Sunday, April 11, 2021

Vaccine #2 Achieved

This week I received my second dose of the Pfizer COVID vaccine. Hooray! The next day was no big deal for me. I had some minor aching in my back and legs, and of course a sore shoulder, but if I had woken up with amnesia I wouldn't have had any reason to think that day was out of the ordinary (except for the shoulder, which was fine by the second day). Soon I will be considered fully vaccinated (i.e. second dose plus 10-14 days).

I'll be honest that things weren't as smooth for my wife. She started feeling increasingly ill the next day and developed a fever that got as high as 100.8 degrees F, along with a lot of aching (she said even her toes hurt) and chills. It hit hardest about 24 hrs after the vaccine, but after another 7 hrs the fever broke. On the second day she was feeling better, but still recovering from the soreness. By the third day she was pretty much fine [1].

It's impossible to know, but I can't help but wonder whether our respective responses to the second dose would have any correlation to severity of disease. If so, my wife would have been in pretty bad shape. Or, if it were an inverse correlation, I would have been in bad shape. Fortunately, we'll never know.

Some may think, "Well if I have a chance of getting sick with or without the vaccine, then why get the vaccine?" That's the wrong way to look at it. First of all there is the simple matter of duration. My wife was miserable for 1 day, and then it was over. People who get COVID are miserable for many days. Second, although my wife felt ill as a result of her immune system kicking into gear, there was no underlying disease. There was no virus causing damage to various organs, no loss of smell, no coughing, no extreme fatigue, and no breathlessness from simply going up the stairs. There was also no wondering when (or whether) recovery would come, worrying about whether a trip to the hospital would be needed, worrying about whether anyone else in the family would be next, or worrying about long-term effects. Other than some special cases, there is no rational risk assessment that would suggest that it's better (or neutral) to not get vaccinated.

We can't completely throw caution to the wind yet, since our 13-year-old is still vulnerable. But Pfizer has reported 100% efficacy in his age range, so I think it's probably only a matter of days before it is approved for him. At any rate, our family is close to being immune (our daughter was previously vaccinated due to some lucky circumstances--with no side effects), and I can soon go out to lunch with coworkers without worrying about getting sick myself or bringing the virus home to my family.

So my advice is to get vaccinated, but if you get the Moderna or Pfizer vaccines [2], just assume that you may need a sick day after the second dose. If your experience is more like mine, then great! But if your experience is more like my wife's, then at least you will be prepared.

Notes:
1. My wife had/has a bulging disk in her neck, so if she's not careful with her posture there is a domino cascade of muscle cramping in her upper back and a resulting headache. We think that the hunching and shivering set off that cascade, so technically on the third day she was still recovering from that.
2. I'm not as familiar with the Johnson & Johnson side effects. My wife's social media intelligence is that they are less severe, but last longer.

Continue reading...

Thursday, March 18, 2021

Vaccine #1 Achieved

This week I received my first dose of the Pfizer COVID vaccine. Hooray! Right now, cells in my body have taken up the mRNA that was delivered by the vaccine and are producing the Spike protein of the coronavirus. Dendritic cells are starting to notice, and will make their way to lymph nodes to alert B cells and T cells that this foreign protein is in my body. Soon B cells that recognize the Spike protein will start to make antibodies--little proteins that bind onto the Spike protein whenever they come in contact with it.

In three weeks, I will receive my second dose, and the process will repeat except that the B cells that were activated the first time will really kick into high gear. At that point, my assimilation into the Bill Gates--Tony Fauci--George Soros conspiracy will be complete! (Also, I'll be immune to COVID.)

Continue reading...

Saturday, February 27, 2021

How the New COVID Vaccines Compare to Other Viral Vaccines

The leading vaccines against SARS-CoV-2 are based on a new technology that delivers mRNA to cells. This novelty, combined with political and social division, has resulted in a fair amount of nonsense commentary about them. The AstraZeneca and Johnson & Johnson vaccines are also somewhat novel. I thought I would quickly put these new technologies into perspective by comparing them to other viral vaccine technologies.

The first thing you need to know is that the principal purpose of a genome is to store the sequence information for all kinds of different proteins. Our genome is made of DNA, but it does not directly make the proteins. Rather, a similar intermediate molecule called messenger RNA (mRNA) is produced from DNA, and it is the mRNA that is directly read by the cell's machinery to make proteins. DNA -> mRNA -> protein. (Additional variation on this scheme can be found among viruses, but RNA -> protein always holds.)

Next, the immune system can be conceptually divided into two arms that work together: innate and adaptive. The innate system responds in ways that are not specific to a pathogen (disease-causing microbe). It's what makes you feel lousy and gives you a fever, and it kicks in quick. The adaptive immune system takes longer to respond, but produces antibodies and other cells that specifically target a pathogen. The value of vaccines comes from their ability to engage the adaptive immune system such that it is ready to go when the actual pathogen shows up. When we talk about being immune to something, we're really talking about the adaptive immune response.

In order to gain immunity, the immune system needs to come in contact with components (usually proteins) of the pathogen. There are several ways of doing this. I've listed the basic strategies for viruses along with some well-known examples in human medicine. Almost all of them are also used in veterinary medicine. There are some further variations to these strategies, but I think this captures the major themes.

1. Infect someone with a weakened virus that does not cause disease. The virus commandeers the cells to produce viral proteins (via viral mRNAs). This is the oldest and classic strategy. (Examples: smallpox, measles, mumps, rubella, yellow fever, and oral polio.)

2. Inject a virulent virus that has been inactivated such that it cannot replicate. This is also a relatively old method. (Example: injected polio, hepatitis A)

3. Inject purified viral proteins. (Example: hepatitis B)

4. Inject virus-like particles (VLPs). These are essentially virus particles that do not have any genome, and thus no ability to replicate or produce more viral protein. (Example: HPV)

5. Use a different non-pathogenic virus as a Trojan horse to make proteins of the virus of interest. (Examples: the AstraZeneca and Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccines are, I believe, the first approved human vaccines of this type. However, this strategy is used in a number of veterinary vaccines.)

6. Inject DNA that codes for viral proteins. DNA -> mRNA -> protein. (Doesn't seem to work well in humans, so it is not used in human vaccines. But there are a few examples in veterinary use.)

7. Inject mRNA that codes for viral proteins. This is the newest technology, first used by Moderna and Pfizer/BioNTech. The challenge of this method has been to deliver RNA to cells, since RNA is easily degraded. The technology advancement has been figuring out how to encapsulate the RNA in lipid nanoparticles such that the RNA is protected until it is delivered inside the cell.

In each of these cases, the adaptive immune system is exposed to viral proteins--proteins that were either produced by the body's cells, or were produced by cell culture prior to injection. mRNA vaccines are the cleanest vaccines in the sense that they don't involve any extraneous viral proteins or genetic material. They really get to the heart of the process: mRNA -> protein, and it's exciting to envision how they might be applied to other diseases.

Each method has pros and cons, and has to be matched to the biology of the virus and the resulting immune response. For example, in some cases antibodies directed against a single protein are sufficient to give you immunity. In other cases it's not that simple, so you wouldn't use a strategy that only delivers a single protein. But in every case, it really boils down to exposing the immune system to the right viral proteins in the right way.

Continue reading...

Thursday, January 21, 2021

Four Years Ago: What I Got Right and Wrong About Trump

Four years ago today, on the first day of the new Trump administration, Sean Spicer called a press conference to tell lies about the size of the inauguration crowd. Here is what I then wrote:


What to Expect: A constant stream of this kind of thing, and four years of attacks on media, science, and any other sources and institutions that don't go along with his narrative of greatness, or that attempt to hold him accountable. You can especially expect him to project on others his own liabilities....

Here is my warning and plea: Do not give your mind over to his efforts to delegitimize truth. You can like his policies. You can think he's better than Hillary or Obama. Whatever. But make him earn your trust! Don't take anything his administration says at face value. [I'm grabbing you by the lapels]...don't let him (and his acolytes) control your perception of truth. You will regret it.
I think the only thing I got wrong is that not enough people regret it.

Continue reading...

Wednesday, January 06, 2021

I Was Told That Trump is Like Captain Moroni, Doesn't Seek Power

This is just a reminder that, days before the election, Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT) compared Donald Trump to Captain Moroni, asserting that he doesn't seek for power.

 “To my Mormon friends, my Latter-day Saint friends, think of him as Captain Moroni,” Lee said pointing to Trump. “He seeks not power, but to pull it down. He seeks not the praise of the world or the fake news, but he seeks the well-being and the peace of the American people.”

I expect to remind you again in two years.

Continue reading...

Friday, December 04, 2020

How to Tell that Someone is Full of Crap: A Short Guide

A non-exhaustive list of signs to watch for:

  • When they say one thing in public, and another in court
  • When they say that they are not obligated to tell the truth when they are not under oath
  • When they insist on things that are denied by the 'hard news' side of their same network or newspaper
  • When they make claims contradicted by their own official report
  • When evidence and data take a back seat to feelings and anecdotes
  • When they, as non-professionals, attack widely-held professional opinion--especially when it includes demonization of the professionals themselves
  • When they widely proclaim that they are being oppressed and silenced (assuming they live in a free society)
  • When there are no hard, disappointing truths; only corruption and conspiracy
  • When they avoid introspection, never admit to being wrong about anything of substance, or fail to give any principled reasons for changing their mind
  • When they say that evidence will be forthcoming--especially when they keep saying it
  • When their primary concern is "controlling the narrative" or winning the debate
  • When they invoke patriotism and religion to help sell their crap
  • When they have a history of being full of crap
  • When they are incentivized to be full of crap
  • When they deny that crap is, in fact, crap

Continue reading...

Sunday, September 15, 2019

A Brief Tribute to Clark Goble

I was saddened to hear of the passing of Clark Goble a week ago. I started this blog in 2005, and through the years I always enjoyed and appreciated Clark's comments, both here and at other blogs. I did not know him personally, and obviously my loss is nothing compared that of his family and friends. Nevertheless, I will miss his presence in the larger online LDS community.

Farewell, Clark.


Continue reading...

Saturday, October 13, 2018

Information Terrorism as a Tool of the Far Right

This article from Wired is worth a read. It shows how the Kavanaugh hearing fit right in to right-wing conspiracy infrastructure. I don't know what the antidote to radicalization is, but if there is one, surely an understanding of who the players are and how they operate must be part of it. The extended quote below (emphasis added) will give you the basic summary of the article, but you should read the whole thing. Given that Church members in America tend to be politically conservative, I worry that they may be more easily influenced by these things--or at least tolerate the means because they sympathize with the ends. To them I would make two comments:

1. Look the other way, and it will only be a matter of time until you become the target.

2. "Verily, verily, I say unto you, wo be unto him that lieth to deceive because he supposeth that another lieth to deceive, for such are not exempt from the justice of God." (Doctrine and Covenants 10:28)

Go forth and tweet.

Brett Kavanaugh and the Information Terrorists Trying to Reshape America:

As Kavanaugh was holed up in the White House undergoing intensive prep to combat the accusations, Blasey Ford was off the grid, moving from house to house with a newly employed security detail, terrified by death threats, swarmed and disparaged by trolls and digital attackers whose smears and conspiracies then bleed over into the blogs and then into more acceptable conservative media. So prepared is this landscape for new conspiracies of central bogeymen—crisis actors, pedophiles, Soros, secret CIA plots, and more—that naked absurdities are liked and reposted without much thought.

Gamergate became Pizzagate became QAnon became entrenched modern narrative architecture ripe for exploitation. The cadre mobilized a movement of misogyny and white nationalism and intimidation—of angry boys who reveled in the chaos god of Roger Stone—and cultivated the narrative to make it acceptable to a wider lane of conservatives. This is triggering violence and identifiable forms of extremism that we can no longer ignore.

This is Donald Trump's America. But more, it is Roger Stone's America. Whatever it takes to win is fair game, even if they burn down the minds of Americans in the process. This willful radicalization is a campaign of information terror waged on fellow countrymen—the necessary domestic counterpart for hostile nation-state information warfare to be successful. It seems no accident that Stone is apparently in Mueller's sights, possibly for behavior that suggests coordination with Kremlin-linked actors.

The leading lights in Stone's orbit take scalps and champion memes, only to shed their skins and awake in a new persona, turning their flamethrowers from one topic or group to the next. In a non-Trumpian America, they might have remained the fringe provocateurs they are, trolling the fact-based world for exposure and ad revenue, vitamin hucksters and doomsday preppers masquerading as political commentators.

But as the Trump Train prepared to leave the station, the conservative media was already so thoroughly riddled with conspiracists and storytellers that the fringe had ample bridges to the much-maligned MSM. To name a few: Sean Hannity and his commentators (John Solomon, Dan Bongino, Sara Carter); Tucker Carlson and his Daily Caller, where Johnson and Judge contributed; Breitbart, which helped integrate conspiracy and propaganda like Infowars and Gateway Pundit.

And, of course, the president himself has amplified conspiracy and demonized "the media"—even while elevating a new ecosystem of far-right media groups and personalities, like One America News' Posobiec and whatever TruNews is. This has transformed the way conservative Americans consume information, altering how they make judgments on truth and reality.


Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP