Wednesday, January 28, 2009

FARMS Reviews "The Case for Divine Design"


The Case for Divine Design: Cells, Complexity, and Creation, by Frank B. Salisbury, is reviewed in the most recent FARMS Review (2008, Volume 20, Issue 1). The review article is "The Clockmaker Returns," by James L. Farmer. Dr. Salisbury is an emeritus professor of plant physiology, and Dr. Farmer is a BYU emeritus biology professor.

I have read The Case for Divine Design completely through once, mostly through a second time, and bits and pieces even more. I think the review is pretty straightforward and even-handed, and I generally agree with it. My one quibble is that toward the end Dr. Farmer seems to see Intelligent Design (ID) as only associated ("guilty by association") with Creationism. However, the fact is that ID grew out of creationism in response to court decisions that prevented the teaching of creationism in public schools.

Now for some of my own comments on The Case for Divine Design:

The main point of the book is to argue that science does not disprove God--not that there is scientific evidence for God (Salisbury rejects ID as legitimate science), but that the history of life is not known in sufficient detail to rule out divine intervention. It is in that sense that he seems to feel affinity toward ID.

He describes his worldview as follows (pg 22):

My belief also includes the idea that an Intelligent Creator, God, played a critical role in this process. I have no conclusion about what that role might have been. Did he engineer the first life on Earth and then let evolution take over, as deists and others believe? Or did he intervene in other ways intelligently creating every species? My attitude is that we simply lack enough information to speculate at this time.
It comes as no surprise that science cannot refute such a position.

Although I am less attracted to ID than Salisbury (and I am repelled by the ID movement), my own view is actually quite similar. Yet in spite of that core agreement, I have a few reservations about the book. First let me say that I appreciate the thought that Dr. Salisbury put into the book. There are a shortage of public LDS-scientist role models and his effort to communicate his years of thinking to another generation is to be commended, and his arguments are worth considering.

In a different FARMS Review article that was written by Dr. Salisbury, he suggested that the authors "are so busy defending evolutionary theory that it never seems to occur to them that there might still be problems with the theory." I think I would turn that around here: Dr. Salisbury is so busy trying to find problems with evolution that he misses some of its strengths. To be clear, he assures us that he is not a "bitter anti-evolutionist," and in an interesting end note, he writes that he "was personally deeply troubled" by Joseph Fielding Smith's book, Man, His Origin and Destiny. (He later met with then-Apostle Spencer W. Kimball, who told Salisbury "that he knew little about the science...and had no personal convictions on the matter," and that President Smith's book was "not to be considered Church doctrine" [quotations from the book, which paraphrased Elder Kimball].) Nevertheless, in my opinion his treatment of evolutionary theory is incomplete, as the following two examples illustrate.

1. Adaptationism and genetic drift. Salisbury repeatedly expresses concern that plausible "just-suppose stories"--especially in regard to the power of natural selection--are accepted too readily as final explanations. You could argue that holding a provisional position (and rejecting others) based on existing knowledge and pending additional information, is not a bad thing--and science is not about achieving metaphysical certainty anyway. But that aside, he seems unaware that scientists such as Stephen J. Gould have made similar criticisms. Probably the most famous example is a paper Gould and Richard Lewontin wrote in 1979 called, "The Spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian Paradigm: A Critique of the Adaptationist Programme," in which Gould and Lewontin argued for a pluralistic approach to evolution that does not entail explaining every detail in terms of natural selection.

This is relevant because Salisbury seems unaware of a significant alternative to natural selection: genetic drift, which is where the frequency of a particular gene can become the norm (or driven to extinction) due to chance events. Imagine an animal hunted to near-extinction; that species will have restricted genetic diversity going forward. In many cases, the reason certain genes will be most frequent in the recovering population will have nothing to do with natural selection. They will be predominant simply because animals with alternate versions happened to get killed by hunters.

This failure to consider genetic drift, in turn, leads him to puzzle over what in my opinion are probably non-existent problems. For example, Salisbury seems to wonder how natural selection can account for the gene that causes Huntington's disease, which kills people in mid-life (i.e. post-reproduction). Although I can imagine a genetic scenario that could lead to the Huntington's gene being spread by natural selection, it is also quite possible that natural selection has nothing to do with it. The gene might simply have spread by chance (i.e. genetic drift). Likewise, Salisbury worries about how a selectively neutral mutation in cytochrome c can spread until it becomes fixed (i.e. present in all individuals of a population). Again, this is the domain of genetic drift, which becomes a dominant factor in small populations.

Salisbury might accuse me of spinning just-suppose stories--which I guess I am, since I haven't looked into the scientific literature concerning the evolution of these genes. However, the point is that once we release ourselves from explaining everything in terms of natural selection and turn to other established evolutionary principles, some otherwise perplexing problems evaporate. Moreover, scientists have devised various statistical tests for differentiating between natural selection and genetic drift.

2. Genetic relatedness. Before genes were understood to be coded by DNA, copies of which are inherited by offspring, evolutionary relationships were determined primarily by comparative anatomy. In the second chapter Salisbury uses a literary device to express his internal deliberations and pondering by putting arguments in the mouths of "the Biologist" and "the Skeptic." The Biologist discusses the relationships inferred by anatomy and the fossil record, but the Skeptic argues (at least twice) that anatomical similarities do not prove genetic relatedness. Inexplicably, the Biologist never points out the evidences of genetic relatedness! The closest we get is a brief treatment of an evolutionary tree generated from cytochrome c sequences in the fourth chapter. He writes:
The conclusion is that, because humans and chimpanzees have identical sequences, they must be closely related, while humans and higher plants must be distantly related, since they have the fewest sequences in common. Stories such as this are compelling and are among the most impressive and plausible evidences that an evolutionist can produce, which is not to say that an Intelligent Creator could not have designed things that way.
This is quite unsatisfactory. Genetic sequences contain treasure troves of evidence suggesting common descent and genetic relatedness, and by and large the inferred relationships match those that were previously determined by comparative anatomy. He may be correct (for now) that we cannot demonstrate a genetic relationship between us and other hominans (for lack of surviving genetic material to study), but if the genetic trail goes cold at Homo erectus, it gets rather hot again with chimpanzees and gorillas. A genetic relationship with a cousin implies a genetic relationship with a common grandparent, even if the exact identity of the parents or grandparents remain uncertain.

In summary, I think that The Case for Divine Design makes some interesting points that are worth considering. However, in the examples I have discussed, as well as some I have not, I think the book raises needless doubt as to why evolution is the central organizing principle of biology. Given the wide range of material that the book covers in so short a space, readers should use the book as a springboard rather than an ending point.



Continue reading...

Friday, January 16, 2009

In Praise of FAIR

I've been meaning to do this for a while, but I just want to praise FAIR for their handling of DNA evidence in the dust-up over Rodney Meldrum's alternate geography of the Book of Mormon. Specifically, it warmed my heart to see a forthright defense of molecular clock. (I also appreciated their treatment of haplogroup X).

The idea of a molecular clock is simple enough: If you can determine how often mutations occur on average, then given differing sequences you should be able to estimate how long ago those sequences diverged from one another. Unfortunately it is more tricky than that in practice. About 10 years ago one study using mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) turned up a problem with dating the most recent common ancestor (MRCA), sometimes called 'mitochondrial Eve,' when it came up with a date of 6,500 years ago.

However, there were a number of problems with this estimate and the method behind it, and using better methods mitochondrial Eve is currently estimated at about 150,000 to 200,000 years ago. But as you might expect, creationists seized upon the finding as evidence supporting the Ussher chronology of the Bible. Never mind the fact that it didn't hold with all groups of people and disagrees with radiometric and other forms of dating, as well as molecular clock dating of the X and Y chromosomes, creationists have accused scientists of rejecting the six thousand-year figure simply out of bias against the Bible--an accusation that Rodney Meldrum apparently agrees with.

So thank you, FAIR, for explaining and defending the science.



Continue reading...

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Autism's False Prophets

"Book Is Rallying Resistance to the Antivaccine Crusade" is a New York Times article about Paul Offit's book, "Autism's False Prophets." Dr. Offit is a pediatrician and chief of infectious diseases at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia.

Dr. Offit’s book traces the history of autism theories, starting with the child psychologist Bruno Bettelheim’s blaming “refrigerator mothers.” It describes early false cures, including “facilitated communication,” in which assistants helped mute children type their thoughts; head-squeezing by osteopaths; cod liver oil; diets; and a 1998 fad for secretin, a pig hormone. It sums up 16 epidemiological studies showing no link between autism and either measles or thimerosal, a vaccine preservative [which was removed from most vaccines as a precaution in 2001 -- LDSSR].

To the newer argument that vaccines overwhelm babies’ immune systems, Dr. Offit notes that current shots against 14 diseases contain 153 proteins, while babies cope with thousands of new foreign proteins daily in food, dirt and animal hair, and that the smallpox vaccine that nearly every American over age 30 got as a child contained 200 proteins.
I'll be putting this on my to-read list. I've followed the controversy at a more popular level, and my own training is in microbiology and immunology, so I am pretty familiar with the concept of vaccines and how they work. However, I am not a physician so I don't know the clinical side well, and I could use some more information on the history of the movement as well as the epidemiological studies.

You can read an excerpt from the book here. Also, Dr. Offit was interviewed on the podcast, "The Skeptic's Guide to the Universe," which is available here.


Continue reading...

Saturday, January 10, 2009

What Separates Humans from New World Monkeys?

[This post is part of a series, What Separates Humans from the Animals?. This addition of the series comes from the archives and was originally posted as Rainbow of Colors: Monkey See.]

Color vision is something I take for granted. I forget that a significant portion of the population does not see the range of colors that I can. And I have no way of appreciating the range of colors that birds and bees can see. The natural history of primate color vision makes for an interesting story.

We see color because the cones in our retinas make three different versions of proteins called opsins. These proteins are responsible for initiating impulses to the brain, and they have differing sensitivities to different wavelengths of light. It is by comparing the signal strength between the three opsins that our brains are able to interpret color. Since we have three types of opsin proteins (S, M and L), we are trichromats.


(Figure shows spectral sensitivities of the opsins in different organisims [1].)

Although there are several types and causes of color blindness, the most familiar cause is genetic and mainly affects men. This is because two of the three opsin genes are located on the X chromosome. Since females have two X chromosomes it doesn't matter if one of them has a defective opsin gene. But if a male has a defective opsin on the X chromosome, he's out of luck.

Color vision appears to have been the norm for most animals--including fish--but most placental mammals are dichromats, apparently because they lost two unnecessary opsins while adopting a nocturnal lifestyle early in their evolution. Most primates are different, however, and this is where the story gets interesting.


There is a basic divide among the monkeys and apes: there are the Old World Monkeys (OWMs) and Apes (including humans), and then there are the New World Monkeys (NWMs). NWM males are dichromats, but some females are trichromats. How can this be? Well instead of having two different opsins on the X chromosome, there are different variants (allels) of the one opsin gene on the X chromosome circulating in the population. Since females have two X chromosomes, they can have two variants of that opsin at once. Such females are called 'allelic trichromats'. Males are stuck with either one or the other variant, and thus remain dichromats. The exception is the howler monkey, which at some point had a gene duplication occur such that the X chromosome has two copies of the opsin gene. One of the opsins mutated such that it has a slightly different wavelength sensitivity, making howler monkeys 'true trichromats,' like us.

OWMs and Apes are true trichromats. The reason for this is similar to the howler monkey. At an early point after the split from NWMs, a gene duplication occured on the X chromosome leading to the existence of two opsin genes of slightly different peak sensitivity. However this was an earlier and separate event from that of the howler monkey. (In the figure above and to the left [2], the arrows indicate lineages that are true trichromats. Red lineages indicate those with a high precentage of OR pseudogenes, as explained below. Click to enlarge.)

All of this is interesting for a number of reasons, including issues of phylogeny, biogeography and so forth, but the story goes one step further. A group of scientists were studying the olfactory receptors (ORs) in primates. These proteins are to smell, what opsins are to vision--except that there are a greater variety of ORs. Specifically, they looked at the proportion of OR genes that are broken (pseudogenes) in a variety of primates and found something interesting. OWMs and Apes have a higher percentage of OR pseudogenes than NWMs, with one exception: the howler monkey. The figure to the right (click to enlarge) shows the percentage of OR pseudogenes in different primate species [2]. Humans have the highest percentage, but note that the only species above 20% are true trichromats. It is too early to say whether there is a causal relationship, but the correlation is striking and suggests that as primates gained better color vision, selective pressure for smell was relaxed, which allowed increasing numbers of ORs to become broken and unused.

As I look out my window, fall colors are on full display. Limited as they may be in comparision to some other animals, I'm grateful for my senses.




1. Vorobyev, Ecology and Evolution of Primate Colour Vision (pdf), Clinical and Experimental Optometry, 2004, 87:4-5. The same issue of this journal has several additional articles on color vision, freely available here.

2. Gilad et al., Loss of Olfactory Receptor Genes Coincides with the Acquisition of Full Trichromatic Vision in Primates, PLoS Biology, 2004, Vol. 2 Issue 1.

See "The Howler Monkey's Tale" in Richard Dawkins' Ancestor's Tale for a popular-science treatment of primate color vision.




Continue reading...

Wednesday, January 07, 2009

Miller, Matzke, et al. Dissect ID Revisionist History

Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District (2005) was a serious blow to the Intelligent Design movement, and Brown University biologist (and active Catholic) Ken Miller played an important role as an expert witness for the plaintiffs against the ID claims. (If you are unfamiliar with the Kitzmiller case, or need refreshing, may I recommend this review article?) The Discovery Institute has found things to complain about the trial ever since (see the above referenced article), and lately they've attacked Ken Miller's testimony, particularly about 'irreducible complexity,' as "smoke-and-mirrors." This is not just a nerd-fight over history; the Discovery Institute and other ID/creationists are still at work--not doing science, mind you--and they would love for the public and education officials to think that the case was wrongly decided.

Ken Miller has now responded in a three-part guest post on Carl Zimmer's blog, The Loom, and he is great--as usual. Part 1, Part 2 (I found this post particularly juicy), and Part 3.

Nick Matzke, who helped on the plaintiff's side, also responded with a lengthy but informative and entertaining must-read rebuttal (God of the Gaps...in your own knowledge. Luskin, Behe, & blood-clotting). Here is a money quote:

This is exactly the problem with ID/creationism – invoking God into gaps in knowledge is pretty troublesome, but creationists do something even worse. They insert God into gaps in their own knowledge, assuming, usually without even a vaguely serious attempt at a literature search (!!!), that whatever tidbits of biology they happen to have picked up represent the sum total of scientific knowledge on a topic.

And then for some icing on the cake, see While we are piling on Casey Luskin....


Continue reading...

Tuesday, December 30, 2008

Year of Darwin: Videos and More

You will hear a lot about Charles Darwin for the next year. This is because it is the bicentennial of his birth and 150 years since the publication of On the Origin of Species. Case Western Reserve University is celebrating their "Year of Darwin" with a line-up of lectures. Many of them are available online. I especially recommend two of them: Neil Shubin gave a paleontology-oriented talk about the discovery of Tiktaalik, and Sean Carroll gave a more gene-oriented talk (see below). I think you'll find both of them worth your time.

Meanwhile, the January 2009 Scientific American has a number of interesting articles. Several that I liked are:

1. Evolution of the Mind: 4 Fallacies of Psychology (a critique of pop evolutionary psychology)

2. Testing Natural Selection with Genetics

3. Diversity Revealed: From Atoms to Traits

4. The Evolutionary Origins of Hiccups and Hernias (this will be familiar if you've read Neil Shubin's book, Your Inner Fish)

5. The Latest Face of Creationism in the Classroom


Go forth and be edified!








Continue reading...

Friday, December 26, 2008

Happy Birthday, Newton. Or Not.

Christmas day was the birthday of Isaac Newton. Or maybe it wasn't. Olivia Judson in the New York Times explains why a slowing earth and a change in calendar makes Newton's birth date somewhat uncertain.



Continue reading...

Tuesday, December 16, 2008

Joseph Smith: Mormonism is Truth

Most wards will study "Gaining Knowledge of Eternal Truths" in the Teachings of Presidents of the Church: Joseph Smith manual this month. I found the following quote a rather inspiring ideal:

“Mormonism is truth; and every man who embraces it feels himself at liberty to embrace every truth: consequently the shackles of superstition, bigotry, ignorance, and priestcraft, fall at once from his neck; and his eyes are opened to see the truth, and truth greatly prevails over priestcraft. …

“… Mormonism is truth, in other words the doctrine of the Latter-day Saints, is truth. … The first and fundamental principle of our holy religion is, that we believe that we have a right to embrace all, and every item of truth, without limitation or without being circumscribed or prohibited by the creeds or superstitious notions of men, or by the dominations of one another, when that truth is clearly demonstrated to our minds, and we have the highest degree of evidence of the same.” [bolding added]




Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP