Brian Greene on Infinity, the Multiverse, and Other Oddities
WNYC Radiolab (a program/podcast that you should be listening to) has a discussion with theoretical physicist Brian Greene. The first part of the discussion is about the wild idea that out in the universe--somewhere--is a person exactly like you. The reasoning is that there are only so many arrangements of matter, so if the universe is infinite, then any particular arrangement of matter will eventually repeat. In other words, somewhere out there is someone who is just like you down to the last neuron.
Later the discussion turns to the concept of the multiverse. Although interesting in itself, what caught my attention was Greene's repeated emphasis that the multiverse is not just a crazy idea that physicists/cosmologists dreamed up and decided to push. Rather, he claims it falls naturally out of observed realities, such as the cosmic microwave background. Whether that is overreaching or not, I honestly don't know.
The idea of a multiverse is sometimes attacked with Occam's razor--that without direct evidence of a multiverse, it is more parsimonious to hold that there is only one universe. Dr. Greene turns that on its head. Which is more parsimonious, the particular fundamental constants that we have, or all possible values and combinations, only one of which we observe?
Now maybe you don't think that the universe is infinite, so--whew--there's not another you out there. But if, according to a prominent strain of Mormon thought, we are part of an eternal enterprise of people production that extends infinitely into the past and future, then it is hard to escape the logical conclusion that you and I are not really unique in the grand scheme of things. Have fun chewing on that.

8 comments:
This post is a perfect example of why I make sure to read everything you publish.
My wife and I will be able to discuss this one together for days!
Have you ever read any of the books in the Discworld series by Terry Pratchett? They are just fun fiction but several go pretty deeply into discussing the possibilities in a theoretical multiverse.
Perhaps we're infinitely unique, even within an infinite world?
Interesting post, but I read exactly the same one---word for word---last week when I was blog lurking in another universe.
Jeremy,
Thanks for the kind words. I have not read Terry Pratchett. Sounds interesting; I'll keep him in mind.
Lincoln,
I'll let you know when I comprehend infinity.
BrianJ,
Yeah, I know. You left the exact same comment.
I've been scratching my head over this one for years. One thing I might add is that I think people concentrate too much on their "bizaro" selves and not enough on the rest of the possibilities. Things like silicon based life forms or even electrically based life forms. Also, I always thought it was funny to think that somewhere out there a real Batman is fighting crime in a real Gotham city. Maybe theres even a Tolkien world out there somewhere.
While the multiverse makes sense given theoretical models I think it's vastly overstating things that it's because of empirical justification. The standard rip of string theory is that it invokes things like the multiverse without any empirical justification.
Not that string theorists are the only ones talking about multiverses. (Loop theorists like Smolin do as well)
I should also add that it doesn't follow logically that given an infinite multiverse that everything occurs. That's just bad math. Consider the odd integers. Infinite. But you'll never encounter an even one in that set.
Now if Greene is saying that nothing limits physical possibilities then what he'd say is possible. However I'm not sure we can say nothing limits physical possibilities.
One has to be very careful here. Once again this gets into the very issue why some see many formulations of string theory as so problematic. Anything goes.
I personally don't believe that it's possible that there could be a repeat of myself. I mean, the universe can only handle so much hotness.
Post a Comment