Monday, May 30, 2005

On Dating

Sorry, no discussion of courtship here. Rather, this is about the tools that scientists use to determine how old things are. I recently came upon a couple of websites that discuss different methods and thought I would draw attention to them.

Radiometric Dating: A Christian Perspective discusses radiometric dating as well as other dating methods including dendrochronology (tree rings) and ice cores. (Note: Ice cores were discussed in a semi-recent FARMS article in an attempt to support the hypothesis that the destruction described in 3 Nephi was due to a volcanic eruption. Sum-up: the data are somewhat supportive. I think the pdf version has a picture of an ice core, if you are curious.)

This link, which I think is called Darwiniana and Evolution, has a brief discussion of dating methods with links to other resources. (Actually the website is much broader than just dating.)

So have a look. I'll probably add at least one of these to the links on my sidebar.

Continue reading...

Genealogy Gets Juicy

A couple of days ago at the conference of the Mormon History Association, one of the speakers dealt with possible children of Joseph Smith via plural marriage. See Justin's post at Mormon Wasp for more details. The summary is that out of nine known potentials, three males have been voted off the island, I mean ruled out by genetic testing. (I wonder how they feel about that.)

I can't help but note the irony: DNA testing is needed to determine whether certain people are descended from the man who restored the spirit of Elijah.

Continue reading...

Friday, May 27, 2005

Joseph F. Smith vs Ernst Haeckel?

In reading the 1909 First Presidency statement, The Origin of Man, part of an oft-quoted section stood out to me.

True it is that the body of man enters upon its career as a tiny germ or embryo, which becomes an infant, quickened at a certain stage by the spirit whose tabernacle it is, and the child, after being born, develops into a man. There is nothing in this, however, to indicate that the original man, the first of our race, began life as anything less than a man, or less than the human germ or embryo that becomes a man.


Continue Reading


What are they talking about? With a few caveats, your genes are the same from the moment of conception until you die. No life-form begins life as something other than what it is (if you don't count metamorphosis), so what is the point of this paragraph?

The answer, I think, is that it is a reaction to outdated and erroneous ideas about evolution. I welcome correction, but I think specifically this paragraph is in response to the ideas of Ernst Haeckel and his "biogenetic law" (although saltationism is another possibility.) Haeckel's idea was that during development, embryos pass through stages that represent adult organisms of evolutionary history. "Ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny." So an embryo would have gone through the stages of fish, reptile, and "lower" mammals, until it finally reached human form. Although lessons can be learned from comparative embryology, such a simplistic progression does not occur and the ideas about genetics that formed the foundation of the idea have long been known to be false.

Haeckel's ideas have been a blight on biology and he has been repudiated. Even before 1900, criticisms of Haeckel had been advanced, but his ideas still hung around in some circles, apparently giving inspiration to Hitler. So this paragraph from the First Presidency is correct. Readers should know that it addresses ideas that have been discarded based on contrary evidence.

(Read more here and here.)


(Haeckel's drawings of embryos have been discredited.)

Continue reading...

Wednesday, May 25, 2005

Interspecies Relationships May Be Over-rated

There has been some discussion at No Death Before the Fall about conditions in the Garden of Eden, and those that will prevail in the millenium. When I saw this article, about a rhino and a goat bonding, the scriptural passage about the lamb and the lion came to mind. In fact, the article cites a few cases of lions "adopting" baby antelopes. The end of the article had a suprising twist, though:

In 1998, an elephant that was abandoned by its mother became best of friends with a sheep at a South African research center.
That friendship ended tragically when the elephant accidentally crushed the sheep to death, probably when it rolled while sleeping.

Reminds me of the rhyme: Fat and Skinny went to bed. Fat rolled over and Skinny was dead.

The millenium notwithstanding, some species may not want to lay down together.

Continue reading...

Tuesday, May 24, 2005

Elder Packer on Reason and Revelation

On a couple of blogs that I frequent, there have been a lot of quotes from Elder Packer thrown around lately, so I'll join in the fun. Here are a few that I like, derived from a BYU Devotional:

Continue Reading


There are two opposing convictions...On the one hand, "seeing is believing." On the other, "believing is seeing." Both are true! Each in its place. The combining of the two individually or institutionally is the challenge of life...

They mix the way oil and water mix--only with constant shaking or stirring. When the stirring stops, they separate again. It takes a catalytic process to blend them. This requires the introduction of a third ingredient, a catalyst, which itself remains unchanged in the blending process.

Each of us must accommodate the mixture of reason and revelation in our lives. The gospel not only permits but requires it. An individual who concentrates on either side solely and alone will lose both balance and perspective...

I spoke of the catalytic process where two seemingly antagonistic influences can merge and each give strength to the other. The essential catalyst for the fusion of reason and revelation in both student and faculty is the Spirit of Christ. He is "the true light that lighteth every man that cometh into the world" (D&C 93:2). The blending medium is the Holy Ghost, which is conferred upon every member of the Church as a gift...

On the one hand is reason: the thinking, the figuring things out, the research, the pure joy of discovery, and the academic degrees man bestows to honor that process. On the other is revelation, with the very private and very personal, the very individual, confirmation of truth. The combining of them is the test of mortal life! (BYU Devotional, 1991, italics in original.)

Continue reading...

On the Number of New World Founders

Via Dienekes' Anthropology Blog I ran into this paper (On the Number of New World Founders: A Population Genetic Portrait of the Peopling of the Americas) with this commentary.

The sum up:

His [Jody Hey's] analysis suggests that only about 70 individuals left their ancestral Asian population, estimated at about 9,000 individuals, to reach America 7,000 to 14,000 years ago. Archeological evidence places the earliest American inhabitants in the New World at around 14,000 years ago. Though Hey’s estimates are more recent, they also indicate a high probability at this time period. Hey did not include genetic data from Eskimo-Aleut and Na Déne speakers, so the number of migrations was not addressed. But with this new approach, researchers will be able to explore this and many other questions to fill in the details of the first American immigration.


I'm not a population geneticist, so I'll leave it at that.

Update: Additional commentary at John Hawks Anthropology Weblog.

Continue reading...

Monday, May 23, 2005

The New Yorker on Intelligent Design

Philosophy of Biology alerted me to an excellent article in The New Yorker about the intelligent design movement. PofB declined to give any excerpts because the whole thing is worth reading. I agree, but I'll give a few excerpts. You can view it as a teaser, or pandering to couch potatoes too lazy to click a link and read a full article.

Continue Reading


First of all, intelligent design is not what people often assume it is. For one thing, I.D. is not Biblical literalism. Unlike earlier generations of creationists—the so-called Young Earthers and scientific creationists—proponents of intelligent design do not believe that the universe was created in six days, that Earth is ten thousand years old, or that the fossil record was deposited during Noah’s flood. (Indeed, they shun the label “creationism” altogether.) Nor does I.D. flatly reject evolution: adherents freely admit that some evolutionary change occurred during the history of life on Earth. Although the movement is loosely allied with, and heavily funded by, various conservative Christian groups—and although I.D. plainly maintains that life was created—it is generally silent about the identity of the creator.

The movement’s main positive claim is that there are things in the world, most notably life, that cannot be accounted for by known natural causes and show features that, in any other context, we would attribute to intelligence. Living organisms are too complex to be explained by any natural—or, more precisely, by any mindless—process. Instead, the design inherent in organisms can be accounted for only by invoking a designer, and one who is very, very smart.

********
It’s true that when you confront biologists with a particular complex structure like the flagellum they sometimes have a hard time saying which part appeared before which other parts. But then it can be hard, with any complex historical process, to reconstruct the exact order in which events occurred, especially when, as in evolution, the addition of new parts encourages the modification of old ones. When you’re looking at a bustling urban street, for example, you probably can’t tell which shop went into business first. This is partly because many businesses now depend on each other and partly because new shops trigger changes in old ones (the new sushi place draws twenty-somethings who demand wireless Internet at the café next door). But it would be a little rash to conclude that all the shops must have begun business on the same day or that some Unseen Urban Planner had carefully determined just which business went where.

********
As it happens, the idea that Darwinism is yoked to atheism, though popular, is also wrong. Of the five founding fathers of twentieth-century evolutionary biology—Ronald Fisher, Sewall Wright, J. B. S. Haldane, Ernst Mayr, and Theodosius Dobzhansky—one was a devout Anglican who preached sermons and published articles in church magazines, one a practicing Unitarian, one a dabbler in Eastern mysticism, one an apparent atheist, and one a member of the Russian Orthodox Church and the author of a book on religion and science.

Continue reading...

Friday, May 20, 2005

Amylase and the Power of Molecular Biology

In preparing for a presentation recently, I came across these two papers: (Here and here--the papers are old enough that they are available for free.) I think they are rather interesting, so I'm going to do my best to tell you about them in layman's terms, although it will help if you have a basic grasp of biology.

Amylase is an enzyme, made in the pancreas of all vertebrates, that helps to break down complex sugars. It is also made in the salivary glands of some mammals. The human genes that code for amylase have a interesting story to tell.

Continue Reading


This image is a schematic representation of the DNA just in front of the human amylase genes:



The first thing to note is that there are five genes: AMY1A, AMY1B, AMY1C, AMY2A, and AMY2B. The AMY1 genes are all expressed in the saliva. Only one representation accompanies them because they are all essentially the same. The AMY2 genes are expressed in the pancreas. However, the DNA in front of the two genes has some differences. Let's look at each structure in more detail.

AMY2B: The arrow at a right angle is showing where transcription starts, which means this is where the cellular machinary starts reading the genetic code for making the protein. It has a "Pan," indicating that this occurs in the pancreas. To the left is a shaded box labeled "gamma-actin". This is a pseudogene that inserted just in front of the amylase gene. (Pseudogenes are copies of genes that are re-inserted into the genome, but lose coding function due to mutation.) The letters and arrows underneath represent primers used in PCR--they need not concern us, so ignore them.

AMY1A/B/C: This schematic is similar to the one I just described. In this case, transcription starts a little upstream, and the "Sal" indicates expression in the saliva. The shaded box again indicates the presence of the gamma-actin pseduogene, but it has been interrupted by the insertion of an endogenous retrovirus. As part of their replication cycle, Retroviruses (such as HIV) integrate their genomes into the host genome and are flanked by Long Terminal Repeats (LTRs) when they do so. If the integration occurs in a germline cell, the viral genome will be passed on to progeny as part of the host genome. In other words, this viral genome is now part of your DNA. Over time, mutations occur which can disable the viral proteins. Evidently a retrovirus, whose proteins have likely lost function, integrated in the middle of the gamma-actin pseudogene.

AMY2A: This schematic is similar to the first two (this gene is expressed in the pancreas) except that most of the retrovirus is gone--there is just one LTR in its place. The two LTRs are made by the virus, and are identical to each other at integration. Because of this, sometimes homologous recombination between the integrated LTRs occurs which results in the removal of most of the viral genome, leaving only a solo LTR behind.

Now it is rather unlikely that a pseudogene would independently insert (5 times) in the same place in front of multiple amylase genes. Again, it is unlikely that a retrovirus would independently integrate (4 times) in to the same place in multiple actin pseudogenes. The most likely explanation for the pattern we see here is that there were duplication events within the genome.

This figure shows a proposed sequence of events (click to enlarge):



An actin pseudogene inserted in front of the original amylase gene. This new formation was duplicated within the genome. One of those is what we know as AMY2B. The other went through additional modifications. First was a deletion of part of the pseduogene (look at the first figure and you'll see that the pseudogene box is longest in AMY2B). Then the retrovirus inserted into the pseudogene and this formation was duplicated. In one case, the LTRs recombined to remove the viral genome, giving us AMY2A. In the other case there were two more duplications to give AMY1A/B/C. Using sequence differences between the five genes, estimates of the times of these events are given (mya = million years ago).

How do we know that the amylase gene did not start out with the actin pseudogene in front of it? Well the pseudogene is not present in other animals such as rodents or New World Monkeys (ie. American). This is shown in the next figure:



Squirrel monkeys are New World Monkeys and do not make amylase in their saliva--only the pancreas--which is why it is being compared with human AMY2B. There is no sign of the actin pseudogene in front of their amylase gene.

Now it gets interesting: New World Monkeys lack the pseudogene and do not make amylase in their saliva; Old World Monkeys have the pseudogene (one copy has a deletion) and do make amylase in their saliva; Apes and Humans also have the pseudogene, as well as the retrovirus, and they both make amylase in their saliva. This is represented in the following figure:



Noted in the figure is a portion of the retrovirus which is sufficient to target gene expression to the salivary glands (this has been done experimentally in mice) but it cannot account for all salivary amylase production because the Old World Monkeys also make amylase in their saliva.

These data are most consistent with the following scenario: Ancestral primates (and other mammals) simply had an amylase gene that was expressed in the pancreas. After New World Monkeys and Old World Monkeys diverged, the gamma-actin pseudogene inserted in front of the amylase gene and a duplication occured. In one of the copies a deletion occured in the pseudogene. After the Apes and Old World Monkeys diverged, a retrovirus integrated into the pseudogene in Apes, leaving Humans and Apes with similar structure in their amylase genes. (Look carefully and you can transfer in information of figures 2 and 4 onto one another.)

Remember I said that there are a few other animals that also make amylase in their saliva. This appears to be a feature that is independent from primates because the regulatory DNA responsible is totally different.

There are several lessons in all of this. First, none of this makes sense outside of the context of common descent. Second, it is an example of gene duplication--the geneology of genes within the genome--and their ability to take on slightly different functions as a result. (For another example, see here.) And third, it shows how pseudogenes and retroviruses can interact with and shape genomes, and that they are powerful markers of relationships.

Postscript: Just for fun, I went to the website that hosts the human genome, which is freely accessible. I was able to zoom in on the part of chromosome #1 that contains the amylase genes. On the left you can see a larger map of the chromsome. The amylase genes are just on the upper arm of the chromosome, toward the middle (centromere). On the right you can see the designation of the amylase genes I discussed. If I were to zoom in closer, I could look at the actual DNA sequence. Interestingly, there is something called "AMYP1". This is an amylase pseudogene--ie. a non-functional copy of one of the amylase genes, which means it is presumably "junk DNA".


Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP