Friday, January 04, 2008

Sciencedebate 2008

There is a growing movement calling for a presidential debated focusing on science and technology. The organizers and supporters of Sciencedebate 2008 include a number of high-profile scientists or science supporters. I recognized probably a dozen of the names among a selection of signers.

This week's Science contains an editorial by Editor-in-Chief Donald Kennedy that argues that if presidential candidates are compelled to tell us about their private faith, then they ought to be compelled to tell us their views on science and technology. The magazine contains profiles of a number of the candidates. Unfortunately it requires a subscription to read, but on the other hand there wasn't much to work with. As Science reported:

"Although none of the campaigns afforded us direct access to the candidates themselves - a telling indicator of the importance of science in the campaign, perhaps - we've talked to some of their advisers, as well as to colleagues, friends and foes alike, who are familiar with their careers."
MSNBC.com has a summary of Science's findings, along with some helpful links. There are a couple of surprises.

It might be fun to watch such a debate, but I don't know if it would be useful. (New topic, same old political spin.) I would hope that some knowledgeable high-profile scientists would moderate it in order to prevent candidates that make ignorant or wrong statements (eg. Giuliani on cancer) from going unchallenged.



2 comments:

Jared*,  1/04/2008 08:47:00 PM  

Back to Giuliani's cancer statistic: the way it was calculated is like claiming that in one hour 100 people entered the mall and 56 people left--therefore 56 percent of people left the mall and 44 percent stayed.

Without knowing if the 56 people who left were in the group of 100 who entered, or the total number of people already in the mall, you can't say anything meaningful about how many people stay at the mall or how long they stay.

Jeff G,  1/06/2008 05:58:00 PM  

It seems like these scientists are a little confused. The whole question of personal religious belief reflects the idea that a candidates values can thereby be inferred. Science, however, is supposed to be value-free or close to it. Thus, it will be hard to see how a candidates position on science can be orthodox while at the same time remain relevant in any direct way.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP