Friday, July 08, 2011

The Self-Defeat of Flood Geology

Flood Geology is the Young-Earth Creationist (YEC) version of geology that seeks to put the geological and paleontological record into the context of Noah's flood. Originally, Whitcomb and Morris (and George McCready Price before them) attributed the whole fossil record to the Flood, but over the years a number of creationists have obtained advanced degrees in the pertinent fields and sought to bring their knowledge and training to bear on the topic.

The latest issue of Reports of the National Center for Science Education has an article by biologist Phil Senter where he looks at what Flood geologists have said about how the various strata and geological periods relate to the Flood. Through a collective process of elimination, Flood geologists have whittled the influence of the Flood to practically nothing. This is illustrated by the following figure from the article:


On the left are the names of the various geological divisions. All those symbols in the center-right represent different reasons for eliminating those periods from flood activity. These include raindrops, charcoal (i.e. fire), animal tracks, etc. From the article:

Several Flood geologists have presented geologically sound reasons why strata assigned to specific parts of the geologic column cannot have been deposited during the Flood year or at least during the part of it when the entire planet was under water, hereafter called the PWS (period of worldwide submergence). In fact, compilation of such studies shows that together Flood geologists have eliminated the entire geologic column as having any record of a PWS.
Further:
This means that—according to the results of the studies by Flood geologists themselves—if the Flood occurred during Phanerozoic time then all Flood deposits are stratigraphically sandwiched between a pair of non-Flood deposits within the stratigraphic span of a single one of the geologic periods. If this is the case, then the Flood left little if any geologic evidence of its occurrence. Flood geologists have difficulty accepting that a worldwide cataclysm would leave but a small geological scar, but they themselves have provided evidence that either such is the case, or the Flood was pre-Phanerozoic, or it is mythical.
It seems to be dawning on at least some Flood geologists that they have a problem. I wonder if perhaps we may be coming full circle. People forget that it was believing Christians who figured out the problem of geology for the Flood in the first place. They gave rise to mainstream geology, but Creationists convinced themselves that mainstream geology was just ideologically anti-Bible. Perhaps the cycle will repeat. At any rate, I expect that this will have little effect on regular folks, for whom nothing but the Bible matters anyway.

By the way, this kind of treatment is not a first for Senter. He has published two articles in the past year (one recently) in scientific journals that undercut Creationism using Creationist methods.


2 comments:

Anonymous,  7/09/2011 09:28:00 PM  

Jared --

The problem is that most of the worldwide flood advocates could care less what geology shows.

They rely on a very literal reading of the scriptures and nothing else matters.

But, this is a rather clever approach.

Anonymous,  7/13/2011 10:52:00 PM  

Amazing how quiet the believers in a worldwide flood have been . . Did this convince them??

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP