Facts and Authority
The Crucible of Doubt, by Terryl and Fiona Givens, contains this quote from Austin Farrer that I liked and thought I would pass along:
Facts are not determined by authority. Authority can make law to be law; authority cannot make facts to be facts.This would seem to be obvious, but you don't have to look too far to find facts disputed on the basis of authority (i.e. position within the Church). By virtue of their authority leaders of (and within) the Church are entitled to establish law, and I strive to obey the law. But when it comes to facts, authority is not a guarantee of accuracy.

4 comments:
Ok, but what is a fact if not norms, rules and laws applied to some phenomenon?
Nice to hear from you again, Jeff.
Yes, I suppose we could get into a philosophical discussion about whether facts actually exist, or whether they can be separated from authority. But I think the spirit and meaning of the quote is pretty clear.
I guess the point I was getting at is that it doesn't seem obvious why an authority can't create a rule or law that, under some circumstances, allows them to decide facts?
Hugh Nibley once said something which I believe is a valid contribution to this discussion:
"The fossil or potsherd or photograph that I hold in my hand may be called a fact—it is direct evidence, an immediate experience; but my interpretation of it is not a fact, it is entirely a picture of my own construction. I cannot experience ten thousand or forty million years—I can only imagine, and the fact that my picture is based on facts does not make it a fact, even when I think the evidence is so clear and unequivocal as to allow no other interpretation." (The Collected Works of Hugh Nibley, vol. 1, ch. 2, 25-27.)
Post a Comment