Order from Chaos
The second law of thermodynamics states that the universe is increasing in entropy. This is often casually interpreted to mean that everything in the universe is tending toward decay and disorder. This may ultimately be true, but our intuition based on our experience with disorder in everyday life is not always a good guide on the matter.
You wouldn't think that a bunch of molecules shaking around could produce any order, but that's what constantly goes on inside every cell of your body. Animations of cellular processes usually depict molecules coming together in an ordered and purposeful fashion, but reality is not as neat. A good example is the assembly of viruses.
Viruses are parasites of living cells; they enter cells, commandeer the cellular machinery and use it to produce more viruses, then leave to find more cells in which to replicate. Many viruses assemble a protein shell that is formed from smaller subunits. This assembly is depicted in the following cartoon (from Alberts, Molecular Biology of the Cell).
The virus is built through self-assembly, a process that is foreign to our daily experience. With that in mind, have a look at these two videos, which model the self-assembly of viruses. (I found them in a post at BioLogos discussing God and randomness.)
Note that the second law of thermodynamics is never violated. The flow of entropy simply takes a route that is not immediately obvious.
Aside from being interesting in their own right, viruses, and these models, serve as a reminder that we should be cautious about using our intuition as a guide to what is or isn't plausible under the second law of thermodynamics. If you think of the Big Bang as a kind of explosion, you might mistakenly think that the immediate product was a disordered universe with very low entropy. Think instead of a universe filled with hydrogen which, under the attractive force of gravity, condenses to form stars, which ultimately produce the rest of the elements and the earth upon which we live.

6 comments:
Jared*,
You are right intuition isn't always the best guide to the 2nd law. For example, on one hand life looks so ordered but on the other hand life creates disorder faster than about anything else so by the universe "allowing" life to exist entropy, is increased even faster than it would be otherwise.
I'll give an overly-simplistic example: Imagine how trashed you would expect a house to be after a week if nobody was living inside versus that same house after a bunch of rowdy teenagers were allow to occupy it for a week?
Living things analogously "trash" the universe faster than about anything else and so there are some scientists who actually think life is one of the universe's way of increasing entropy more quickly. I believe Sean Carroll talks about this at length in his popular science book n the arrow of time.
From the video: "Notice that the sub-assemblies form and break apart en route to the most stable structure."
So basically atomic and molecular geometry gives rise to macromolecular geometry, which gives rise to cellular geometry, tissue geometry, and ultimately organismal geometry. Could one think of these ordered stages like peaks of activation energy in the transition state of a long slow chemico-evolutionary reaction, all ultimately leading to a zero-level entropy state? Does the inherent geometry of matter provide the activation energy needed to get over the first peak? Could God act as catalyst that reduces the activation energy required to get over that first "hump" of atomic geometry? Because the real problem with all of this isn't that order seems to exist in self-assembling units, but that there is order at all. I hate how the big questions in biology always come down to physics... should have paid more attention in that class.
Joseph Smidt - your comment has pushed me off the fence to go pick up "Arrow of Time." I was on the fence last time I was at B&N and splurged on the evolutionist Sean Carrol instead of the physicist one. This has opened a new chapter in the life/entropy question for me!
raedyohed,
Sean Carroll also has a blog post about it here. It has choice quotes like this: " life is Nature’s way of opening up a chemical channel to release all of that free energy bottled up... in the atmosphere of the young Earth."
Enjoy!
Thanks for the back-up Joseph. It's nice to have an actual physicist agree.
Ahhh, so a successful system will maximize the increase in entropy by facilitating otherwise unlikely chemical reactions. That makes sense, just never had a text put it that way. This is what happens when all you read is papers on GWAS and comparative genomics.
Carrol's explanation is not so much a mechanism for the origin of such a system, but a rather good explanation for why such a system would thrive. Think of all the free energy that isn't being dissipated (fast enough) on its own...it's like exploiting an untapped market segment, like the Snuggie(tm).
So now if some system that is built on the naturally occurring geometry of molecules happens to facilitate this kind of entropy-increasing cascade, bada-bing you're in business.
As a stake president I very much enjoy reading your posts.
Post a Comment