Tuesday, June 19, 2007

Mormons and the Multiverse

The physical plausibility of the Mormon conception of God appears to be inversely proportional to his necessity. Let me explain.

The Big Bang poses some problems for Mormon theology. Run the tape of time backwards and the universe reaches a point where it is so hot and dense that it is hard to see how God could exist within the universe, to say nothing of an infinite hierarchy of gods or eternal intelligences (whatever those are). Last year Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought published "Eternal Progression in a Multiverse: An Explorative Mormon Cosmology," (pdf link) by Kirk D. Hagen. The basic idea is that this universe is only a part of a larger multiverse, and this gives our theology a door out of this universe. (See also Clark's post on this topic at Mormon Metaphysics.)

Creationists of various stripes (including intelligent design) have argued that certain aspects of this universe (eg. fundamental constants) that are conducive to life on this planet have been designed--that the universe just happens, by chance, to have the features necessary to make our existence possible seems too improbable. Therefore it is likely that God designed the universe.

Some scientists have responded that--whatever the merit of that argument--the concept of a multiverse renders the argument irrelevant. Of all the universes that make up the multiverse, some will have the properties needed for life. We live in one of those universes. (For a recently published example of this kind of argument, see here.)

But Richard Sherlock doesn't like this argument at all. In his FARMS Review essay, "Mormonism and Intelligent Design", he writes:

What critics have resorted to is a wildly imaginary but inventive claim that there may be an infinite number of parallel universes. At one time it was suggested that the universe might go through an infinite number of expansions followed by contractions, a big bang and a big crunch, if you will. This idea, however, has been refuted by recent data. But no problem. The hypothesized infinite multiverses will do equally well. We might be simply the universe that was "organized" in the design-specific manner that it appears to be. The other universes or multiverses as they are called may be "organized" in much less inviting ways. Or maybe they started and failed, collapsing back on themselves or flying apart. The question is why would one want to multiply entities for which we have absolutely no evidence? The reason for the multiplication is not science, for the appeal to hidden entities or forces violates what scientists claim to seek above all else: explanation, not mystery. The reason is the deeply held faith in materialism and in the equally strong article of faith by some against God or divine design.


And so we come full circle. Do we insist on God's necessity and accept the problems of the Big Bang, or do we invoke the idea of a multiverse and give up cosmic improbability?




10 comments:

Anonymous,  6/19/2007 07:54:00 AM  

I like Sherlock's point about "entities for which we have absolutely no evidence."  It reminds me of what Elder Nelson said about the big bang:  "To me, such theories are unbelievable!" (Ensign, Jan 1988, p. 64.)

AthieV,  6/19/2007 09:06:00 AM  

Isn't evolution itself a kind of argument against the cosmic improbability thing? In effect, the improbability argument starts by assuming that our specific universe, and the kind of life in it, are the end state and then noting how perfectly we fit in the universe. But if we take evolution seriously, we ought to say that we're perfectly adapted to the universe, rather than that the universe is perfectly adapted to us. So with different physical constants, there wouldn't be the kind of life that we are, but there might be some completely different kind.

Douglas Adams analogized to a puddle of water that gains consciousness. It observes the hole in which it lies and marvels at the precise and carefully crafted fit between the puddle and the hole, concluding that the hole must have been created especially to house the puddle.

Jared*,  6/19/2007 09:58:00 AM  

Gary,

I don't have time to respond properly, but I acknowledge your comment.

RT,

I think you make at legitimate point--one that I brushed over with "whatever the merit of that argument."

Anonymous,  6/19/2007 11:21:00 AM  

Two things, as a non scientist who is curious:

1. I have always wondered why we assume there is an end to the universe. What I mean by this is that yes the Big Bang shows a point where all mass goes back to a central point but why is that a beginning point, and why can't things exist in the infinite space of the universe outside of that mass?

2. It seems that if there were a multiverse, all universes would be subject to the universal constants of the multiverse. Doesn't that eliminate the cosmic imporability issue? Since it is all pure speculation, can't we just speculate in that simple rule and thus protect ourselves?

Again, I am not a scientist, and am just trying to learn here.

Matt W.

Anonymous,  6/19/2007 12:07:00 PM  

I would really like to see Clark review this article, mostly because I find his analyses in the past superior.

Matt, 1) time and space stop at the singularity. 2) In the multiverse models, each universe has its own constants.

Anonymous,  6/19/2007 12:47:00 PM  

I don't see it mentioned here yet, so let me refer readers to a book I'm only half-way through: "The Science of God," by Gerald Schroeder. I'm am the farthest thing from a physicist (it's taken me two months to get through the first half), but the subject fascinates me and there might be some insight from his book. He also has a website if you search his name. He doesn't address the idea of a multiverse, but has a definite opinion about the Big Bang.

Jared*,  6/19/2007 12:55:00 PM  

J. Stapley,

I provided a link to one of Clark's posts. Or did you have something else in mind?

Anonymous,  6/19/2007 02:10:00 PM  

Crap, that was during MHA week and I missed it. I thought the link was to older posts. Thanks for bringing this to my attention.

Clark Goble,  6/19/2007 08:26:00 PM  

I'd note that while there isn't (yet) physical evidence for these that's not to say there aren't good physical reasons for accepting a multiverse. Put an other way the reason physicists postulate such things isn't simply hand waving. There usually are good theoretical reasons.

I should also add that there actually are some reasons to think a multiverse is observable. I'd mentioned this in the post Jared linked to. Those who missed it might wish to check out the New Scientist article.

Regarding FARMS ID article I'm still shocked they put such a thing up. Hopefully they'll have a rejoinder from an anti ID person since to me ID has huge theological problems regardless of what side of the "no death before the fall" you are on. (I think even Gary would agree with me there)

Clark Goble,  6/19/2007 08:33:00 PM  

Matt, the problem is that there isn't in normal conceptions of space an "outside" to the big bang. It's not just some mass that's compressed in the early moments of the universe. It's space itself. It's hard to wrap your mind around but space itself changes size.

If there was a multiverse each universe would be subject to some ultimate physical laws but within each universe the "local laws" would be different. This is due to different symmetries. Think of it like freezing water. The water follows the laws of motion and thermodynamics. But depending upon how that water freezing it may have different symmetries. (Say different kinds of ice with crystals in different directions)

It turns out a lot that we call laws, primarily for historical reasons, really end up just being descriptions of symmetries in the universe. Interestingly you can treat the laws of thermodyanmics as just an expression of symmetries within a particular system. Different systems lead to different properties.

In each universe the symmetries it has ends up dependent upon how the universe develops from the early moments of the big bang. Assuming that randomness is real, then if we were to rewind our universe back to the early moments of the universe and then let it develop it would have very, very different properties than it does now. More than likely properties that would make it unconducive to life.

Hope that helps.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP