Monday, December 19, 2005

Animals, Men, and the U.S. Constitution

(via Evolutionblog) Here is something interesting from the Eagle Forum, the right-wing organization that Utah senator Chris Buttars is involved with.

Continue Reading


Fact v. Fiction #1: Some evolutionists who claim to be Christians — but also evolutionists who label themselves "theistic evolutionists" — argue that God could have used the evolutionary process hypothesized by Darwin to create the universe. But evolutionism reduces man to an animal. Theism, conversely presents man as made in the image of God. If man is an animal, but man is also made in the image of God, what does that make God?


Fact v. Fiction #2: Evolutionists claim that their battle against creation-science is primarily a "scientific" issue, not a constitutional question. But our treasured U. S. Constitution is written by persons and for persons. If man is an animal, the Constitution was written by animals and for animals. This preposterous conclusion destroys the Constitution. The Aguillard Humanists leave us with no Constitution and no constitutional rights of any kind if they allow us to teach only that man is an animal.


These subtle and dangerous attacks on God Himself and the Constitution must be repelled. There are additional "Fictions" being hurled by evolutionists against creationism, and we will consider these in our next "Briefing." As the battle moves into the courtroom again, WE MUST BE PREPARED TO DEFEND THE TRUTH! (all emphasis in original)



Deep thinkers, those Eagle Forum folks are. They might want to have a talk with medical schools that use animals to illustrate principles of [non-animal] human physiology, or scientists who test drugs on animals with the bizarre notion that the results might apply to [non-animal] humans.

But the preceeding passage brings up something of interest to me, and that is religious attitudes toward the U.S. Constitution. I'm not much of a political philosopher; mostly I just listen to talk radio and read the news. On the conservative side, especially the among the religious right, you hear a lot about God's inspiration behind the Constitution, something I accept. However, some people treat it as if it was dictated by God on Mount Sinai and almost raise it to the status of inerrant scripture. This presumably feeds the originalist--living constitution divide. Stories (folk stories?) like the one of Benjamin Franklin advising the drafters to pray probably contribute to this view.

Imagine my suprise when I read this passage in Bushman's Rough Stone Rolling:
Timothy Dwight, grandson of Jonathan Edwards and president of Yale College, had not long before lamented that the United States formed its Constitution "without any acknowledgement of GOD; without any recognition of his mercies to us, as a people, of his government, or even his existence." How could the nation not be "a smoke in the nostrils of JEHOVAH."

So how is it that Dwight viewed the Constitution as an abomination but today's religious-right elevate it to near-scripture status? Can anybody recommend a treatment of the history of religious views of the U.S. Constitution?

17 comments:

Jared*,  12/18/2005 07:43:00 PM  

I must also ask, can one be a non-animal mammal?

Anonymous,  12/18/2005 10:27:00 PM  

In 1892, the United States Supreme Court unanimously stated that the United States was founded as a Christian nation.

In Holy Trinity Church v. The United States (143 U.S. 457), the Supreme Court outlined several examples of recognition of God in America's historical documents, then said

------------------- quote -----------------------
“There is no dissonance in these declarations. There is a universal language pervading them all, having one meaning. They affirm and reaffirm that this is a religious nation. These are not individual sayings, declarations of private persons. They are organic utterances. They speak the voice of the entire people.”
------------------ end quote ---------------------

The Court then takes it one step further, offering substantial evidence that the United States was founded as a Christian Nation, and concludes

------------------- quote -----------------------
“These and many other matters which might be noticed, add a volume of unofficial declarations to the mass of organic utterances that this is a Christian nation.”
------------------ end quote ---------------------

Anonymous,  12/18/2005 10:43:00 PM  

Speaking of what God dictated on Mount Sinai, consider this. George Albert Smith became president of the Church in May 1945. Three years later, in general conference, he said

------------------- quote -----------------------
“Our Heavenly Father raised up the very men that framed the Constitution of the United States. He said He did.... I am saying to you that to me the Constitution of the United States of America is just as much from my Heavenly Father as the Ten Commandments. When that is my feeling, I am not going to go very far away from the Constitution.” (as quoted in Ensign, Sept. 1987, 16; see also Ensign, June 1976, 27; quoted also by Ezra Taft Benson in New Era, May 1975, 19.)
------------------ end quote ---------------------

Jared*,  12/18/2005 11:16:00 PM  

Thanks for the quotes, Gary.

Elder Oaks also spoke on the Constitution and it was published in the Feb. 1992 Ensign.

-------quote-----------
"Reverence for the United States Constitution is so great that sometimes individuals speak as if its every word and phrase had the same standing as scripture. Personally, I have never considered it necessary to defend every line of the Constitution as scriptural. For example, I find nothing scriptural in the compromise on slavery or the minimum age or years of citizenship for congressmen, senators, or the president. President J. Reuben Clark, who referred to the Constitution as “part of my religion,” also said that it was not part of his belief or the doctrine of the Church that the Constitution was a “fully grown document.” “On the contrary,” he said, “We believe it must grow and develop to meet the changing needs of an advancing world.”

That was also the attitude of the Prophet Joseph Smith. He faulted the Constitution for not being “broad enough to cover the whole ground.” In an obvious reference to the national government’s lack of power to intervene when the state of Missouri used its militia to expel the Latter-day Saints from their lands, Joseph Smith said,

“Its sentiments are good, but it provides no means of enforcing them. ...Under its provision, a man or a people who are able to protect themselves can get along well enough; but those who have the misfortune to be weak or unpopular are left to the merciless rage of popular fury.” This omission of national power to protect citizens against state action to deprive them of constitutional rights was remedied in the Fourteenth Amendment, adopted just after the Civil War.

I see divine inspiration in what President J. Reuben Clark called the “great fundamentals” of the Constitution."
------end quote--------

Elder Oaks then lists his [Oaks's} choice of five fundamentals.

I welcome discussion of our Church's view and interaction with the Constitution, but I'm interested here in the broader view. Was Timothy Dwight an anomaly?

Anonymous,  12/18/2005 11:21:00 PM  

Timothy Dwight was referring to the text of the Constitution, which in fact does not mention God. What Dwight apparently didn't understand is that religious concerns had been intentionally left to the states. The 1892 Supreme Court (143 U.S. 457) emphasized the recognition of God in state constitutions.

------------------- quote -----------------------
“If we examine the constitutions of the various states, we find in them a constant recognition of religious obligations. Every constitution of every one of the 44 states contains language which, either directly or by clear implication, recognizes a profound reverence for religion, and an assumption that its influence in all human affairs is essential to the well-being of the community. This recognition may be in the preamble, such as is found in the constitution of Illinois, 1870: ‘We, the people of the state of Illinois, grateful to Almighty God for the civil, political, and religious liberty which He hath so long permitted us to enjoy, and looking to Him for a blessing upon our endeavors to secure and transmit the same unimpaired to succeeding generations,’ etc.”
------------------ end quote ---------------------

There follows a very long paragraph which includes references to a number of state constitutions as examples of the states including reference to God, and concludes by quoting article 22 of the constitution of Delaware, (1776,) which required all officers, besides an oath of allegiance, to make and subscribe the following declaration

------------------- quote -----------------------
“I, A.B., do profess faith in God the Father, and in Jesus Christ His only Son, and in the Holy Ghost, one God, blessed for evermore; and I do acknowledge the Holy Scriptures of the Old and New Testament to be given by divine inspiration.”
------------------ end quote ---------------------

By the way, the 1892 U.S. Suprepe Court saw a Biblical reference in article 1, section 7, “(a provision common to many constitutions,) that the executive shall have 10 days (Sundays excepted) within which to determine whether he will approve or veto a bill.”

Anonymous,  12/18/2005 11:59:00 PM  

While serving as a Counselor to President Heber J. Grant, J. Reuben Clark, Jr. said

------------------- quote -----------------------
“To me, my brethren and sisters, that statement of the Lord, ‘I have established the Constitution of this land,’ puts the Constitution of the United States in the position in which it would be if it were written in this book of Doctrine and Covenants itself. This makes the Constitution the word of the Lord to us. That it was given, not by oral utterance, but by the operation of his mind and spirit upon the minds of men, inspiring them to the working out of this great document of human government, does not alter its authority.” (Conference Report, April 1935, 93; emphasis added.)
------------------ end quote ---------------------


Again in 1942, President Clark said

------------------- quote -----------------------
“In the 101st Section of the D&C, which contains a revelation received by the Prophet in 1833, when the persecution in Missouri was at its highest, the Lord told the brethren that they should appeal for help. Then He added these verses, which I want to read to you: [Reads D&C 101:77-80.]

“I suppose you brethren will all know, but I will recall it to your attention, that the Constitution of the United States is the basic law for all of the Americas, or Zion, as it has been defined by the Lord....

“So, brethren, I wish you to understand that when we begin to tamper with the Constitution we begin to tamper with the law of Zion which God Himself set up, and no one may trifle with the word of God with impunity.” (Conference Report, October 1942, 58-59; emphasis added.)
------------------ end quote ---------------------


Regarding the idea that we today are more enlightened and intelligent than were those inspired men whom God raised up, President Clark said

------------------- quote -----------------------
“These were the horse and buggy days as they have been called in derision; these were the men who traveled in the horse-drawn buggies and on horseback; but these were the men who carried under their hats, as they rode in the buggies and on their horses, a political wisdom garnered from the ages. As giants to pygmies are they when placed alongside our political emigres and their fellow travelers of today, who now traduce them with slighting word and contemptuous phrase.” (Stand Fast by Our Constitution, 136-37; as quoted in 1976 by President Ezra Taft Benson in This Nation Shall Endure, 19; emphasis added.)
------------------ end quote ---------------------

Apparently, President Clark would have seen the need to “grow and develop” the Constitution in somewhat the same light as the need to “grow and develop” the Doctrine and Covenants itself (which certainly has happened), rather than cultivating the idea that we today are more enlightened and intelligent than America's Founding Fathers. I don't think Elder Oaks wanted to cultivate that idea either.

Anonymous,  12/19/2005 02:17:00 AM  

The above J. Reuben Clark quotes are intended to clarify President Clark's position only. Hopefully, the last paragraph of the comment makes that clear. But just to prevent any confusion about that, I decided to post this addendum.

Elder Oaks is entitled to teach that it is not “necessary to defend every line of the Constitution as scriptural,” he being the current Constitutionalist among the Apostles (First Presidency and Twelve) and, indeed, there has been something of a deemphasis of the Constitution generally and its inspired nature specifically since Ezra Taft Benson died.

Again, the above comment was not intended to correct Elder Oaks but rather to state that I don't think felt the same way.

Anonymous,  12/19/2005 02:18:00 AM  

Jared,

I apologize if this turns out to be a threadjack, but during the E.R.A. debate, the Church said

------------------- quote -----------------------
“Recognized constitutional authorities state that the Equal Rights Amendment would represent a serious eroding of the powers of states and would result in a massive transfer of legislative power dealing with domestic relations from the states to the federal level. This transfer would greatly disrupt the division of powers central to our constitutional system.” (Ensign, Mar. 1980, 13.)
------------------ end quote ---------------------


And Elder Oaks, in the same 1992 article you've quoted, said

------------------- quote -----------------------
“The particular powers that are reserved to the states are part of the inspiration. For example, the power to make laws on personal relationships is reserved to the states. Thus, laws of marriage and family rights and duties are state laws. This would have been changed by the proposed Equal Rights Amendment (E.R.A.)... The most fundamental legal and political objection to the proposed E.R.A. was that it would effect a significant reallocation of law-making power from the states to the federal government.” (Ensign, Feb. 1992, 72.)
------------------ end quote ---------------------


I find it interesting that the current First Presidency disagreed with what Elder Oaks said in 1992 about the significance of such a reallocation of law-making power when they said, on July 7, 2004, “The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints favors a constitutional amendment preserving marriage as the lawful union of a man and a woman.” This was a statement of principle in anticipation of the expected debate over same-gender marriage in the U.S. House and Senate and it was probably not compatible with the J. Reuben Clark quotes I've cited above. But times change and the Church goes where the First Presidency lead it as President Marion G. Romney taught.

------------------- quote -----------------------
“Today the Lord is revealing his will to all the inhabitants of the earth, and to members of the Church in particular, on the issues of this our day through the living prophets, with the First Presidency at the head. What they say as a presidency is what the Lord would say if he were here in person. This is the rock foundation of Mormonism.” (Conference Report, Apr. 1945, 90; as quoted in Ensign, Nov. 1992, 79.)
------------------ end quote ---------------------


It seems there are now overriding issues that make “a constitutional amendment preserving marriage as the lawful union of a man and a woman” (the Church's position in 2004) more important than preserving “the division of powers central to our constitutional system” (the Church's position in 1980). In other words, the First Presidency is authorized to authorize tampering with the Constitution and even the great fundamentals are not always to be defended as scriptural.

Jared*,  12/19/2005 09:56:00 AM  

Gary,

All of your comments have been interesting. As far as a deemphasis goes, I think it is linked to the international growth of the Church.

About 10 years ago, in a private setting, I listened as one of the Apostles (then and now) related a story about someone yelling to him, "When are you going to do something about the Constitution?" to which he replied, "Of which country?"

If I remember the story right, and if it has any bigger meaning, I think it points to the fact that the Brethren recognize that we are an international Church now and that other countries have good governments as well.

Jeff G,  12/19/2005 12:31:00 PM  

Here is also an article worth reading:

http://www.thenation.com/doc/20050221/allen

"Our Constitution makes no mention whatever of God. The omission was too obvious to have been anything but deliberate, in spite of Alexander Hamilton's flippant responses when asked about it: According to one account, he said that the new nation was not in need of "foreign aid."

"In the eighty-five essays that make up The Federalist, God is mentioned only twice (both times by Madison, who uses the word, as Gore Vidal has remarked, in the "only Heaven knows" sense)."

""In God We Trust" did not appear on our coinage until the Civil War, and "under God" was introduced into the Pledge of Allegiance during the McCarthy hysteria in 1954."

"In 1797 our government concluded a "Treaty of Peace and Friendship between the United States of America and the Bey and Subjects of Tripoli, or Barbary," now known simply as the Treaty of Tripoli. Article 11 of the treaty contains these words:

As the Government of the United States...is not in any sense founded on the Christian religion--as it has in itself no character of enmity against the laws, religion, or tranquillity of Musselmen--and as the said States never have entered into any war or act of hostility against any Mehomitan nation, it is declared by the parties that no pretext arising from religious opinions shall ever produce an interruption of the harmony existing between the two countries.

This document was endorsed by Secretary of State Timothy Pickering and President John Adams. It was then sent to the Senate for ratification; the vote was unanimous."

"Madison believed that "religious bondage shackles and debilitates the mind and unfits it for every noble enterprize." He spoke of the "almost fifteen centuries" during which Christianity had been on trial: "What have been its fruits? More or less in all places, pride and indolence in the Clergy, ignorance and servility in the laity, in both, superstition, bigotry, and persecution.""

But I'm sure that those men who lived more than a century later knew more about the intentions of these founders than did the founders themselves. Riiiiight.

Clark Goble,  12/19/2005 01:47:00 PM  

I tend to be a big proponent of the inspired constitution. (Who'd have thought Gary and myself would be agreeing?) Although the tie to the D&C is intersting. The question becomes, what does that say of both the D&C and the Constitution.

We know that versions of the revelations have changed, for instance -- especially sections that were in the Book of Commandments that were modified for the D&C. We know things were taken out (famously the problematic Lectures on Faith which formed the doctrinal part of the Doctrines and Covenants by most accounts) We know some sections were largely formed out of diaries and that the current form in the D&C have some problems when compared with the original diary entries.

Put an other way, our view of the D&C ought inform our view of the Constitution. I think the problem is that when people say the constitution is inspired, they treat it as if it were dictated from God. Yet several of the quotes Gary provides clearly argue against that meaning of inspiration.

Clark Goble,  12/19/2005 01:51:00 PM  

Jeffrey, the fact Madison and others were anti-formal religion ought not be taken as an argument against inspiration. I don't think we need know we are inspired to be inspired. Indeed I can think of many times in my life where I only noticed the help of the Lord in hindsight.

If, as the GA quotes suggest, the inspiration came about largely as an aid to reason and in many, many people, then this ought be expected. God could easily inspire people to be a check and a balance on the rush of those who were pro-religion to get the best document he could.

We should also note that because God is working with highly flawed individuals, this doesn't imply that the constitution is the best document. It has to deal with the realities of the people at the time. For instance I'm fairly confident that God would have wanted Africans to have full rights as Europeans in the constitution. Unfortunately the reality of the racism of the time prevented that.

Something to keep in mind when juding the constituion. We shouldn't limit the constitution to be all that God wanted in our government anymore than we should limit scripture to the existing canon.

Anonymous,  12/19/2005 02:41:00 PM  

Jeffrey,

I actually read the article you've linked prior to writing my comments last night. The Supreme Court quoted sources just as old as Brook Allen's.

We all select our quotes, don't we. The 1892 U.S. Supreme Court provided substantial evidence for their conclusions, both in quantity and quality. One hundred thirteen years later, Brooke Allen used a different, smaller set of quotes in an attempt to prove the opposite. Rememeber, the 1892 Supreme Court decision was unanimous. I doubt Allen would be willing to argue that the 1892 U.S. Supreme Court was comprised of nine idiots.

Have you taken the time to read Holy Trinity Church v. The United States (143 U.S. 457)?

Anonymous,  12/19/2005 02:42:00 PM  

Clark,

I'll bet there's a ton of stuff we agree on.

Jeff G,  12/19/2005 02:53:00 PM  

"I don't think we need know we are inspired to be inspired."

This is perfectly legitimate. I was not arguing that the founders were not inspired, only that they weren't forming a "christian" nation of any kind.

Jeff G,  12/19/2005 02:58:00 PM  

Gary,

Why don't you quote those older sources rather than the 1892 ones then?

I have no doubt that those men involved in the 1892 trial considered the country to be "christian" IN SOME SENSE of the word. However, I think their view regarding the founding fathers are totally off. The most prominent men among the founding fathers were deists, unitarians and agnostics.

Of course this is all beside the point anyways. Who cares if any has or does believe this country to be "christian"? This is totally separate from the question of whether it SHOULD be a christian nation. If all people can do is quote less informed people from the past to support their argument then how sad for them.

Anonymous,  12/20/2005 02:32:00 AM  

Jeffrey,

I have a 400 page book published in 1895 wherein the author provides over 80 pages of quotes from the Christian laws of the Colonies, 14 pages of references to Christianity found in the early State Constitutions, a seven page discussion of the Christian nature of the Ordinance of 1787, the opinions of colonial jurists, decisions of the State Supreme Courts and of the United States Supreme Court, Jefferson's June 4, 1824 letter to Major John Cartwright (one page), a revised and amplified version of the letter that was published in 1829 (9 pages) and Delaware Supreme Court Chief Justice Clayton's public reply to the argument of Jefferson in State v. Chandler, in November, 1837 (8 pages).

This 1895 author provides a very good answer to your friend Brooke Allen's argument about the Treaty with Tripoli, “ There can be no doubt that the stipulations of a treaty have the character of a supreme law, but nobody pretends that all the arguments used therein have such a character. The first clause of Article XI. in this treaty alleges a supposed fact as an argument, bearing upon a conclusion, afterwards stated, and has no more than an argumentative force. That allegation has been regarded as of so little authority that a majority of the courts which have been called upon to adjudicate on the question, whether ‘ The government of the United States of America is, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion,’ do not even mention it. Furthermore, whatever may have been the authority of that Treaty, it was superseded by the Treaty of June 4, 1815, in which the clause in question is omitted. . . . This omission in the second Treaty of the statement made in the first, that “ The government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion,” may fairly be construed as a retraction of that statement, and as an authoritative denial of its truth.”

I've posted excerpts from the colonial laws here. But, after typing just a few excerpts (and only for the first three colonies), I decided you probably wouldn't read it anyway because you've already made up your mind about this or you would have read the older sources quoted by the 1892 U.S. Supreme Court here and your comment would have been entirely different.

This is history we're talking about. The documents don't lie.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP