islands created by human development and the fact the 70% of the earth is covered by water. Now 38 years isn’t a lot of time on a global scale, but the 18 year and growing pause in global temperature increase is becoming more and more significant. This announcement that 2014 was the hottest year on record is just foolishness. Why are you perpetuating this foolishness.?

Jared*,  1/19/2015 06:46:00 PM  

Matt,

I believe you have misinterpreted the statistics in the table (page 5). Each column basically gives comparative odds, where the years are compared to one another. Let's take the NOAA numbers. Imagine that the numbers represent Olympic swimmers rather than years. Swimmer #2014 has a 48% chance to win. I suppose you could reason that there is therefore a 52% chance that he will lose, but you can only bet on one swimmer. Who would you bet on instead? In other words, 2014 is 2.6X as likely to win as 2010 by NOAA's ranking, and 1.6X by NASA's ranking.

Matt Thorley,  1/19/2015 07:22:00 PM  

Jared,

I just wouldn’t bet, because I don’t care swimming. I’m sure the swimmers care and you may care, and that is certainly your right, but if I’m not interested I shouldn’t be forced to place a bet. You and the swimmers knock yourself out, but don’t force me to participate in your silly pass time.

Now what about the headline? Do you really think it was appropriate to declare 2014 the hottest year on record given that the difference in the land based data sets was within the margin of error, and the satellite data set shows that 2014 was clearly not the hottest.? Wouldn’t it be more accurate to say that the land based data sets were not definitive and the satellite data set continued to show an 18 year pause?

Jared*,  1/19/2015 08:59:00 PM  

For someone who hates swimming, you sure hang around the pool a lot. No one is forcing you to pay attention.

I think Gavin Schmidt is plenty smart. It may not be to your taste, but given the feeding frenzy the topic engenders, I doubt NASA and NOAA would have staked their claim if they couldn't back it up.

Speaking of which, Gavin says that the satellites are sensitive to El Nino--which helps explain why 1998 looms so large in their data sets since it was a large El Nino year. When the El Nino contribution is removed, one of the satellites agrees that 2014 is hottest. I'm sure that's all cooking the books for you, but there it is.

But I have to say that playing up the difference between the surface and satellite data sets brings on deja vu. In the late 90s-early 2000s, there was a lot of hay made over disagreement between them. Guess which one turned out to be right?

Matt Thorley,  1/21/2015 07:22:00 PM  

Jared,

As I’ve said before, the only reason I hang around the pool is because you guys keep talking about using the heavy hand of government regulation to make us all swimmers whether we want to or not. As long as it’s just pool side conversation among you scientists I’m perfectly happy to ignore you, but if you want to use politics or economics to compel us all to become swimmers then I have a dog in that fight.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP