Saturday, September 09, 2006

Joseph and the Day-Age

In Joseph Smith as Scientist, John A. Widtsoe puts forth the thesis that Joseph Smith anticipated modern science. In the chapter, "Geological Time," he notes that although Joseph's re-working of Genesis in the Book of Moses (1830-31) left the days of creation in tact, the Book of Abraham (1835-1842) uses both 'day' and 'time' in way that can be interpreted in a more expansive manner. Widtsoe then writes:

Continue Reading


Now, then, we must remember that Joseph Smith made this translation long before the theologians of the world had consented to admit that the Mosaic days meant long periods of time; and long before geology had established beyond question that immense time periods had been consumed in the preparation of the earth for man.

Joseph Smith, the humble, unlearned, despised boy, unfamiliar with books and the theories of men, stated with clear and simple certainty, if his works be read the the eye of candid truth, this fundamental truth of geological science and the Bible, long before the learned of the world had agreed upon the same truth.

Standing alone, this fact might be called a chance coincidence, as result of blind fate. But recalling that it is one of many similar and even more striking facts, what shall be said, Has ever imposter dared what Joseph Smith did?
Although it has been particularly popular in LDS circles, the approach to interpreting the days of Genesis as long periods of time has been used in mainstream Christianity also, where it is known as the day-age theory. The roots of the day-age theory extend back at least to 1681 in the writings of Thomas Burnet, a chaplain to King William III, where he intepreted the Genesis days as unspecified lengths of time [1]. Georges-Louis Leclerc, Comte de Buffon argued in 1778 that the earth was some 75,000 years old and that the days of Genesis were indefinite periods of time--as long as physics needed [2].

In 1823 George Stanley Faber, an Anglican, began advocating the day-age theory [3]. It became more popular starting in the mid-1840s when Hugh Miller and Robert Shaw adopted it, and thereafter became one of two popular methods of reconciling Genesis with geology [1]. (The other is known as the gap theory.) The day-age theory was not confined to Europe; in an 1833 publication Benjamin Silliman, a geologist and chemist at Yale, quoted Scottish geologist Robert Jameson regarding a more expansive interpretation of the days in Genesis, and in an appendix to a geology text (1839, but possibly in earlier editions also), Silliman himself argued for the day-age interpretation.

Was John Widtsoe a little over-exuberant? As far as I know, Joseph Smith never discussed the length of the creative periods. Clearly Joseph was not the first person to extend the days of Genesis--if that is what he intended--though he was early in the trend. As far as I can tell, it was not until the Saints were in Utah that discussion of the periods of creation began, with Brigham Young and Orson Pratt[4], in 1871, advocating (or at least open to) long periods of time. There seems to be a gap of at least 29 years between the Book of Abraham and open LDS discussion of the day-age interpretation.

I plan to continue this discussion in a future post.




References:

1. Report of the Creation Study Committee, at Reasons to Believe (an old-earth creationist organization)

2. Changing the Public's Perception of Evolution - Christian Origins of Evolutionary Thought, National Center for Science Education (a pro-science organization)

3. Philosophical naturalism and the age of the earth: are they related?, Answers in Genesis (a young-earth creationist organization)

4. In Orson Pratt: Prolific Pamphleteer (Dialogue Vol. 15 No. 3), David Whittaker notes (#28):
Pratt functioned in Mormonism [reconciling scripture and science] as Benjamin Silliman (1779-1864), a Yale professor of chemistry and natural history, did for New England audiences during the same period. While evidence is lacking, it is possible that Pratt attended some of Silliman's lectures in the 1830s while doing missionary work in the Boston area, a claim made by Jules Remy, A Journey to Great Salt Lake 2 vols. (London, 1861), 2: 12ff.

4 comments:

Anonymous,  9/09/2006 11:11:00 PM  

I became aware of the gap theory in January. I even worked on a blog post about it.

Jared*,  9/09/2006 11:45:00 PM  

Gary, thanks for sharing. Why don't you go ahead and post it?

I read the Wikipedia entry on the gap theory while preparing this post and noticed the similarity to B.H. Roberts also, but I didn't plan to do anything with it--so I'm glad to see that you were working that angle.

Anonymous,  9/13/2006 03:52:00 PM  

Nice write-up Jared. I'll look forward to your series.

Jared*,  9/13/2006 10:54:00 PM  

Mark,

You're getting ahead of me, but you raise good points.

J. Stapley,

Thanks for stopping by.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP