Intelligent Design: Context Matters
[This post is part of a series: (Super) Naturalism, ID, and the Book of Mormon.]
If an intelligent designer was involved in the creation of life, how might we know of their involvement? Certainly one way would be for the designer to publicly announce their involvement. But what if we only consider the world around us, how could we tell? Natural theology and its descendant, Intelligent Design, posit that complicated features of life that appear to have purpose bear the hallmark of thoughtful design. Darwin upset the applecart by coming up with a convincing way for apparent design to arise naturally, without recourse to intelligent intervention.
And here we come to a problem: science, which employs methodological naturalism, takes nature as its guide to reveal what nature is capable of. Leading ID proponents have sought to put a cap on the abilities of nature by asserting that certain features are 'irreducibly complex' or contain 'specified complexity.' They have sought to plant these conceptual flags on various biological features, not because any designer has specified direct involvement in the creation of those features, but precisely because such a designation is lacking. Only if the designer does things that cannot be done in the ordinary course of nature can his works be identified. ID proponents assert that nature as we know it cannot produce some of the things that are found--in nature. They justify their position by appealing to archaeology, forensics, and SETI, each of which are accepted scientific disciplines or ventures that seek to uncover the works of intelligent beings. At the same time, they deny that any knowledge about the designer, his methods, or intentions are needed to justify judging something found in nature as intelligently designed.
The problem is that archaeology, forensics, and SETI each operate with a large background knowledge, not only of what kind of things intelligent beings do, but of what kind of things nature does in the absence of organisms with intelligence levels approaching human. They look for the artificial, which is judged against the background of nature [1]. In my opinion, ID proponents have not yet produced sufficient justification for distrusting nature, and without a more thorough knowledge of the universe with which to make comparisons, science can only employ methodological naturalism to probe life's mysteries. Unless the designer decides to speak up in a clear and open manner, nature is all we have.
ID stands in contrast to the Book of Mormon, for which supernatural claims were made from the beginning, and for which scholarly apologetic arguments depend on knowledge of the circumstances of its production.
Notes:
1. For purposes of simplicity, I am not taking up the argument over whether human intelligence is itself a product of nature.

13 comments:
"In my opinion, ID proponents have not yet produced sufficient justification for distrusting nature..."
Wow, science really *is* faith-based, isn't it? ;>)
Some of the more informed IDers *are* trying to argue from a naturalistic PoV -- though it seems they're not doing a very good job at it.
Jack
Great point. Whenever someone brings up information theory or worse Seti I just roll my eyes. (Seti especially - I mean we've found evidence of how many aliens now?)
Jared, have supernatural claims been made for the origin of the Book of Mormon, or have supernatural interpretations been imposed on the claims?
Lincoln,
I amended my first post to state that I'm using the term 'supernatural' in a straightforward sense--i.e. things not accessible to science like God, angels, etc. In that sense, I think the claims are made, not imposed.
Having said that, I'm interested in your perspective if you would like to expand on it.
You said: "In my opinion, ID proponents have not yet produced sufficient justification for distrusting nature, and without a more thorough knowledge of the universe with which to make comparisons, science can only employ methodological naturalism to probe life's mysteries. Unless the designer decides to speak up in a clear and open manner, nature is all we have."
Since Genesis 1-2, and the Book of Abraham and the Book of Moses, and John 1 and hebrews 1 all assert that God is the Creator of the earth and its life, hasn't the designer decided to speak up in a clear and open manner?
God is clearly taking credit for the organization of the earth. Why should we assume we MUST give credit to either laws (that always connect a specific cause to a specific effect) or to random chance (that allow a cause to result in only statistically predictable effects) as the ONLY possible cause of the very complex and intricate mechanisms that exist in living things at the cellular level?
As far as making a distinction between detecting intelligence in sciences like forensics and archeology, the (to other religions blasphemous) proposition of Mormonism is that the intelligence of mankind and of God are related, that one is a nascent form of the other. So why shouldn't we be able to discern evidence of God's intelligent actions in a manner analogous to how we discern the actions of human intelligence?
It seems that you are asking God to give an explicit endorsement of Intelligent Design before you want to take it seriously as a proposition. Would this take the form of a First Presidency statement, like previous ones on the creation? But those statements, which predate the modern intelligent design movement, are unequivocal in asserting that God did create the earth and its life by imposing order on its otherwise chaotic elements. Looking for that imposed order therefore seems to be consistent with what God has revealed about his act of creation.
You might plead that you are not ordered by the First Presidency or your stake president to do this, which would be correct. However, if you were to choose to make this kind of inquiry, I think you would be fully justified in doing so by the scriptures and the official First Presidency statements.
Certainly Professor Franklin Salisbury does not think we should avoid considering the Intelligent Design hypothesis. He does exactly that in his recent book, Divine Design. He at least keeps an open mind about what it is possible for us to accomplish in discerning the evidence that God specifically designed certain aspects of life, rather than letting cosmic rays and time do it for him.
Then there is the simple fact that there is NO naturalistic explanation for the existence of the first living cell. Evolution can only work with already existing cells, but it offers NO explanation for the transition from nonliving matter to the highly complex interdependent living factory that is a cell. The modern "theories" amount to little more than hand waving to try to bridge the gap from amino acids to the functional proteins in a cell that match the DNA in a cell.
Nature fails at this most critical point. There is no law nor any evidence that random molecular movement can make the gigantic leap from non-living chaotic matter to an organizaed, living cell. No matter how well Evolution works once a living cell exists, the existence of that first cell has no scientific, natural explanation, and the more we have learend about DNA and the fact that a living cell is a complex automated factory, the less likely a random agglomeration of chemicals could create it becomes.
So why are we obligated to make naturalistic assumptions when those assumptions fail? None at all! Because we kow how the mechanism works, human beings are close to the level of intelligence to create a cell. WE KNOW it can be done through intelligent manipulation of atoms and molecules. In fact, that is the ONLY way we know to create a cell. To insist that this is not the best explanation for the origin of the cell is nothing more than an ideological aversion to the inexorable logic of the observed facts. As much as it may make your relationships with atheist scientists difficult, how can you justify avoiding the simple logic of the facts?
coltakashi,
Thanks for stopping by and for your interest. It is my bedtime, but I'll try to give a descent but quick response.
Since Genesis 1-2, and the Book of Abraham and the Book of Moses, and John 1 and hebrews 1 all assert that God is the Creator of the earth and its life, hasn't the designer decided to speak up in a clear and open manner?
Such scriptures indicate that God created the world, and he takes credit for it. They do not indicate what he did specifically, unless you want to take creation from dust and rib seriously. It is one thing to accept God's involvement as a religious proposition or revelation, and another to claim objective scientific evidence for him designing a flagellum, the blood clotting cascade, or whatever.
You are enthusiastic about the first cell. I can certainly imagine God constructing the first cell. But I can also imagine him setting things up at a more fundamental level such that the first cell was a natural consequence. Should I prefer one scenario over the other? How could one choose between them?
It seems that you are asking God to give an explicit endorsement of Intelligent Design before you want to take it seriously as a proposition.
Yes and no. I am happy to have him involved creating the world, but I think it dubious to assert that scientific evidence can tell us exactly where, when, and what he did.
Certainly Professor Franklin Salisbury does not think we should avoid considering the Intelligent Design hypothesis.
I've read his book. Maybe I'll get around to reviewing it sometime. At a basic level I agree with him. But even he does not thing ID should be taught as science.
But even he does not think ID should be taught as science.
Thanks Jared,
I agree with you that God tells us who created the world, but leaves out the details on how, but ID is merely a new way to clothe creationism. Lets not borrow this garbage from evangelicals too - we have enough baggage from them.
When will you people wake up and realize that there are bigger issues at hand?
http://www.theonion.com/content/node/39512
Since science has not even an hypothesis how the first cell could be created by random processes--no how, where or when--why should we place any trust or faith that such a materialistic explanation exists?
Another problem I have with the materialist assumption is that it assumes the solar system is a closed system, that nothing material could ever come to earth from another planet anywhere in the galaxy, which we know is false. The universe came into being at least 13 billion years ago. the entire history of life on earth is less than 4.5 billion years old. There has been plenty of time for an intelligent civilization to arise in another solar system, reach the point (in mankind's not too distant future) when it can create life, and even travel here to plant it. SF author Robert Sawyer, who is far from a Christian young earth creationist, argues in his novel Calculating God that the fact that mankind is on the verge of having the capability of doing many things we attribute to God means that we cannot be intellectually honest with ourselves and rule out, a priori, that such beings, only a few thousand years more advanced than we are, could actually exist among the billions of planets in our galaxy. The existence of the living cell could be just as much a relic of their visit here and their technology as a fossilized Tricorder.
Remember, materialists and atheists like to say they believe in the "Copernican Principle" that earth is nothing special, that it is an ordinary world among many. And if that is so, then intelligent life at our level and beyond must also be ubiquitous. Given that assumption, the hypothesis that there is someone out there who did on earth what we will be capable of doing on another earthlike planet within the next few thousand years is very reasonable. To insist that humans are smarter than anyone else in the galaxy is or ever could have been is one of those old Euro-centric White Imperialist notions that were just so basic to our culture for centuries that few people even recognize that it makes no sense.
coltakashi,
Not a single hypothesis? Oh, come on.
the materialist assumption...assumes the solar system is a closed system, that nothing material could ever come to earth from another planet anywhere in the galaxy
What is your justification for this? Even Richard Dawkins thinks it likely that highly intelligent beings exist in the universe that would we would hold as gods, if we met them. But to say that they are responsible for life on earth, without evidence, is sheer speculation (on two counts: their existence and their involvement).
The hypthesis of an alien (non-earth origin) intelligent being or beings intervening in the origin and development of life of earth is of course speculative--but so is the hypothesis that only material, non-purposive causes created life, as well as the theory that random mutation and competition for survival among mutated and nonmutated individuals of a species could be entirely responsible for all development in species over time. Most of the hypothesized mutations and competitions are unobservable. The ones that have been observed (mainly with bacteria and human biology) are very minor and distinctly noncreative, consisting primarily of disabling an existing mechanism rather than creating a new one. We really have no observed example of random mutation being creative in a way that simulates what an intelligent biologist could do. All we get from biologists is "Look at this remarkable mechanism in nature; isn't it great how creative evolution can be?" But that is circular reasoning. It assumes what actually needs to be proved.
At this point in the discussion, a standard retort of biologists is that "God would not create the stupid mechanisms that exist in nature." Exactly how does a biologist know what God would do? And of course, they are constantly talking about how ingenious are the mechanisms that evolution creates. Perhas the division of credit should go the other way: intelligent and elegant solutions made by an unspecified intellgent agent (or agents), while inelegant and wasteful solutions were made by random mutation and competition for survival. The Intelligent Design critique does not assert that ALL variation in species over time is due to purposive design, only that there are identifiable instances in which the notion that random mutation and competition for survival can create elegant mechanisms is stretching our credulity.
coltakashi,
I don't agree that the alternatives are equally scientifically speculative. It didn't have to be that organic molecules, such as amino acids, turn out to be easy to make from inorganic precursors. Or, to quote one of the links from my last comment:
"there was a time, not too long ago, when the fact that DNA coded for proteins, and proteins were necessary for making DNA, seemed like the ultimate intrinsically unsolvable problem in the study of the origin of life. It’s the ultimate chicken-and-egg problem, or, if you like, the ultimate “irreducible complexity” problem. And yet, scientists worked on it for a few decades and discovered a workable, surprisingly simple solution."
Post a Comment