Sunday, August 31, 2014

The Case for Junk DNA

Most of our DNA probably doesn't really do anything and could be dispensed with. Some may find that statement to be surprising, but there are good reasons to believe it. "The Case for Junk DNA," published a couple of months ago at PLoS Genetics, explains some of the history behind the idea of junk DNA as well as experimental and observational support. (A layman's explanation is provided by Carl Zimmer here.) The argument rests on a few basic facts:

1. Much of our (and other organisms') genome is made up of repetitive sequences, broken genes, bits and pieces of viruses and other self-replicating virus-like elements. A few may have secondarily taken on function in helping to regulate genes, or even create new genes, but attributing some kind of essential function to most of it would be like saying that the phrase "copy and paste me" peppered throughout Shakespeare's works serves a narrative function.

2. There is no correlation between genome size and organismal complexity. As illustrated by the image below, genome size can vary widely, even between closely related lineages. (Millions of bases shown on a log scale, with the star indicating humans.)


Let that sink in for a second. Salamanders have genomes that are over 10 times as large as ours. (Insert joke about the salamander's letters.)

3. If you assume that most of the genome is functional, then the mutation rate in humans (or other organisms) ought to be causing 'mutational meltdown' because our collective genomes are being hit with deleterious mutations faster than natural selection can remove them.

There is also experimental support, such as a 2004 experiment where a large section of a mouse's genome was deleted with no apparent effect.

When you put it all together, I think the evidence strongly suggests that much of our genome is expendable. T. Ryan Gregory, one of the authors, has blogged and published on this issue for a long time. If you think of a reason for why we need all that 'junk' DNA, Gregory asks that you submit it to 'the onion test,' which is simply:
...if most eukaryotic DNA is functional at the organism level, be it for gene regulation, protection against mutations, maintenance of chromosome structure, or any other such role, then why does an onion require five times more of it than a human?




2 comments:

Matt Thorley,  9/02/2014 06:54:00 PM  

I’ve long suspected that “junk” DNA may contain the cellular instructions for evolution.

Jared*,  9/02/2014 09:21:00 PM  

Matt,

That junk DNA can play a role in evolution is true. As I mentioned, it can be incorporated into genes, regulate genes in a different way, destroy genes, and so on. However, there is no basis to say that it instructs evolution. I'm not even sure I know what that means.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP