Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Valentine's Day Science: Solution to the Single Man's Dilemma

It's a problem that haunts many single men I have known: If I marry this girl, how do I know I won't be missing out on an even better one?

Math provides the solution:

[G]o on roughly 10 first dates, with mates who are close to your ideal. If after 10 dates there’s someone you want to go back to and he or she is available, then go for it. But give yourself those 10 first dates.




Continue reading...

Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Commission for the Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice

Commission for the Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice: That's the name of the Saudi Arabian police squad that is making sure that Saudi Arabians are protected from Valentine's Day.

I think BYU students should adopt the name for the Honor Code office. Spread the word!



Continue reading...

Sunday, February 10, 2008

Notable Quotes of Sterling Talmage

I previously introduced the book Can Science Be Faith-Promoting? by Sterling Talmage. Below I have collected a few of what I thought were notable quotes. All italics are as printed in the book.

These first three quotes are from "An Open Letter to Joseph Fielding Smith." Sterling first sent a copy to his father, James E. Talmage, who wrote in reply, "I think it should be put into final shape an sent to its intended addressee without delay.... The conditions are peculiar but in my judgement and in that of certain others it is well to follow the course indicated."

In your boyhood and in mine, the statements of the general authorities of the Church were considered to be final; nobody in good standing in the Church presumed to question them. Today this is not so, and I believe for only one reason, namely, that some of the authorities have made statements that are not worthy of belief... [pg. 213]

My observation has convinced me that positive misstatements by men in authority regarding facts on which they are not informed constitute a stimulus toward skepticism many times more potent than any amount of the whispering regarding the [white horse prophecy], which you so rightly condemn. [p. 214]

But laying all personal feelings aside and speaking solely in the interest of the educated young people of the Church, I feel that if you continue to go outside your field and off your subject, invading at every opportunity the field of earth science in which you are so obviously not well informed, I shall feel justified in letting no chance pass, in speech or writing, to prove point by point that our faith is not founded on absurdity. [p. 215]

If I were forced to make a choice between an acceptance of the truths of nature and some of the stupid, fiatistic dogmas of certain miscalled "fundamentalist" sects, I would choose the truths of nature without any compunction whatever. Fortunately, I am not forced to make such a choice, since I have been taught from my early youth that the gospel is broad enough to include all truth. [p. 155]

...in spite of the definite proof that the total span of earth duration cannot be as brief as seven thousand years, the back part of my mind was still harassed by the echo of a thirty-year-old sermon: The Doctrine and Covenants says that it is! In such a manner, can a misfounded faith persist, even in the face of a truth that flatly contradicts it. [p. 174]

There are some other gems, but I'll leave it at that for now. In fairness I will end with a quote from a letter of Joseph Fielding Smith to Sterling.
There is nothing in all the world so dear to me as revealed truth--the gospel with all its amplifications received through the word of the Lord to his prophets, even in our own day. When I think I find something which tends to destroy the faith of the youth in these revelations, or which is hurtful to this truth, I have opposed it with vigor and have freely expressed my views.




Continue reading...

Wednesday, February 06, 2008

Satanic Panic

Why People Believe Weird Things: Pseudoscience, Superstition, and Other Confusions of Our Time, by Michael Shermer, is similar to Carl Sagan's The Demon-Haunted World. Both cover some of the same ground, including witch-hunts. Shermer discusses some of the psychological and sociological factors that can help mass hysteria--such as witch-hunts--take off, and then turns to the "Satanic panic" of the 1980s and 90s. Satanic cults that did terrible things to animals and babies were perceived as reaching epidemic proportions.

"In the 1970s, there were rumors about dangerous religious cults, cattle mutilations, and Satanic cult ritual animal sacrifices; in the 1980s, we were bombarded by books, articles, and television programs about multiple personality disorder, Procter & Gamble's "Satanic" logo [see above; LDSSR], ritual child abuse, the McMartin Preschool case, and devil worship."
I was a little young and insulated from such things in the 80s, but the list jogged my memory (what about Dungeons and Dragons?). By this time I was thinking of all the Satanic charges fired by anti-Mormons (e.g. pentagrams on the Salt Lake Temple). Continuing:
And the 1990s have given us the ritual child abuse scare in England, reports that the Mormon Church was infiltrated by secret Satanists who sexually abuse children in rituals, and the Satanic ritual abuse scare in San Diego. [pg. 107]
Infiltrated?! According to Ed Decker types (Good ol' Ed. What's he up to these days?) Mormonism was Satanism--in disguise (that's a FARMS link, just in case you were nervous). But Mormonism was just one source of Satanism for Ed. One of my prized possessions (no pun intended--or is it?) is one of Ed's tirades against freemasonry, wherein he shows that the street layout of Washington D.C. has masonic symbols and that the White House is at the southern point of a pentagram--which is why our nation is under siege by the forces of darkness. He bemoans the fact that good Christians who join the Masons unknowingly swear oaths to Satan. Good stuff, but I digress.

As coincidence would have it, just a few days ago I happened to read the Church's policy on Satanism and the occult in the CHI (they're against it). A 1991 letter from the First Presidency advised that they not be topics in Church meetings. The Encyclopedia of Mormonism states that:
At the present time [~1992; LDSSR], symbols related to Satan have become so prevalent that the warning voices of leaders in the Church have again been raised concerning some people's fascination with the power of evil.
Outgrowths of the hysteria, perhaps? Given the Glen L. Pace memo episode (must read), I think so.

[Addendum: Over at DMI, Kevin Barney provided a link with more information about the Satanism scare in Utah.]

[Further Addendum: This post was discussed on a BCC Zeitcast.]


Continue reading...

Monday, February 04, 2008

Thinking Like a Greek

A few weeks ago, for whatever reason, I was thinking of the following quote from Duane Jeffery's Noah’s Flood: Modern Scholarship and Mormon Traditions (pdf):

In conclusion, the distinction between “cosmic history” and “event history” does seem to be a useful one. A framing of the scriptures as cosmic history perceives that scriptural writers primarily intend to teach moral lessons and make it clear that Deity operates in the affairs of men, bolstering in the minds of adherents a sense of meaningful place in a larger scheme of things. This is distinguished from “event history,” the type to which we are presently accustomed and which apparently became the norm only with the Enlightenment. It has been said that in order to understand these distinctions and the nature of scripture as cosmic history, we must learn to think like Hebrews, not like Greeks. Modern society, it seems, thinks like Greeks.

I acknowledge my own personal bent toward “thinking like a Greek,” though I try to blend Hebrew understandings with the science and general approach to the world I derive from the Greeks. But even as I say this, I strongly believe that most of the challenges facing our modern world must be addressed by thinking like a Greek.
It occurred to me that I seemed to remember a similar quote in an Institute manual. I finally found it (having searched the wrong manual a couple of times) in section 54-7 in the New Testament manual:
Sometimes the reader of Revelation is startled by some of the imagery and symbolism used by John. They seem almost bizarre at times in their unusual nature. This is due, however, to a basic difference in cultural background and the use of language. Most members of the Church today are products of Western (Occidental) civilization. The occidental peoples tend to use language like a contractor uses building materials: he builds structures which are concrete in detail and form. But the oriental world, of which the Holy Land was a part, is more artistic in its use of language. Words are but colors with which the artist paints verbal pictures. Thus, the Oriental is usually more concerned with effect than with form and detail. Westerners say the sun is rising, while an Arab may say that it leaps from its bed of sleeping.

John, of course, being Jewish, was a product of Oriental, not Occidental, culture. So his depiction of the Savior as having a sharp, two-edged sword protruding from his mouth is perfectly acceptable, even though the Western mind trying to picture that image concretely may find it somewhat jarring to the sensitivities. To the Eastern mind the symbolism is most appropriate, for such a person is more concerned with the effect of the symbol than with its detail. Pushing the images and symbols of John’s writings for literal interpretation will lead to baffling and sometimes grotesque pictures. But if one remembers the Oriental’s love of imagery, such things as beasts with seven heads and ten horns, armies compared to locusts, and prophets with fire coming from their mouths (11:5; 19:15) will become beautiful and profound symbols of eternal truth.
Although the quotes treat slightly different topics, both highlight the cultural context of scriptural writers and the confusion that can happen when we impose our context onto theirs.



Continue reading...

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

Bible Code; Genome Code

Craig Venter has been working to create an entirely artificial organism. A step toward that goal was achieved when it was announced that a completely synthetic genome has been created. According to the New York Times:

He revealed that the genome had five “watermarks,” sequences of genetic code that would spell words using the letters for the amino acids that would be produced by the DNA.

Wired Science reported Monday that it had ferreted out the messages, with help from government scientists. One watermark said “VenterInstitvte,” using the unusual spelling because there is no amino acid represented by the letter “u.”

The other messages were CraigVenter, HamSmith, GlassandClyde and CindiandClyde for his co-authors Hamilton O. Smith, Clyde A. Hutchison III, John I. Glass and Cynthia Andrews-Pfannkoch. A Venter spokeswoman confirmed them.
Clever, but not all that novel of an idea.

So I'm wondering why Bible Code believers haven't been scouring the human genome for hidden messages from God. Or have they and I just don't know about it? With 3 billion base pairs, there've got to be a few YAHWEH's--in an interesting context, in some language--somewhere.


Continue reading...

Religion, Cladograms, and Mormons Part 2

Thinking about the lineage of religions provides an opportunity to think about another concept in biological relationships: monophyletic vs paraphyletic groups. A monophyletic group consists of a common ancestor and all of its descendants. If some of the descendants are excluded, the group is paraphyletic.

Let's illustrate with reptiles. When you think of reptiles you probably think of turtles, snakes, lizards, and so forth. A 5-year-old would not confuse reptiles with birds. However, birds are descended from a group of dinosaurs, which were reptiles. The term reptile is useful because it carries with it a certain group of characteristics. However, when it comes to taxonomy and relationships, it is paraphyletic because it excludes birds (aves). Including birds would make it monophyletic. Neither method of classification is inherently good or bad; the value depends on what you want to emphasize. The dominant feeling among biologists is that classification should be organized around evolutionary relationships, so groupings should be monophyletic.

It occurs to me that those who exclude Mormons, Jehovah's Witness, Unitarians, etc, from Christianity make Christianity a paraphyletic group because they exclude some religious descendants of original Christianity. Mormons would prefer that Christianity be monophyletic--or at least more inclusively paraphyletic. (Of course religions are not biological organisms, and the whole exercise is an analogy.)

So the next time someone says that Mormons aren't Christians, ask them their justification for making Christianity paraphyletic. If they don't know what you mean, explain using birds and dinosaurs. I think that--chances are--your conversation will become doubly interesting.



Continue reading...

Monday, January 28, 2008

The Passing of President Hinckley


I feel like the blog should officially note the passing of President Gordon B. Hinckley. Perhaps I will eulogize him later. For now I will simply say that I thought he was an inspired man and leader, and I will miss his optimistic voice, his pragmatic attitude, and his self-deprecating wit.

General Conference will never be quite the same. (Who will be the next person to challenge an Apostle to a duel?)


Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP