Monday, October 05, 2009

Let's Get Something Straight About Ardi

Last week the journal Science published a raft of papers describing the fossil remains of Ardipithecus ramidus, an ape that lived 4.4 million years ago and that is more closely related to humans than to chimpanzees. The split between the lineages that (in retrospect) lead to humans and chimpanzees is thought to have occurred about 6 million years ago. So Ardi--as the fossil has been nicknamed--lived a million (or two) years after that split.

The common ancestor of humans and chimpanzees remains unknown because of a lack of fossils. In fact, it may surprise you to learn that until a few years ago there were no chimpanzee fossils either--and what has been found is just teeth. Presumably this is because they live in areas that are not conducive to fossilization.

Anyway, in the absence of fossils scientists have only been able to imagine what that common ancestor was like, and at times they have tried to make inferences based on chimpanzees. But it's easy to forget that chimpanzees are the product of 6 million years of evolution just as we are. Ardi gets us closer to that common ancestor, and based on her the discoverers argue that some of the traits of the common ancestor were a little more like humans and less like chimpanzees.

Unfortunately some of the reporting on Ardi contains confusing language--sometimes coming from the scientists that made the discovery. For example, one of the authors (C. Owen Lovejoy) has been quoted as saying that we didn't evolve from apes--apes evolved from us. First of all, humans are apes (just like we are mammals and primates). But more importantly, chimpanzees did not evolve from humans or vice versa. Each came from a common ancestor. Apparently that common ancestor has traditionally been thought to have been much like a chimpanzee. What Lovejoy means is that we can no longer use chimpanzees as a stand-in for the human-chimpanzee common ancestor because some chimpanzee characteristics evolved after the split.

The bottom line is that in light of Ardi, the authors argue that the common ancestor of humans and chimpanzees was a little more like humans, and a little less like chimpanzees, than previously thought.

I hope that helps. See Carl Zimmer's informative post, Ardipithecus: We Meet At Last for more.



12 comments:

Joseph Smidt,  10/06/2009 02:32:00 AM  

Jared*, great analysis.

"It's easy to forget that chimpanzees are the product of 6 million years of evolution just as we are."

How true it is.

Stan,  10/06/2009 02:34:00 AM  

But I thought Ardi was the 'missing link'! =:) Alas, another gap has been added to the fossil record.

Dave C.,  10/06/2009 03:06:00 PM  

“A child of God . . . is not a monkey; neither were his ancestors."
- Boyd K. Packer (living president of the Quorum of the 12 apostles).
(Source: http://www.byub.org/talks/transcripts/wc/2006/5/wc200653-1774.pdf)

Joseph Smidt,  10/06/2009 03:22:00 PM  

Dave C.

You have to be careful with such statements from Presidents of the Quroum of the Twelve. As such a president, Joseph Fielding Smith said this:

"We will never get a man into space. This earth is man's sphere and it was never intended that he should get away from it. The moon is a superior planet to the earth and it was never intended that man should go there. You can write it down in your books that this will never happen"
www.signaturebooks.com/excerpts/elder.htm

Man went there shortly after. If you actually wrote that down and believed it you would have been wrong.

My point is, (and I promise I am not trying to cause problems) that even presidents of the Quorum of the Twelve can be wrong. (Not about everything, but every once in a while something.)

I think official statements need to be unanimous for reasons.

Dave C.,  10/06/2009 05:07:00 PM  

Joseph,

I think JFS's comment was based on mere opinion rather than doctrine. BKP's comment is based more on doctrine than opinion, thus it carries more weight IMO.

You are right that we must be cautious about statements of opinion from general authorities. Here is what Brigham Young once said:
"So it is with regard to the inhabitants of the sun. Do you think it is inhabited? I rather think it is. Do you think there is any life there? No question of it; it was not made in vain. It was made to give light to those who dwell upon it, and to other planets."

As was the case with the statement from JFS, I find no doctrine to support the notion of sun dwellers. But I do find doctrine to support BKP's statement. At the same time I realize that BKP and I might be wrong. I don't know how Adam's body was created.

Joseph Smidt,  10/06/2009 06:10:00 PM  

Dave C.

I appreciate your comments and though we differ I am convinced the church is the "Good Ship Zion". Though we may differ on opinions over many things, ultimately what binds us together will guide us to celestial waters.

Now, it has been said by some "if you don't have faith to reject evolution you never will have the faith to be saved."

However, I believe Brigham with his Adam-God theory, BH Roberts with his pro-evolution attitude, Joseph Fielding Smith with his anti-evolution attitude, and even Cleon Skousen with his "where-in-the-world-did-he-come-up-with-that-crazy-idea" theories will ultimately be on this same ship and will one day reach the celestial harbors. (Assuming they stayed true to the "Good Ship".)

Stan,  10/06/2009 06:29:00 PM  

“A child of God . . . is not a monkey; neither were his ancestors."

This is actually a very insightful statement. BKP's understanding of evolution is clear and this statement clarifies an often misunderstood aspect of human evolution. He is absolutely right, man did not descend from monkeys! We both share a common ancestor. He is also correct is saying we are not monkeys, we are primates.

Can I twist this quote even more to make it appear as an endorsement of evolution? =:)

Jared*,  10/06/2009 09:29:00 PM  

President Packer has been pretty clear over the years about his view on evolution. Several years ago on the now defunct Mormons and Evolution blog, I compiled a number of his statements and gave my two cents. The context of his anti-evolution statements is almost always one of morality and our divine potential. I don't get the sense that he cares that much about evolution per se.

Dr. Faux,  10/07/2009 04:22:00 PM  

Jared*:

Thanks for the post. Sorry for being late in making a comment.

The "Ardi" find is fantastic. I have been studying the reports. My evolution students have been busy picking apart the arguments.

I STRONGLY believe that it is counterproductive for Latter-day Saints to fight against science, especially evolutionary science. We waste time in discussion over issues that have long been settled.

"Ardi" is a 4.4 million year old biped primate that could easily be a close ancestor to humans. Those bones are very meaningful. And, it is a huge mistake to ignore them.

I am not persuaded that "Ardi" is packed with great theological implications. The closest to theology that "Ardi" gets is genealogy. We Mormons believe in genealogy, don't we!!

I don't know where Adam & Eve fit in, but I don't think we need to know the answer to that -- not in this lifetime.

SteveP,  10/07/2009 08:08:00 PM  

Jared*, Keep up the good work! I appreciate that you keep such a close eye on current science. I always find your posts informative and insightful.

Ardi was a great find in the hominin line. It makes me wonder what else is waiting in the wings--this really took a long time from its being dug out of the ground to being published.

Allen,  10/12/2009 09:46:00 PM  

One difference between us and other primates is that we, according to scripture, have a spirit child of God inhabiting our bodies. Other primates don't. I think this is what Elder Packard is getting at. I think he is ignoring how our bodies were created and is focusing on the origin of our spirits. When he says man didn't come from monkeys, he is saying, I think, that man's spirit came from God as His spirit-children. Scientists, of course, don't say anything about spirits, because they have no instruments that can extract information from spirit matter (and by implication resurrected matter). So, I interpret BKP's statements as referring to our spirits and evolution as referring to our physical bodies. I'm happy with both viewpoints.

I am aware that BKP disbelieves in evolution, because he believes that death entered the world when Adam and Eve partook of the Tree of Knowledge. To BKB and likely to most Mormons who disbelieve in evolution, evolution couldn't have been involved in the creation of an earth without death, and so they disbelieve in evolution.

I believe in both an earth that was created without death and in evolution, because I read the scriptures to say that death entered the world after Adam & Eve partook of the fruit, and that evolution could have been involved in the physical world that came into being after they partook of the fruit.

As a side note to this, I look to the scriptures for the "why" of things. Why did God create the earth. Why did He place mankind on it. I look to science for the "how" of our physical world. I look to science to know how God created the world. How he created bodies that could be homes for our spirits. I recognize that we don't have the complete story of why God created the cosmos, and we don't have the complete story of how the cosmos was created. In fact, we don't have any story of how the spirit world was created and how the resurrected world will be created. I await with anticipation for more information from God and more information from science. They are both good avenues of finding truth.

iolanidreams,  11/06/2009 12:37:00 PM  

Please allow me to jump in with a thought. I believe we did have a common ancestor. Perhaps the apes regressed as the human species progressed. Just as we make choices now,choices were made then? The more we learn the more questions we have. Truth will be the same in the scriptures as well as science.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP