Friday, August 19, 2011

The Further Fall of Adam

Last week NPR did a story on the debate occurring among evangelical Christians over whether Adam and Eve were historical figures.

But now some conservative scholars are saying publicly that they can no longer believe the Genesis account. Asked how likely it is that we all descended from Adam and Eve, Dennis Venema, a biologist at Trinity Western University, replies: "That would be against all the genomic evidence that we've assembled over the last 20 years, so not likely at all."

Venema says there is no way we can be traced back to a single couple. He says with the mapping of the human genome, it's clear that modern humans emerged from other primates as a large population — long before the Genesis time frame of a few thousand years ago. And given the genetic variation of people today, he says scientists can't get that population size below 10,000 people at any time in our evolutionary history.

To get down to just two ancestors, Venema says, "You would have to postulate that there's been this absolutely astronomical mutation rate that has produced all these new variants in an incredibly short period of time. Those types of mutation rates are just not possible. It would mutate us out of existence."
The story points out that Venema is a senior fellow at the BioLogos Foundation, which later clarified:
All science can say is that there was never a time when only two people existed on the earth: it is silent on whether or not God began a special relationship with a historical couple at some point in the past.

The Mormon angle on this is very traditional, and yet progressive at the same time. (I previously posted some of my own thoughts in this series of posts.) I've never seen any Church leader question the historical reality of Adam and Eve. Further, with Adam having been equated with Michael the archangel by Joseph Smith, identified as the great patriarch and presiding priesthood holder of the human family in scripture, and singled out in Joseph F. Smith's vision of the spirit world, I think his historicity is safe with us.

But beyond maintaining the credibility of modern prophets, many Mormons see the existence of Adam and Eve as integral to the gospel message, which is something they share with many evangelicals. This has led some commentators to adopt an argument expressed by BYU religion professor Joseph Fielding McConkie.
How literally do we take the story of the Garden of Eden? This we know: Adam was real. He was as real as Christ. For if Adam was not real the Fall was not real; and if the Fall was not real the Atonement was not real; and if the Atonement was not real Jesus the Christ is not and was not necessary....Had there been no Eden there could be no Gethsemane; had there been no Eve there could be no Mary; if we have not inherited death from Adam, we have no claim on everlasting life through Christ [1].

If I can digress for a moment, this strikes me as a big non sequitur. What? If Adam was not real then I don't need the resurrection or forgiveness of sin? Nonsense. Death, sin, and separation from God exist independent of however we explain their origin. Although ostensibly presented as a defense of the Atonement, in my opinion the above argument is more like taking the Atonement hostage in defense of Adam. It's like saying, "Leave Adam alone or the Atonement gets it!"

At this point someone will object and point out that the scriptures speak of the Atonement as overcoming the effects of Adam's fall. And here is where we get to the progressive side of Mormonism. Although individual judgments of where to draw lines may vary, there is clear support from several Church leaders for taking at least some of the story of the Fall with a big grain of salt. In fact in the very same essay by McConkie quoted above, he wrote:
What, then, do we conclude of the Eden story? Was it figurative or literal? We answer by way of comparison. It, like the temple ceremony, combines a rich blend of both. Our temples are real, the priesthood is real, the covenants we enter into are real, and the blessings we are promised by obedience are real; yet the teaching device may be metaphorical. We are as actors on a stage. We role-play and imagine. We do not actually advance from one world to another in the temple, but rather are taught with figurative representations of what can and will be [1].

Speaking of the temple, the endowment used to be specific about this. As then Elder Boyd K. Packer put it,
What is said in the revelations about the Creation, though brief, is repeated in Genesis, in the Book of Mormon, in Moses, in Abraham, and in the endowment. We are told it is figurative insofar as the man and the woman are concerned [2].

Make no mistake. Joseph Fielding McConkie and President Packer see no truth in evolution whatsoever in the history of this world, and in the history of humans in particular. And yet, when it comes to the Garden of Eden things become figurative.

So we are left with a historical Adam and Eve and, paradoxically, an essential but figurative story that we call the Fall. That leaves a lot of room for interpretation and, it would seem, for science.

Before ending, let's look at one more thing from the NPR story.
"Evangelicalism has a tendency to devour its young," says Daniel Harlow, a religion professor at Calvin College, a Christian Reformed school that subscribes to the fall of Adam and Eve as a central part of its faith.

"You get evangelicals who push the envelope, maybe; they get the courage to work in sensitive, difficult areas," Harlow says. "And they get slapped down. They get fired or dismissed or pressured out."

Harlow should know: Calvin College investigated him after he wrote an article questioning the historical Adam. His colleague and fellow theologian, John Schneider, wrote a similar article and was pressured to resign after 25 years at the college.

The article that got Harlow in trouble is "After Adam," and it's an interesting read. Mormons will not agree with all of his arguments, but they may be surprised how often they do agree with him. Particularly interesting are the parallels between the story of the Garden of Eden and other ancient stories. Reading the article provides another example and a reminder of how interestingly Mormonism is positioned on some issues. Schneider's article is "Recent Genetic Science and Christian Theology on Human Origins." I've only skimmed it, but these sentences from the summary should catch your attention.
[Schneider] invites readers to examine [thinkers] for whom the Incarnation and Atonement are the purpose of creation from the beginning. Their understanding differs from the execution of divine “Plan B,” as implied by the Augustinian western version of an unintended “fall” from utopian first conditions.
The Atonement planned from the beginning? Now there's a thought.

Notes:

1. Joseph F. McConkie, "The Mystery of Eden," in The Man Adam.
2. Boyd K. Packer, "The Law and the Light," in The Book of Mormon: Jacob through Words of Mormon, To Learn with Joy.


13 comments:

Anonymous,  8/19/2011 11:14:00 PM  

Your pointing out and juxtaposing comments about historicity and figurativeness meeting and devolving upon Adam in Eden (the critical setting vis arguments from the need for the Atonement) is quite valuable, thank you.

Re the NPR story, Venema gets his science dreadfully wrong. Genetic ancestry is not pedigree ancestry. The most recent common ancestor (though not a unique universal ancestor in the traditionally Adamic sense) most certainly existed less than 10kya. See an assortment of top-tier papers on the subject linked at: http://dl.dropbox.com/u/3103006/Common%20Ancestry/CommonAncestry.zip

Jared*,  8/20/2011 06:06:00 PM  

raedyohed,

Thanks for your comment and for the reading material.

I'm afraid I'm not seeing the error in Venema's statement. I understand him to be saying that there is no way that human genetic diversity coalesces to a single couple--especially in the last few tens of thousands of years. He is implicitly arguing against the traditional interpretation of Genesis.

You seem to be addressing a different question, which is how far back you have to go to find someone who is an ancestor of all currently living people.

Unless I'm missing something, you are both probably right.

Anonymous,  8/21/2011 05:17:00 PM  

Yeah, I'm open to the idea that the Garden Story is really more ethnocentric than we've previously imagined. This helps to make sense of the supposed theological incongruities. If it's all about "Israel" then there's really no problem with a specific Fall and Atonement that play off of one another. And the principle of adoption takes on a more poignant meaning.

But then again, if the Fall can only be understood ultimately in a pre-mortal context then the whole question is moot.

Jack

Anonymous,  8/21/2011 10:49:00 PM  

I responded to this post on my own blog here.

Anonymous,  8/21/2011 11:51:00 PM  

OK OK, I could be more fair. I'll give Venema some slack because the NPR writer might be putting words in his mouth, or changing the context of a quote, and admittedly some of my contention is over semantics and delivery. Here's some places where I think the article goes wrong:

"Asked how likely it is that we all descended from Adam and Eve, Dennis Venema, a biologist at Trinity Western University, replies: 'That would be against all the genomic evidence that we've assembled over the last 20 years, so not likely at all.'

(Not necessarily true, since ANY given couple could be an "Adam and Eve" as recently as 10kya. Although, to be fair, by "Adam and Eve" he's probably thinking of what most of us think of; solitary couple begets the entire human race ~6000ya. OK, of course evolutionary genetics refutes this.)

"Venema says there is no way we can be traced back to a single couple. (So, admittedly, this isn't a direct quote from Venema, so I guess I can give him the benefit of the doubt, and assume he understands the difference between genetic coalescence and pedigree ancestry. Even so, as the article gets this wrong, and since I rarely if ever see the distinction made it's still a point of frustration. Maybe this is just semantics, but still.)

...

"To get down to just two ancestors, Venema says, 'You would have to postulate that there's been this absolutely astronomical mutation rate that has produced all these new variants in an incredibly short period of time. Those types of mutation rates are just not possible. It would mutate us out of existence.' (Again, this line of argument is problematic because is conflates the genetic MRCA with the pedigree MRCA. Pedigree estimates are calculated quite differently. The Chang papers--"paper", "discussion", "reply"-- outline how this works, and the other papers refine the idea in a more realistic model of ancient migration and population distributions. For a quick read see the Nature paper, it's short and also has the best revision of the models.)"

I still argue that 'Venema via NPR' gets the science wrong by conflating genetics with pedigrees. The BioLogos statement seems to walk the NPR statements back just a hair to where they are probably more accurately limited. "All science can say is that there was never a time when only two people existed on the earth: it is silent on whether or not God began a special relationship with a historical couple at some point in the past." I think in a fair discussion of the Adam story it ought to be pointed out that there were in fact plenty of couples walking around ~6000ya who are all counted among the ancestors of all modern living humans. God may very well have had some "special relationship" with one such couple.

Jared*,  8/22/2011 12:06:00 AM  

raedyohed,

Thanks for the clarification. I think we are on the same page.

A weakness in the pedigree interpretation is that although you can say with confidence that everyone currently on Earth has a MRCA less than 10kya, could you say that, say, 600 years ago? For example, the aboriginal Tasmanians were apparently isolated for about 10kya until European explorers found them.

I guess what I'm saying is that I don't think the pedigree interpretation solves the problem in a comprehensive way, at least with respect to being literal biological descendant of a historical couple that lived in the last 10kya.

Tim,  8/22/2011 07:32:00 PM  

Current estimates for divergence of out of Africa in humans (and TMRCA tend to be older) is more like 50k-100k (see Gravel et al. 2011 Figure 4; http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2011/06/30/1019276108.abstract ; sorry if there is a paywall).

The Gravel et al. paper is taking modern individuals and modeling when they diverged from each other based on the distribution of allele frequencies in the 1000 genomes project. Thus, even though they are now in contact they are still separated genetically by that amount of time. I have not seen this performed on people from oceania yet though a similar method has put the split between Native Americans and East Asians in the range of 15K (Wall et al. 2011 Molecular Biology and Evolution). So 10K for everyone is unsupported.

For me this leaves two interpretations (plus about a million variants), similar to what others have mentioned, that 1) Adam and Eve were the last common ancestor to us all but lived a lot longer than 10K years ago or 2) Adam and Eve lived among others but had a special relationship with God (his spirit children) and as Jack said adoption is incredibly important.

Anonymous,  8/23/2011 10:36:00 AM  

Tim - The issue is one of conflation between genetics and genealogy. See the papers I posted in a previous comment (you can download a zip file at that link). In brief; genetic coalescence and genealocigal coalescence converge at radically different rates. Assume a current population size n. A genetic coalescence converges on a single MRCA at a rate of n generations, whereas a pedigree coalescence converges on a single MRCA at a rate of about 1.77*Log(base2)*n generations. This is per the Chang papers.

The Rhode paper in Nature in 2004 makes some important additions to the Chang model to account for rates of gene flow among fragmented populations. The initial Chang estimates, not taking this into account, were unrealistically recent. The Rhode paper(s) estimate that by incorporating various scenarios of population distributions the genealogical MRCA is not as recent, but still surprisingly so. Even the most hyper-conservative (in an unrealistic way) senario only pushes back the genealogical MRCA to about ~5kya. The most realistic scenarios push it back to ~2kya. The 10kya estimate is the point at which ALL individuals alive then are the ancestors of ALL living individuals alive today. In the most realistic estimates this is more like 3-4kya (see figure 3 in Rhode's longer paper.)

So, he concludes that, "to the extent that ancestry is considered in genealogical rather than genetic terms, our findings suggest a remarkable proposition: no matter the languages we speak or the colour of our skin, we [all] share ancestors who planted rice on the banks of the Yangtze, who first domesticated horses on the steppes of the Ukraine, who hunted giant sloths in the forests of North and South America, AND who laboured to build the Great Pyramid of Khufu [in 2,560 BC]." (emphasis and [brackets] mine) This obviates the scriptural-historical issues surrounding your (and most people's) #1. It necessitates the ideas of special-ness and adoption in your #2.

Further, under the conflation of genetics and genealogy (as in Gravel) one would still be stuck with BOTH problems #1 and #2, because the timing of the MRCA (#1) is still only properly thought of as an interbreeding individual in a small population (#2). So if we conflate genetics and genealogy we have two problems (timing and context) whereas when we properly separate out genealogy from genetics we eliminate the timing issue and are left only to ponder the more pressing and interesting context issue.

Anonymous,  8/23/2011 10:54:00 AM  

Jared* - You've gone straight to the doctrinally critical issue with this scenario. Let me back up.

If you start with a given couple, say, 10kya, then by 5kya let's say that they might not be the ancestors of all individuals living at 5kya. That supposition notwithstanding, by the time we reach 0kya they will have become universal common ancestors, so long as they have any ancestors alive at 0kya. Yet on the other hand, the distant 10kya point is, in realistic terms, actually the most conservative estimate for the point at which All people living THEN are the ancestors of ALL people living NOW. It is estimated that the one single couple who are the MRCA of all people living now seems to be realistically about 2kya, while the point at which all people then alive are the ancestors of all of us now living is about 4kya.

Now there is this gap of about 2000 years, from 4kya to 2kya where not everyone alive is necessarily related to the same ancestors that we all have in common. On the other hand, those people between 4kya and 2kya can most likely all be related back to some pairing about 6-8kya, because even though gene flow might have been lower, the populations were also a lot smaller thus maintaining a rapid universal coalescence. Of course the MRCA of people 2kya has to be a common ancestor (CA) for all of us too.

Even though I've argued that to describe human history in purely genetic terms is bad science, it doesn't completely resolve science with the traditional view of Adam since there are peoples we can't necessarily place in a simple monophyletic relationship. Again, to be fair, even though Venema and the general scientific community overlook the fact that genealogical CA's are extremely recent, it still would cause one to seriously reevaluate what we think of Adam and his historical context.

Relic populations which until recently may have only shared deep ancestry with Europe and Asia are the major question. I think that investigating this from a doctrinal and ethical position could bear some fruit. To me it's a bit like having realized that the model of universal Nephite descent was way off base. It was this model that got us into trouble early on in the population genetics studies. As a result the Church revised the BoM introduction to say that "they are among the ancestors of" as opposed to being "the principal ancestors of" indigenous Americans. I think we might want to revise our historical concepts of Adam along the same lines, if we correctly understand from scripture that he had a special creation and a special physical relationship with God the Father, as most who hold a more traditional view believe.

Anonymous,  8/23/2011 10:59:00 AM  

In retrospect, after writing all of that I ought to have first pointed out that the genetic-genealogical conflation is often overlooked because we forget that genetic coalescence is single parent (because we are diploids passing on genes in haploid fashion) whereas the genealogical coalescence is biparental, thus converging orders of magnitude more rapidly.

Sorry to be a thread hog. It's fascinating stuff to me!

Jared*,  8/23/2011 07:38:00 PM  

raedyohed,

I'm glad you are interested; thanks for your contributions.

If you haven't already, you really need to check out the series of posts I linked in the OP (i.e. here).


FYI, Dawkins' The Ancestor's Tale has a nice treatment of these concepts. (See All Humankind, including the Tasmanian's Tale and Eve's Tale.)

Anonymous,  8/23/2011 08:46:00 PM  

Just read the first of the linked series. Looks very promising. Putting it on my list. At the risk of ruining the ending for me, would you say that the concept of very recent genealogical MRCA's reinforces the ideas you lay out in that series? Do recent genealogical MRCAs add to, subtract from or in any other way modify how we need to think about Adam via evolution? Or do you think the point is moot?

And thanks for the tip on Ancestor's Tale. That sat on my office bookshelf all year last year. Unfortunately it was under Gould's Structure of Evolutionary Theory. You can imagine I didn't quite get to it. Maybe I'll bump it up a spot!

Jared*,  8/23/2011 10:13:00 PM  

I think this post in the series most directly deals with your question. To quote:

"Of course all humans are ultimately related to each other anyway, making all of them the 'family of Adam.' Rather than viewing the whole human family as a tree descending from Adam and Eve, it might be better to think of it as a network or web of relationships that extends forward and backward in time, with Adam and Eve presiding over all."

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP