Tuesday, March 13, 2007

Richard G. Scott on Truth

Yesterday I stumbled upon "Truth", a speech given by Richard G. Scott in 1978. Elder Scott presents two methods of determining truth, the scientific method and prayer. Elder Scott's praise for science has sincerity behind it, he having a nuclear physics background. And I was interested to see a slightly different version of a story he told in the May 2003 General Conference regarding a janitor that thought he and his colleagues were liars. Elder Scott goes on to discuss answers to prayer and provides some practical advice along with examples from his life.

Church-type speeches that discuss the scientific method usually use it as a foil for revelation. Elder Scott does not disappoint in this regard.

The scientific method is a sound and most valuable way of arriving at truth. There are two limitations, however, with that method. First: We never can be sure we have absolute truth, though we often draw nearer and nearer to it. Secondly: Sometimes, no matter how earnestly and sincerely we apply that principle, we come up with the wrong answer.
I heartily agree with Elder Scott here. However it seems to me that these statements also apply to other ways of finding truth, including prayer and revelation. I think that Church history and doctrinal development bear that out. I guess you can't expect a Church authority to make that case, though. On the other hand, most of the examples Elder Scott gives of answered prayer have to do with personal circumstances rather than intellectual questions or ultimate answers.

Elder Scott does not discuss what to do when the two methods collide; it would be interesting to know whether he accepts radiometric dating of fossils older than 4,000 B.C.

Continue reading...

Friday, March 09, 2007

Utah Residents Aid Discovery

You may have already encountered the story about the origin of pubic lice (crabs), as it has been picked up by several news outlets. It makes for an interesting story and illustrates what our parasites tell us about the past.

The best summaries I have seen are by Carl Zimmer and the New York Times.

I noted this line from the New York Times article:

"Dr. Reed’s team collected pubic lice from a public health clinic in Salt Lake City." [emphasis added]


Looks like the bees of the Beehive State have been busy--and contributing to interesting research in the process. Go Utah!



Reed DL, Light JE, Allen JM, Kirchman JJ. Pair of lice lost or parasites regained: the evolutionary history of anthropoid primate lice. BMC Biol. 2007 Mar 7;5(1):7

Continue reading...

Tuesday, March 06, 2007

Ye Scurvinous Primates

One of my favorite short-stories derived from our genome concerns the need for vitamin C in our diet, without which we get scurvy. It may come as a surprise to you that many--perhaps most--animals make their own vitamin C, however primates do not. It may also come as a surprise to you that the reason we cannot make vitamin C is because our gene that codes for the enzyme needed for the final step is broken, a feature that we share with other primates.

I've intended to tell this story for a long time, but Larry Moran at Sandwalk does a nice job, so I'll send you there. See his two posts:

1. Scurvy and Vitamin C
2. Human GULOP Pseudogene

Continue reading...

Friday, March 02, 2007

Chromosomal Theory??

In the course of consulting a genetics book from college, I noticed the following section heading: "Mendelism and the Chromosomal Theory".

And here I was taught about chromosomes as if they were facts. And isn't Mendelism dead?

Teach the controversy.



Disclaimer: Yes, I'm being sarcastic.

Continue reading...

Wednesday, February 28, 2007

Understanding Trichotomy

Are you more closely related to a sibling or a first cousin? The answer is obvious, but the question is not as silly as it sounds. If you were trying to determine the relationship of three people (two siblings and a first cousin) based on their DNA sequence, you would get contradictory information. For most informative loci, you would make the correct conclusion. However some of the time you would erroneously group the cousin and one of the siblings together because they shared genes that were absent in the other sibling. So overall, you are more closely related (genetically) to your sibling, but there are parts of your genome where your cousin is your closest relative.

Applying this scenario to a larger scale helps us to understand the trichotomy problem in determining species relationships, such as the relationship between humans, chimpanzees, and gorillas. You've probably heard that our genome sequence is very similar (94-98.5%, depending on how you measure) to chimpanzees. The problem is that both genomes are also very similar to gorilla. Depending on where you look, you might group gorillas and humans together, or gorillas and chimpanzees together. The problem is illustrated in panel A of the the following figure [1]. (Click for larger image.)



The meaning of PI-characters and RGCs is not important here. All you need to know is that, along with genes, these are characteristics in genomes that can be compared. As the figure shows, in most cases the human-chimpanzee relationship is supported, however in a minority of cases other relationships are supported.

Why is there support for alternative relationships? The answer is analogous to the sibling/cousin relationship scenario above. Humans, chimpanzees and gorillas each have their roots in a common gene pool. However, the sorting of ancestral polymorphic alleles in the diverging lineages is subject to evolutionary processes such as genetic drift. Thus purely by chance, alleles can become fixed in a way that gives a different picture than the true species-branching pattern.

The concept is illustrated in the following figure [2]:



Here, the broad lines represent what the true relationship of humans, chimpanzees, and gorillas is thought to be. The colored lines represent hypothetical gene polymorphisms. Notice that the true species relationship can differ from that inferred by looking only at the polymorphisms (esp. HG and CG, which give results as in panel A of the first figure).





1. Rokas A, Carroll SB (2006) Bushes in the Tree of Life. PLoS Biol 4(11)

2. Hobolth A, Christensen OF, Mailund T, Schierup MH (2007) Genomic Relationships and Speciation Times of Human, Chimpanzee, and Gorilla Inferred from a Coalescent Hidden Markov Model. PLoS Genet 3(2): e7

Continue reading...

Saturday, February 24, 2007

Weird People in Utah

Of course there are weird people everywhere. However--

The September 2006 issue of Survey Notes, a publication of the Utah Geological Survey, contains a list of odd questions that their geologists have been asked. I've put the best ones (in my opinion) below.

“As many as 13 black helicopters land, become bright, and then fly away…. They have stolen most of a 350-foot cliff called the Lace Curtain (a black basalt volcanic feature)…. What would be the best way of stopping them?”

“My horse found a gold nugget but now I can’t find the location. Is it possible the Green River has moved its course several miles in the last decade?”

“I am looking for some very, very remote land…. I want it so remote that I will have to walk for three days to get to it. Will you please send me the information I need? The gentleman in Washington told me that the states would have this information….”

“Do you have a map to the Lost Rhodes gold mine?” ( The Lost Rhodes gold mine is a mythical Spanish gold mine allegedly located somewhere in the Uinta Mountains.)

“I found a carving from Spanish explorers (who were in Utah over 200 years ago) on an aspen tree (individual trunks have an average lifespan of less than 100 years)…. Can you help me find the Lost Rhodes gold mine?”

“I was talking to this guy the other day…. He said that everyone knows that the whole Salt Lake Valley sits above a large cavern and that downtown is going to fall about a quarter mile during an earthquake. When I heard this I just laughed. Then, the next day I was reading some stuff on the Internet about very large caverns, occupied by colonies of lizard people, that extend deep beneath the Western Rockies as well as beneath the Bonneville basin…. Can you give me more information?”

“Are you aware of a submarine village under the Great Salt Lake? It belongs to a fine American family that shares it with hundreds of other Utahns….”

“I am very happy to declare that there is an exact relationship between launching of satellites and natural disasters like volcanic eruptions, earthquakes, El NiƱos, and hurricanes…. Would you like to know more? I am very excited and happy to discuss this data with you because our southern region is in danger of earthquakes after launching from Cape Canaveral….”

“I have been quarrying Cambrian-age quartzite dinosaurs….Can you verify the authenticity of my many astounding discoveries?”

That last one may have more than one thing wrong with it, but I know one thing: there were no Cambrian-age dinosaurs.

Oh, and do a little Google searching using terms in the lizard-people paragraph, and you'll find some treats.

Continue reading...

Thursday, February 22, 2007

Genesis and Generation

Having just finished Generation, I had another look at Genesis 1. I think that a pre-seventeenth century reader would have little to quarrel with. The water and earth bringing forth life-forms fits quite nicely with spontaneous generation, which makes me wonder if anybody referred to Genesis in defense of the concept. Another curiosity is that only plants are described as having "seed after [their] kind". Animals do too, so why is it only mentioned for plants? (Plants also have sex, you know. And what we call a seed is actually a plant embryo.)

Once again I am reminded of James E. Talmage's statement:

The opening chapters of Genesis, and scriptures related thereto, were never intended as a text-book of geology, archeology, earth-science or man-science.

Continue reading...

Tuesday, February 20, 2007

I've got an AIDS cure I want to sell you.

Would you like the Iranian-national pride version or the Gambian-pray-and-paste version?

"Whatever you do, there are bound to be skeptics, but I can tell you my method is foolproof....Mine is not an argument, mine is a proof. It’s a declaration. I can cure AIDS and I will." --Gambian President, Yahya Jammeh

Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP