Saturday, March 22, 2008

Q&A with Henry J. Eyring

Henry J. Eyring, the author of Mormon Scientist: The Life and Faith of Henry Eyring, was gracious enough to field some questions from LDSSR, for which I thank him.

1. As our scientific understanding continues to expand, the tension between science and religion continues. How is Henry Eyring relevant to a generation that never knew him? How can he help them in their efforts at reconciliation?

Though each generation sees a new wave of scientific discovery, the religious and ethical issues raised by those discoveries are fundamentally the same. The perspectives offered by Henry Eyring are, in that sense, timeless. See his statements on page 247 of the book, under the heading, "It Was Ever So."

2.Elder Neal A. Maxwell said that Hugh Nibley’s obvious loyalty to the Church gave him greater latitude in expressing his opinions. Do you think this was also the case with Henry?

Henry seems to have been trusted for his combination of professional capability, pure motives, and consistent obedience. It is a example for which I am personally grateful.

3. The book indicates that Henry and Joseph Fielding Smith were friends. Beyond the encounter arising from Henry’s review of Man, His Origin and Destiny , were there other circumstances that brought them together?

I'm not aware of interactions other than those noted in the book. There is no doubt in my mind, though, that his respect for President Smith was real.

4. Was your undergraduate major in geology inspired by your grandfather? Why not physics or chemistry?

My love for geology was the gift of boyhood mentors at BYU-Idaho, Madison Junior High School (in Rexburg) and BYU. I wasn't good enough at mathematics to compete with my forebears in either physics or chemistry, but I love the study of the physical earth.

5. In your geological studies, did you sense any conflict between science and religion? How was Henry’s perspective helpful to you?

I was blessed to have my grandfather's views conveyed to me from boyhood. As a result, my scientific studies only added to my faith.

6. The book states that President David O. McKay used Henry as an unofficial science ambassador. Did Presidents Smith, Lee, or Kimball use him in a similar manner?

President McKay served for more than 15 years after he first invited Henry to speak for the Church. Henry's efforts seem to have become habitual, and when President McKay passed away he kept right on going. My guess is that subsequent Church presidents simply let him roll along.

7. Were there any correspondence gems that did not make it into the book?

Space did not permit me to include many of the touching thank you letters that he received from friends and strangers. In 1977, for instance, one young man wrote the following:

Dear Brother Eyring:

It's been two weeks since I had the opportunity of spending two hours talking with you. I wanted to write and tell you "Thanks" for spending that time with me. Through your care and wisdom and the sincere critiquing of my words and desires, new prospects of education, vocation and interest were sparked. Gerontology is a fascinating area of study; preparing youth and adults for this very important part of life is the basis of my desire in this field. I plan to pursue advanced degrees in health sciences and education and eventually teach at the college level the "Science of Aging."

Again I would like to thank you for your desire, care and concern, and for allowing Friday, September 16 to be remembered as "a day when someone's precious time was spent in behalf of another." I really enjoyed our visit!

8. In your research for the book, did you find anything that surprised you?

I was surprised by the extent to which Henry's faith rested on Joseph Smith's account of the First Vision. He seemed to accept that as a fundamental religious "postulate," the bedrock that made his faith unshakeable. As far as I can tell, his father gets much of the credit for that.

9. Can you explain Henry’s relationship to Carl F. Eyring (for whom the BYU building is named)?

Carl was Henry's uncle. He did research with Millikan at Chicago and seems to have had a great influence on Henry's older sister Camilla [wife of Spencer W. Kimball -- LDSSR] when she was studying at Brigham Young Academy. Camilla returned one summer to Arizona and told Henry that he ought to get a PhD. He was one of many immediate family members who took that advice.

10. Were you the grandson that, according to Henry, said, "I am not a 'unbeam, I'm Henry Johnson Eyring!"?

I am the one. When I was about that age my grandfather came to live with us for several weeks while he received radiation treatment for prostate cancer at Stanford, where my father taught. It was a sweet time. I remember Grandpa as the fellow who peeled oranges and cracked walnuts for me.



Continue reading...

Saturday, March 15, 2008

Book Review: Mormon Scientist

Henry Eyring died before I was old enough to know or care who he was. As far as I can remember, I first became aware of him during college, and only because of my interest in science and the accessibility of the Internet. With the publication of Mormon Scientist: The Life and Faith of Henry Eyring, Henry is once again in the limelight and a new generation can become familiar with him. This new biography is written by his grandson, Henry J. Eyring (who was urged to do so by Elder Neal A. Maxwell), and draws on Henry's former books, archived materials, articles published in Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought (see below), and the memories of his children, including President Henry B. Eyring of the First Presidency (and father of the author). The book is published by Deseret Book and during my recent trip to Utah I observed that it was being heavily advertised.

Among Church members who know his name, Henry Eyring is probably known for three things: (i) his commitment to the Church, (ii) his commitment to--and successful career in--science, and (perhaps less-well known) (iii) his bold but diplomatic face-off with Joseph Fielding Smith, then president of the Quorum of the Twelve. In light of the above, and given the position of President Eyring, I wondered what to expect from the book.

If you are looking for a reconciliation of science and religion you will be disappointed. Henry did not attempt reconciliation; he accepted contradiction and couched his views on science in terms of the genius of God while shunning dogmatism. Although it is portrayed as genuine, I have to think that his vagueness was also strategic. He often repeated his father's advice to him that "in this Church you don't have to believe anything that isn't true." Statements like that emphasize the broadness of Mormonism and allow people of different persuasions to see in it what they want, while avoiding becoming locked into conflict with any particular Church leader. Nevertheless, the book is peppered with Eyring's words of wisdom, some of which science-enthusiasts may want to appropriate for their own use.

The book provides a survey of Henry's life, beginning with his youth in one of the Mormon colonies in Mexico, and then charting his scientific career. Although some sense of his research accomplishments is given, the book avoids technicalities and readers need not have a background in science. Most of the book focuses on his role as ambassador between science and religion, as well as personality traits that made him unique. I did not previously know that he was actually assigned by the First Presidency (under David O. McKay) to unofficially represent the Church in science-and-religion discussions. However, he did not use that fact to bolster his position.

Among faithful Church members, it would have added great weight to his arguments to say, "I speak regularly at the request of the First Presidency, and they're supportive of my views." The temptation would have been especially great when well-intentioned Church members criticized his scientific views as evidence of weak faith or even heresy.... He discretely stood on his own authority and took his lumps, because that was part of the job. (p. 208)

Henry's famous face-off with Joseph Fielding Smith is recounted in a respectful but forthright manner. The same forthrightness characterizes discussion of Henry's parents; not only was his father polygamously married to sisters (something that, at a young age, Henry decided was not a good idea), the second marriage took place in 1903, well after the 1890 Manifesto. By way of explanation the book states,
However, polygamy was still legal in Mexico...and Church leaders in the Mormon colonies continued to selectively encourage polygamy until a final worldwide prohibition was issued by the First Presidency in Salt Lake City in 1904.
Although that statement glosses over some of the sticky issues surrounding post-Manifesto polygamy, I was surprised to see it treated at all. My guess is that many Church members will find such a thing surprising.

I found a few points to quibble with, but I don't think they are worth mentioning here. Overall the book makes for light reading, with only excerpts of representative letters used. I hope that someone will assemble and publish more of his correspondence. Also, readers should know that the focus of the book is firmly on Henry. Other family members are mentioned from time to time, however readers should not expect to gain direct insight into their views (i.e. President Henry B. Eyring's views).

Sadly the Church does not currently have a scientific mentor--someone who commands the respect and support of both leaders and laity, and can serve to ease the tension between science and religion. For this reason, I hope that Mormon Scientist will be read widely in the LDS community.


Resources:

Mormon Scientist has an associated website: mormonscientist.org. There you can read a free chapter, and Henry Eyring's books, The Faith of a Scientist and Reflections of a Scientist, will be made freely available--a wonderful idea!

In addition, interested readers may want to consult the following:

1. A Dialogue with Henry Eyring
2. Agreeing to Disagree: Henry Eyring and Joseph Fielding Smith (original article here)
3. Harvey Fletcher and Henry Eyring: Men of Faith and Science (original article here)
4. The Deseret Morning News interviewed Henry J. Eyring here.
5. My own Q&A with Henry J. Eyring is here.


Continue reading...

Saturday, March 08, 2008

My Visit to Utah's Museum of Ancient Life

I was in Utah earlier this week. In addition to getting in some skiing (Conditions were almost perfect. And FYI, I would rate myself as a solid intermediate.), I went to the North American Museum of Ancient Life at Thanksgiving Point. I wasn't really expecting much from it, but I have to say that I was impressed. It's not the Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History, but I don't think it's that far behind, either. And it's more child friendly.

Unfortunately we were on a tight schedule, so I didn't get to look it over closely (i.e. read the display signs). The geology was presented in a straightforward manner, but now that I think about it, I don't remember much discussion of evolution--perhaps I missed it. Yet I am suspicious that in order to make the museum successful, they avoided the issue. For example, although they had a fossil (or cast?) of one of the earliest birds, I did not see any discussion of birds descending from dinosaurs. Now I wish I had paid better attention; I got distracted taking the pictures below.



In order to give a sense of geological time, they have a series of gears that represent various time-scales. Here my daughter is turning what represents one year. If you ever see the million-year wheel move, let me know.


I'm proud to say that I knew what this display represented the moment I saw it, and without reading the label--the Precambrian.


This is part of the trilobite display. I would like to find my own trilobite fossil some day.


This is one of the display rooms. There's a T-rex in the back, some dinosaur eggs on the bottom right, and a rack of various skulls hanging in the upper-right.


There is a model river where you can see erosion in action, as well as watch dinosaurs get buried or uncovered.


Here my daughter and I work on a pretend fossil dig, brushing away sand to uncover the bones.

There are also some movies (which we did not watch). So if you are in Utah and in the mood for some natural history, go check out the museum. I think that both you and your kids will have a good time.



Continue reading...

Tuesday, February 26, 2008

What to Think of Wise?

Kurt Wise is a young-earth creationist who earned a Ph.D. at Harvard as a student of Stephen J. Gould (of all people). In Evolution: What the Fossils Say and Why it Matters Donald Prothero mentions Wise and quotes something he has written (I have included a little more than is quoted in the book):

Although there are scientific reasons for accepting a young earth, I am a young-age creationist because that is my understanding of the Scripture. As I shared with my professors years ago when I was in college, if all the evidence in the universe turned against creationism, I would be the first to admit it, but I would still be a creationist because that is what the Word of God seems to indicate. Here I must stand.
I find myself conflicted over this position. His intransigence in the face of clear evidence is anathema to science--and in my view, personal growth--and for that I feel indignation. Yet I also maintain beliefs that lack the evidential support that I would like, and so I also feel compassion and empathy. Is Wise to be admired or disdained?

I think Prothero gets it about right.
I have no problem with his belief system.... If he labeled his ideas as religiously inspired, that would be fine. But he continues to pretend that he is following the rules of science; he wears the label of scientist and promotes his particular brand of "science" to unsuspecting people who are impressed with his Harvard Ph.D. but don't realize that he admits that he stopped doing science [a] long time ago.
I don't know to what extent Wise is guilty of the sins that Prothero attributes to him--I do know that Wise is considered one of the more honest creationists because he eschews some of the false or misleading arguments that some creationists use--but I think that Prothero's basic point is correct.

Commenting on Wise's quote above, Richard Dawkins asks,
Can you imagine believing that and at the same time accepting a salary, month after month, to teach science? Even at Bryan College in Dayton, Tennessee? I’m not sure that I could live with myself. And I think I would curse my God for leading me to such a pass.
I'll bet that Kurt Wise has his share of scars.



Continue reading...

Monday, February 25, 2008

The Transition of a Young-Earth Creationist

This week's Science has a news article that features paleontologist Stephen Godfrey's transition from young-earth creationist to scientist. The context is non-LDS, but I think it captures some of what John A. Widtsoe was talking about. Unfortunately the article is not freely available, but I've put some highlights below.

He was raised in a conservative Christian home where his father, a Sunday-school teacher, regularly led family Bible study after dinner, and the family attended Church each week.

Godfrey entered college convinced that scientists were engaged in a vast conspiracy to promote evolution. At Bishop's University in Sherbrooke, Quebec, he majored in biology and lived at home, several kilometers away. In one sense, his studies had little effect on his faith. "You can learn facts, and you can do really well on exams and not believe" what you're learning, he says.
Wanting to get to the bottom of the truth about evolution, he enrolled in graduate school. He was able to work with fossils in the laboratory without needing to confront his beliefs, but fieldwork strained his belief that fossils were laid down during Noah's flood.

Godfrey held out from embracing evolution, however, until after moving in 1989 to Drumheller, Alberta, dubbed the "dinosaur capital of the world" because of its diversity of fossils. Godfrey often drove southeast to Dinosaur Provincial Park, passing through a landscape of sediments laid atop one another: deposits from freshwater and terrestrial environments in one, marine organisms and mollusks in another, and a third that mimicked the first, a mix of fossils from fresh water and land. "These animals were living here in this same place, but they couldn't have all been there at the same time," he says, a fact that was irreconcilable with flood geology. It was then that "the rest of the young-Earth creationist ideas kind of exploded."

--------------------------
Godfrey ran through bitterness, anger, and disappointment about having been deceived for so many years. He sought out creationists and confronted them. Late in graduate school, he and his devout Christian wife, mother-in-law, and mother attended a weekend symposium at a Bible school in New York state, where Godfrey says he angrily stood up at the end of a talk and argued passionately with the speaker.

It was there, and in conversations during holiday meals, that Godfrey's parents realized that he had changed. Deeply unhappy, they worried whether their son could endorse an old Earth and remain a Christian. ... Godfrey's father eventually asked that he stop mentioning evolution, as the topic was too upsetting to the family, who believe that their afterlife depends on embracing creationism.

--------------------------
Trying to articulate where his religious beliefs stand now, Godfrey's eyes fill with tears. "It's been so long, a lifelong struggle, to sort out," he says. He has flirted with atheism but found it too depressing. Several years ago, he stopped attending church for a year before returning. He believes in God today, he says, but tomorrow may be different.

--------------------------
Like many creationists-turned-evolutionists, Godfrey is conflicted about how, and how forcefully, to press his case. In 2005, he and his brother-in-law Smith published Paradigms on Pilgrimage, a book describing their own transition and making the case for evolution. His father prayed that it would not be published, and Godfrey did not send his parents a copy. He thought his book would change minds among creationists but isn't sure it has.

"I haven't" read it, says his younger sister Esther Godfrey, of Sherbrooke. "I'm feeling it's a very odd way of viewing the Bible, if you can choose which parts you believe literally and not literally." Esther Godfrey is not sure what turned her brother away from a young Earth, as they've never discussed it. "I know he saw something at some point, maybe a fossil, and thought the Earth has to be old," she says. "That is what I've heard."

--------------------------
When it comes to his children, Godfrey's not sure what they believe nor how firmly to steer them. Certainly, he says, they are exposed to creationist teachings. Of all his children it's his youngest, 4-year-old Victoria, who shows the strongest penchant for science. Wandering the beaches near her home, she often asks to bring home bones she finds, just as her father did years ago. Will her view of the world make room for evolution? Godfrey watches and waits and wonders whether to step in.



Continue reading...

Friday, February 22, 2008

The Scars of John A. Widtsoe

I have loved the following quote ever since I encountered it several years ago. It comes from the preface of Joseph Smith as Scientist, written by John A. Widtsoe. It also seems like an appropriate introduction to a couple of forthcoming posts.

In the life of every person, who receives a higher education, in or out of schools, there is a time when there seems to be opposition between science and religion; between man-made and God-made knowledge. The struggle for reconciliation between the contending forces is not an easy one. It cuts deep into the soul and usually leaves scars that ache while life endures.


Continue reading...

Tuesday, February 19, 2008

Book Review: Evolution: What the Fossils Say and Why It Matters


In his foreword to the book, Michael Shermer calls Evolution: What the Fossils Say and Why It Matters "the best book ever produced on [creationism]." I have not read many other books on creationism, so I cannot comment on Shermer's assessment. However, I agree that it is a fine book and I recommend it for those who want an introduction to creationism, paleontology, and what fossils tell us about the history of life.

Donald Prothero is a professor of geology and paleontology whose career extends at least back to 1980, and he occasionally draws on personal experience when making his case. These experiences give additional weight to his descriptions of fossils--some of which he has studied firsthand--and his explanations of paleontological concepts. For example his treatment of the often misunderstood and abused concept of punctuated equilibrium is clear, and agrees with what I had read elsewhere. (In short, it is the the paleontological application of Ernst Mayr's concept of allopatric speciation.) Perhaps the most notable feature of the book is the many illustrations and photographs depicting either fossils or concepts. (The color plates can be viewed here.) These are quite helpful as aids to understanding and visualizing Prothero's descriptions, and are probably the book's greatest strength.

The chapters are divided into two parts. The first part deals with background issues like the nature of science, the history of creationism (you can read that chapter here), and an introduction to evolution and systematics. The second part is essentially a tour of the history of life on earth from the origins of life to modern humans. Special emphasis is given to transitional fossils between major groups such as fish and tetrapods, dinosaurs and birds, and synapsids and mammals. Short of picking up a paleontology textbook, this is probably one of the friendliest and most convenient introductions to major fossil groups that you will find (or at least that I know of so far).

The final chapter addresses the question of why any of this matters. A number of reasons are given including scientific competitiveness, separation of church and state, and medical progress. Ultimately I think this chapter is probably superfluous. Lovers of science value evolution for its own sake and despise creationist arguments for their corrosive effect on science and public understanding. Those who read the book and still cannot accept evolution will not finally be moved. Nevertheless, it makes for interesting reading.

Now for my complaints:

1. I found a surprisingly high number of grammatically incorrect or jumbled sentences. They occurred frequently enough that I thought that they detracted from the book. Also, in at least a couple of places Prothero dates his writing of a particular passage by referring to current events, which is fine except that it looks funny when he dates a passage to 2005, but then on the next page references a 2007 book. Hopefully future editions will at least fix the English.

2. The enormous scope of the subject is such that Prothero could not frequently dwell on details and still produce a readable popular-science book. Readers who are interested in more details will find many references for further reading. However, the attribution of some claims and quotes are poor. For example reference is made to a New York Times article, but no citation is provided, and quotations used to introduce chapters or subheadings frequently list the author but without the reference from where the quote was taken.

3. Because the subject matter is so broad, Prothero was bound to make some mistakes, especially outside of his own field. For example, the "central dogma" is popularly misunderstood to mean that information flows exclusively from DNA --> RNA --> Protein, so phenomena such as retrotranscription of RNA --> DNA is sometimes claimed (e.g. in this book) to represent a violation of central dogma. But central dogma as originally advanced by Francis Crick is nucleic acid (DNA or RNA --> Protein); retrotranscription is therefore not a violation of central dogma. (In fairness, although central dogma was first advanced by Francis Crick, apparently James Watson later gave a differing version [DNA --> RNA -->Protein], and this is the reason for confusion. Crick's version has not been overturned.)

Another mistake is evident in this passage:

Molecular phylogeny emerged in the 1960s with very crude methods.... Other methods compared the strength of the immune response (more closely related organisms have stronger immune responses than distantly related organisms, because the former have more genes in common than the latter).
That sentence doesn't make any sense. Stronger immune response to what? No reference is provided, but it appears to me that Prothero is a little confused. In early studies rabbits were immunized with human albumin, and then the reactivity of the rabbit antibodies to the albumin protein of various apes and monkeys was evaluated. The strength of reaction indicated similarity of proteins (i.e. fewer mutations), which suggested a closer relationship. (This was before the days of DNA sequencing.)

3. Again, because of scope, Prothero does not usually get into the nitty-gritty of creationist arguments. Creationists will probably complain that he has not given their arguments a full hearing, and occasionally they may have a point. This is unfortunate because some may conclude that Prothero cannot answer the details of creationist arguments.

However, don't let my gripes get in the way. This is not the first book I would recommend to someone with no previous knowledge of evolution, but it very well might be the second.



Continue reading...

Thursday, February 14, 2008

Believing Weird Things

I've been reading Why People Believe Weird Things on part of my work commute. On two separate occasions, I've been asked by co-workers what I was reading. Showing them the book, I half-expect them to say, "Aren't you one of those people?"

The final chapter is "Why Smart People Believe Weird Things." Shermer's criteria for a claim being weird is if it is (i) not accepted by most people in a field of study, (ii) logically impossible or highly unlikely, and/or (iii) supported only by anecdotal or uncorroborated evidence. His summary for why smart people believe such things is,

[S]mart people believe weird things because they are skilled at defending beliefs they arrived at for non-smart reasons.

I couldn't help but think of the claim that, for Mormons, higher education correlates with religiosity. I guess we are in a no-win situation; if we aren't stupid we are good at justification. But there is some truth here, because Mormons are generally the first to admit that their basis for belief is not solely--or even primarily--a rational one.

And so we go to a deeper question: Are non-rational beliefs illegitimate? That's a discussion for another day, but I'll conclude with an interesting quote from Martin Gardner, as quoted by Shermer (p. 275-76).
Skeptics and scientists are not immune. Martin Gardner--one of the founders of the modern skeptical movement and slayer of all manner of weird beliefs--classifies himself as a philosophical theist or, a broader term, a fideist. Gardener explains,
Fideism refers to believing something on the basis of faith, or emotional reasons rather than intellectual reasons. As a fideist I don't think there are any arguments that prove the existence of God or the immortality of the soul. More than that I think the better arguments are on the side of the atheists. So it is a case of quixotic emotional belief that really is against the evidence. If you have strong emotional reasons for metaphysical belief and it's not sharply contradicted by science or logical reasoning, you have a right to make a leap of faith if it provides sufficient satisfaction.




Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP