Sunday, March 25, 2007

FARMS: Abraham, Astronomy and Cosmology

FARMS has made the text of one of their books, Astronomy, Papyrus, and Covenant, available online. The book was brought to my attention by Kevin Barney in his BCC post, Kolob as Sirius. Several of the chapters deal with scientific issues, so I'll give a brief summary of what I've read and then add my two cents.



"Astronomy and the Creation in the Book of Abraham" by Michael D. Rhodes and J. Ward Moody.

This chapter takes a concordist view between the scriptures and science. I tend to think that concordism is a mistaken approach (see here and here), but I still found the chapter refreshing to read because it takes the sciences seriously on the age of the earth, death before the fall, and faunal succession. The authors essentially punt on the topics of pre-Adamites and evolution.
Since the authors of this paper have received their advanced degrees in physics and astronomy, with no formal training in biology, we will take the prudent course and let those who are more knowledgeable on the subject deal with evolution.
Good move on their part. Michael Rhodes is a faculty member of the BYU religion department, and taught my Pearl of Great Price course. (I specifically took it from him for the Facsimiles.) His views on evolution are about what you would expect from a BYU religion professor.


"'And I Saw the Stars': The Book of Abraham and Ancient Geocentric Astronomy," by John Gee, William J. Hamblin, Daniel C. Peterson.

This chapter argues that the astronomy revealed to Abraham was from a geocentric perspective. I think they make a pretty good case; they certainly caused me to see some passages in a different light. We often think of the Book of Abraham as being the most science-friendly of the LDS creation accounts, however, paradoxically, there is an apologetic function served in eschewing concordism for the geocentric perspective. Doing so helps to bolster the notion that the Book of Abraham really reflects ancient teachings rather than nineteenth-century views.

In the appendix, the authors write:
We believe that a careful examination of early cosmologies from LDS scriptures revealed within a few years of each other shows a wide range of conflicting astronomical ideas.
I would like for them to expand on that.


"The Creation of Humankind, and Allegory?: A Note on Abraham 5:7, 14–16," Richard D. Draper.

This chapter essentially argues that the Book of Abraham is the most ancient of the creation accounts, and so it (or an earlier source, or God) is responsible for the apparently allegorical nature of the text, rather than Moses.
Genesis, Moses, and Abraham preserve the "official" account of humankind's entrance into the world as revealed by God. He has not seen fit to reveal more. No official statement of the First Presidency or public revelation by church leaders annuls the story as told in the scriptures. Does that force us to accept the account as historically accurate, or is there some room that God himself has given us an allegoric account?
Draper discusses Brigham Young and Parley Pratt as viewing at least parts as allegorical, but one should also add Spencer Kimball and Bruce McConkie.

Interestingly, Draper argues that Joseph Smith never taught anything other than a literal reading of Adam and Eve's creation. In doing so, he is at odds with others who attempt to connect the idea that Adam and Eve were God's children, physically, to Joseph Smith (usually via Moses 6:22).


Some things I disagree with, and others I am unsure of. However I think that these chapters each contain valuable elements for informing discussions of science and scripture in an LDS context.

Continue reading...

Saturday, March 24, 2007

Blogger Triumphant

Yesterday was my dissertation defense. First I gave a 50 min public presentation regarding my work, followed by a Q&A. Then I met privately with my committee for--I guess it was an hour and a half or so. We discussed my work further and they made me dance and roughed me up a little, but in the end they passed me. Then I went to a ward dinner that my wife was in charge of. How Mormon.

It only feels somewhat triumphant; I've heard from others that the experience is anti-climactic. In spite of the fact that I don't want to read through my dissertation for a long time, I have to do some revisions--a couple of which give me a little bit of heartburn. The worst part is definitely over, but it isn't total relief yet. And I don't feel a whole lot smarter yet; maybe that comes when they put the hood on me.

Aside from finishing the revisions, in the next couple of weeks I will finalize my next job (a postdoc). This will all but certainly involve moving, requiring us to sell our house. Along with the efforts to get our house ready to sell, I still have experiments to do so that I can publish some of my latest work. So it's going to be a busy spring.

And here I thought that I would be able to spend all of my time blogging. I guess I'll have to settle for some.

Continue reading...

Sunday, March 18, 2007

Book Received: Man, His Origin and Destiny

I acquired a copy of Joseph Fielding Smith's Man, His Origin and Destiny, and have begun making my way through it. The book has long been out of print (although it is included in Deseret Book's "Gospelink" collection), however used copies are available for a pretty reasonable price.

My copy has the name of a former owner written on a cover page and contains a number of highlights and markings. These markings are predominantly found in chapters primarily devoted to the exposition of doctrine. In addition, strips of what look like newspaper or mail ads have serve as bookmarks in several places. Again, these are in doctrinal chapters and the bookmarks have been in place long enough to stain the pages brownish.

The copyright page contains this handwritten note:

SaVEOR ATONed in the Spirit World[,] Page. 330.
The passage of interest to this person is actually a quotation of Moses 6:54.
Hence came the saying abroad among the people, that the Son of God hath atoned for original guilt, wherein the sins of the parents cannot be answered upon the heads of the children, for they are whole from the foundation of the world. [underlining by previous owner/reader]
It will be interesting to see what other passages stood out to the former owner/reader.

I expect that the book will serve as future bloging material. I have not yet decided how I want to approach it--whether to give chapter summaries and analysis or just point out and respond to tidbits along the way. Maybe something in between. I'm open to suggestions.


Continue reading...

Tuesday, March 13, 2007

Richard G. Scott on Truth

Yesterday I stumbled upon "Truth", a speech given by Richard G. Scott in 1978. Elder Scott presents two methods of determining truth, the scientific method and prayer. Elder Scott's praise for science has sincerity behind it, he having a nuclear physics background. And I was interested to see a slightly different version of a story he told in the May 2003 General Conference regarding a janitor that thought he and his colleagues were liars. Elder Scott goes on to discuss answers to prayer and provides some practical advice along with examples from his life.

Church-type speeches that discuss the scientific method usually use it as a foil for revelation. Elder Scott does not disappoint in this regard.

The scientific method is a sound and most valuable way of arriving at truth. There are two limitations, however, with that method. First: We never can be sure we have absolute truth, though we often draw nearer and nearer to it. Secondly: Sometimes, no matter how earnestly and sincerely we apply that principle, we come up with the wrong answer.
I heartily agree with Elder Scott here. However it seems to me that these statements also apply to other ways of finding truth, including prayer and revelation. I think that Church history and doctrinal development bear that out. I guess you can't expect a Church authority to make that case, though. On the other hand, most of the examples Elder Scott gives of answered prayer have to do with personal circumstances rather than intellectual questions or ultimate answers.

Elder Scott does not discuss what to do when the two methods collide; it would be interesting to know whether he accepts radiometric dating of fossils older than 4,000 B.C.

Continue reading...

Friday, March 09, 2007

Utah Residents Aid Discovery

You may have already encountered the story about the origin of pubic lice (crabs), as it has been picked up by several news outlets. It makes for an interesting story and illustrates what our parasites tell us about the past.

The best summaries I have seen are by Carl Zimmer and the New York Times.

I noted this line from the New York Times article:

"Dr. Reed’s team collected pubic lice from a public health clinic in Salt Lake City." [emphasis added]


Looks like the bees of the Beehive State have been busy--and contributing to interesting research in the process. Go Utah!



Reed DL, Light JE, Allen JM, Kirchman JJ. Pair of lice lost or parasites regained: the evolutionary history of anthropoid primate lice. BMC Biol. 2007 Mar 7;5(1):7

Continue reading...

Tuesday, March 06, 2007

Ye Scurvinous Primates

One of my favorite short-stories derived from our genome concerns the need for vitamin C in our diet, without which we get scurvy. It may come as a surprise to you that many--perhaps most--animals make their own vitamin C, however primates do not. It may also come as a surprise to you that the reason we cannot make vitamin C is because our gene that codes for the enzyme needed for the final step is broken, a feature that we share with other primates.

I've intended to tell this story for a long time, but Larry Moran at Sandwalk does a nice job, so I'll send you there. See his two posts:

1. Scurvy and Vitamin C
2. Human GULOP Pseudogene

Continue reading...

Friday, March 02, 2007

Chromosomal Theory??

In the course of consulting a genetics book from college, I noticed the following section heading: "Mendelism and the Chromosomal Theory".

And here I was taught about chromosomes as if they were facts. And isn't Mendelism dead?

Teach the controversy.



Disclaimer: Yes, I'm being sarcastic.

Continue reading...

Wednesday, February 28, 2007

Understanding Trichotomy

Are you more closely related to a sibling or a first cousin? The answer is obvious, but the question is not as silly as it sounds. If you were trying to determine the relationship of three people (two siblings and a first cousin) based on their DNA sequence, you would get contradictory information. For most informative loci, you would make the correct conclusion. However some of the time you would erroneously group the cousin and one of the siblings together because they shared genes that were absent in the other sibling. So overall, you are more closely related (genetically) to your sibling, but there are parts of your genome where your cousin is your closest relative.

Applying this scenario to a larger scale helps us to understand the trichotomy problem in determining species relationships, such as the relationship between humans, chimpanzees, and gorillas. You've probably heard that our genome sequence is very similar (94-98.5%, depending on how you measure) to chimpanzees. The problem is that both genomes are also very similar to gorilla. Depending on where you look, you might group gorillas and humans together, or gorillas and chimpanzees together. The problem is illustrated in panel A of the the following figure [1]. (Click for larger image.)



The meaning of PI-characters and RGCs is not important here. All you need to know is that, along with genes, these are characteristics in genomes that can be compared. As the figure shows, in most cases the human-chimpanzee relationship is supported, however in a minority of cases other relationships are supported.

Why is there support for alternative relationships? The answer is analogous to the sibling/cousin relationship scenario above. Humans, chimpanzees and gorillas each have their roots in a common gene pool. However, the sorting of ancestral polymorphic alleles in the diverging lineages is subject to evolutionary processes such as genetic drift. Thus purely by chance, alleles can become fixed in a way that gives a different picture than the true species-branching pattern.

The concept is illustrated in the following figure [2]:



Here, the broad lines represent what the true relationship of humans, chimpanzees, and gorillas is thought to be. The colored lines represent hypothetical gene polymorphisms. Notice that the true species relationship can differ from that inferred by looking only at the polymorphisms (esp. HG and CG, which give results as in panel A of the first figure).





1. Rokas A, Carroll SB (2006) Bushes in the Tree of Life. PLoS Biol 4(11)

2. Hobolth A, Christensen OF, Mailund T, Schierup MH (2007) Genomic Relationships and Speciation Times of Human, Chimpanzee, and Gorilla Inferred from a Coalescent Hidden Markov Model. PLoS Genet 3(2): e7

Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP