On Being Certain: God in Your Brain
Continuing the discussion of On Being Certain, by Robert Burton...
If it is possible to have knowledge without a feeling of knowing or certainty, is the converse--certainty without knowledge--possible? Burton argues that it is. As evidence, he points to people who have had spiritual/mystical experiences as a result of seizures or that have been induced by chemical or electrical stimulation. Such people often report feeling a profound clarity of thought, purity, oneness with the universe, feeling the presence of Jesus or Mohammad, and emotions of joy, love, and so forth. However, these experiences apparently often occur without reference to specific beliefs or ideas. In other words, there is feeling but not information.
Neuroscientists have begun to map which parts of the brain are responsible for these sensations, and at least some (many? most? all?) near-death experiences can be explained along these lines. (As an aside, Burton lists a number of religious/mystics who may have had epilepsy, including Joseph Smith. I think that's the kind of thing that gets repeated because it sounds nice, not because there's any actual evidence behind it. More on this from FAIR.)
The study of the brain and spiritual/mystical experiences is sometimes called 'neurotheology'. In this context Burton wrote something of particular interest to me:The underlying point is both profound and self-evident: Even if the origination of the sense of God were extracorporeal--from a distant black hole, a past life, a dead relative, the rings around Uranus, or God in his or her heaven--the final pathway for the message's perception must reside within the brain. [p. 25]
I reached the same conclusion several years ago, and I find it tantalizing as a place where spiritual meets physical. If any of the thoughts or feelings associated with genuine spiritual experiences are a function of brain activity (which I don't think can be denied), then there must be a point where atoms start moving and neurons fire due to interaction with the spiritual (assuming it exists, which I do). If such is the case, then at that point the spiritual becomes accessible to science--in principle. Practice is another issue.

1 comments:
Well, I tell you the nexus of the spiritual and physical connection is not the pineal gland (he he, sorry Descartes. I couldn't resist).
I tend to agree that spiritual experiences have some sort of biochemical effect on our central nervous system, or that there is are physical correlates for spiritual experiences. When people report strong spiritual experiences, they usually report noticeable physical events. There's the usually tingling senstation or feeling of warmth. IMO, these physical events are mostly occurring in our minds.
Post a Comment