Tuesday, March 22, 2005

Terri Schiavo: It's Either Cruel or Not--Pick One

I wasn't going to post again about Terri Schiavo again--it's such a circus. But there has been some discussion in the bloggernacle here, here, and here, so I just want to say my piece. (I also posted once before here.)

Continue Reading


I have no reason to disbelieve doctors who say that she is not conscious and that her movements, such as smiles, are actually involuntary reflexes. I am therefore alright with letting her pass on. On the other hand since her family is so against it, it seems like the honorable thing for her husband to do is to give them full custody and move on. I agree with Kaimi at T&S that much of the current argument is over evidentiary nuances and politics. I think both sides of the debate raise legitimate issues. However some things that people are saying drive me crazy.

First, on talk-radio people talk with disgust and horror about how Terri is going to be starved to death--it's so barbaric. Yet they turn around and emphasize the importance of a living will. They seem to be saying that the withdrawl of the feeding tube is only cruel and wrong unless the person left a living will stating that they don't want to be kept alive artificially. It seems to me that the issue of whether it is cruel or not is independent of Terri's pre-injury wishes. If it is cruel, are we prepared to euthanize when someone doesn't want to be kept alive artificially? I doubt conservatives would go for that--slippery slope, you know. If it isn't cruel then talking about how horrible the manner of death is, is really an appeal to emotion, not reason.

Second is the hyperbole. I have repeatedly heard people say that we don't even treat our animals this way. One person even said that if we did, we'd be "taken out and shot." Good grief--is this supposed to convince anybody? We put animals down all the time--healthy or not. And that's just the domesticated ones. Others we shoot, poison, trap, etc.

I think that the complexities of this case make it very easy to "look beyond the mark."

Continue reading...

Monday, March 21, 2005

Rubella Banished From U.S.

According to this article, Rubella (the "R" in MMR vaccine) has been elminated from the U.S. The only reported cases in the last year have been imported.

Continue Reading


Rubella, also commonly known as German measles, soft measles or three-day measles, is a usually mild viral infection that causes a fever and a rash.

But early in pregnancy it can cause birth defects ranging from deafness to severe brain damage and death.

"During 1964 and 1965 a rubella epidemic in the United States caused an estimated 12.5 million cases of rubella and 20,000 cases of congenital rubella syndrome which led to more than 11,600 babies born deaf, 11,250 fetal deaths, 2,100 neonatal (newborn) deaths, 3,580 babies born blind and 1,800 babies born mentally retarded," the CDC said in a statement.

A vaccine was licensed in 1969 and since then the rubella virus has been included in the measles, mumps and rubella or MMR combined vaccine routinely given to babies and young children.

Now the CDC estimates that 93 percent of the nation's children younger than 2 get the vaccine.


Of course, this doesn't mean we stop vaccinating. Importation of the virus is always a threat, but this is good progress.

Continue reading...

Friday, March 18, 2005

Petrified Wood at Meridian Magazine

Meridian Magazine recently posted an article about petrified wood. You can find the article here. The authors comment on a news story that reports that scientists have been able to petrify wood in the laboratory in a short amount of time. They raise the question of how long it actually takes petrifaction to occur in nature. Rather than millions of years, they suggest a much shorter amount of time. They wonder whether decay processes require a short timescale for petrifaction.

Continue Reading


Now the issue of petrifaction is interesting enough, but their purpose in writing the article appears to be to neutralize arguments against a young earth or worldwide flood. They seem to think that some petrified wood could be a result of Noah's flood--that the timescale is plausible. However, they state that they are not trying to be dogmatic about age of the earth or flood issues. They also propose that the reason that science does not convincingly point to God is because it would degrade the testing ground of mortality. Finally as proof-of-principle that petrifaction can occur quickly, they discuss a wall in England where objects placed in the flow of highly mineralized water petrify in months.

In discussing the petrifaction process they offer only a couple of references--one of them World Book Encyclopedia. Now I don't mean to be snobbish or anything, but World Book Encyclopedia? Is that really the most authoritative source they could dig up? Wouldn't a geology textbook or an interview with a geologist be a little more authoritative? I'm not saying that the encyclopedia information is incorrect, just that if they really want answers to their questions a more authoritative and specialized source would be prudent.

Well, I don't have time to go to the library and research the issue--although next time I'm there I may see what I can find--but I did some internet searching as well. I found this page on the North Dakota Geologic Survey website. It seems to answer some of the questions about petrifaction. The specimen is buried in a manner that excludes oxygen--thus slowing, if not halting, the decay process. It also points out that various amounts of detail are retained. Perhaps this reflects varying amounts of decay. Oh, and there is an "ask a geologist" feature. As for the time required, my limited reading suggests that it depends on the circumstances. It seems obvious to me that the concentration of the relevant minerals would be an important factor, as illustrated by the wall discussed in their article.

One other thing about the article struck me as strange. They refer to Christian Sunday school manuals and then quote from Gospel Principles. Now the book is a Sunday school manual for us, and we do consider ourselves Christian. It's just that their use of a generic designation suggested to me that the quote would come from another denomination.

As to the issue of testing in mortality--I don't disagree with their basic suggestion. However, I wonder if they would go the next step to arguing that the many evidences that contradict the young-earth view of the earth are deliberately made to test us. I don't want to put words in their mouth. However I find this extension of the argument distasteful because not only does it mean that God is deliberately tricking us (or perhaps allowing us to be tricked by Satan), but the whole charade was orchestrated for the very tail end of mortality (assuming the Second Coming is within a couple hundred years.) It has only been within the last couple of hundred years that we have begun to understand physics, geology, and biology in unprecedented depth and accuracy. Why, in all of human history, are we the ones who need to be tricked? Isn't that a lot of work to go through just to "test" of few of us?

Ultimately I don't think that the time required for petrifaction is that important of an issue in our understanding of the history of the earth and life on it.

Continue reading...

Thursday, March 17, 2005

Review of Defeating Darwinism

I recently checked out Defeating Darwinism by Opening Minds, by Phillip Johnson, from the library and thought I would share my thoughts on it. Hopefully in the process I can clarify why I do not support the Intelligent Design movement, which is primarily lead by the Discovery Institute. Please note the following abbreviations I will be using: DD = Defeating Darwinism; ID = Intelligent Design; IC = Irreducible Complexity.

Continue Reading


DD was published in 1997 and follows Darwin on Trial and Reason in the Balance, written by Johnson, as well as Darwin's Black Box, written by Michael Behe. (See here for my review of Behe's book, as well as my first post about intelligent design. Because some of the arguments apply here, also see my post on the randomness of evolution.) I have not read Johnson's other books.

The purpose of DD was to provide a simple, straightforward explanation of ID and criticism of evolutionary theory that could be understood by someone in high school. It is less than 150 pages and is a easy read. If you want to quickly determine where Johnson is coming from, I recommend this book. One of the broad purposes of this book, and Johnson's work in general, is to help enable students to maintain religious faith in the face of the mountain of evolutionary theory. He seems genuinely concerned that people are needlessly jettisoning their faith (especially Christian faith) and wants to help. In this respect I am sympathetic. It is his approach and conclusions that I disagree with.

Johnson begins the book by relating how some students try to reconcile their faith with science. The reconciliation is usually some form of theistic evolution--that God used evolution in his creative processes. Johnson argues that no reconciliation can be made because evolution is based on naturalism/materialism and therefore, by definition, excludes God. Therefore science, and education in general, must be stripped of naturalistic assumptions. His argument is essentially an ultimatum--choose God or naturalism. He writes:

The evolutionary story is a story of humanity's climb from animal beginnings to rationality, not a story of a fall from perfection. It is a story about learning to rely entirely on human intelligence, not a story of the helplessness of that intelligence in the face of the inescapable fact of sin.

There is no satisfactory way to bring two such fundamentally different stories together, although various bogus intellectual systems offer a superficial compromise to those who are willing to overlook a logical contradiction or two. A clear thinker simply has to go one way or another.

Unfortunately, I do not believe either story is free of logical contradictions. It is for this reason that I believe that when the whole truth is known, there will be a perfect compromise. False dichotomies are easy to make.

He goes on to discuss issues of critical thinking, ID and IC, and then quite frankly and openly discusses the overall cultural strategy he is charting. He also lays out his general critiques of the evidence supporting evolutionary theory. Prominent among them is the fossil record, and he includes the usual quotes from Eldridge and Gould admitting to its weaknesses. (Scientists, including Eldridge and Gould, insist that their arguments have not been properly understood. Neither Johnson nor I are paleontologists so I will not engage this argument. However, note that evidence for common descent does not rest on fossils alone.) He also tries to draw a distinction between the medium of DNA and the message it contains, arguing that the message could not have come about by chance. My following comments will be a mixture of reaction to the book and ID in general.

The critical problem with ID, in terms of science, is testability. If God has intervened in the development of life on earth, how would we know it? Proponents of ID argue that design can be detected by positive evidence. What is this positive evidence? The answer is IC. But the very notion and implications of IC are disputed--or ignored--by mainstream science. And at root, IC is an argument from ignorance--we don't know how something could have evolved by natural means and therefore it must have been designed. It is a subtle trick to turn an argument from ignorance into "positive evidence"--create a category that is derived from an argument from ignorance, find a biological system that fits the criteria of your category, then call that positive evidence for design.

What I don't think many people realize is that ID really cannot get them what they want. For the sake of argument, let's say that IC is a legitimate concept and really does indicate ID. The reason it can detect design is because it is the only marker that can distinguish natural processes from intelligent ones. In other words, it distinguishes organisms created with ID from those related just by common descent. The IC systems that have been proposed thus far might distinguish some higher taxa, but most species and genera would probably be unaffected. For example, what kind of IC system would distinguish chimpanzees from humans? The only IC systems proposed so far are things like vision, the immune system, blood clotting, and cilia. Both humans and chimpanzees--most vertebrates for that matter--have all of those. Given the very high degree of DNA identity between these two species, I think it is highly unlikely that any IC biochemical systems will be identified to differentiate them. With the main tool of ID being useless in distinguishing between humans and chimpanzees, we are left with naturalism. So we can infer ID throughout the tree of life except where it really counts--us. The concepts of IC and ID are therefore useless to anybody hoping to establish that humans are uniquely created apart from the rest of the animal kingdom and we are essentially left with a concept that Johnson finds unacceptable--naturalism/materialism responsible for the ultimate creation of humans!

My point here is not to argue that mankind are merely animals or that God has nothing to do with our creation. It is to show that ID is utterly useless to show otherwise where the theological stakes are highest. If the tools of ID cannot establish a unique creation for humans, does the rest really matter?

As I stated above, Johnson spends some time drawing a distinction between the information contained in DNA and the medium of the information (ie. the DNA itself.) He argues that it is ID that is responsible for the information contained in DNA. This is because matter cannot organize itself to contain information--just as ink and paper have no ability to produce words and sentences. I'm not quite sure I fully understand his argument here, and I'm not prepared to persue it. I'll just say that his analogies are fundamentally different than biological processes and they smell funny to me--but I can't quite put my finger on it yet.

If you have any question about whether cultural issues are really at the bottom of the ID movement, just read the last few chapters. Johnson believes that, like Freud and Marx, Darwin must be overthrown. He blames naturalism/materialism for social and moral decay, and he issues a Christian call to arms to help overthrow materialism.

Although I disagree him on a number of issues, I think Johnson and I can agree on this: all people should know more about science and the assumptions and philosophies that govern it. Whereas Johnson thinks that the rules governing science are arbitrary and in need of overhaul, I think that they are necessary and should be maintained. However I also support clear explanations of what they are and why they are needed. With a proper understanding of the issues involved, I believe students can make good (not just reactionary) judgments as to how much of their worldview should be shaped by science, and how much by religion.

Continue reading...

Let's Start Light

Well I'm back, and I see the blogesphere has been quite active in my absence. So I'm going to start light by linking to this post at The Panda's Thumb that explains why "teaching the controversy" over evolution is a bad idea. It makes some great points.

As I see it, if you wanted to teach the non-existent controversy in public schools, there’s only one way you could do it and give it justice. First, you’d have to give the students a very thorough background in biology and evolutionary theory. You could then introduce the ID claims and the mainstream scientific responses, and the responses to those responses, etc. You could then take things a step further and have students “critically examine” the scientific evidence, including reading important contributions to the literature. The problem is, once you manage to successfully do all this, the kids are ready to graduate college.

Now technically the Discovery Institute does not advocate teaching ID in classrooms. They only advocate teaching "evidence" against evolution. (They seem to use this strategy a lot, like how they decline to identify the IDer, thus allowing them to officially deny criticisms against them while allowing popular perception to do their work for them.)The points in this post apply nonetheless.

Continue reading...

Saturday, March 12, 2005

Administrative Notice

I'll be unavailable for blogging for a few days, so you can either ponder some of my past posts or go have a look at the other quality blogs in the bloggernacle. But don't get too attached, because I'll want you back later next week.

-The Management

Continue reading...

Random Until Further Notice

I believe that much of the anxiety that people express about evolution is rooted in a single concept--its randomness. After all, if evolution accounts for the existence and diversity of life and is truly random, we have a number of theological difficulties on our hands. The scriptures clearly teach concepts of planning and foreordination, and so would seem to be at odds with evolutionary theory. As we shall see, if we really probe this problem to its depth we will get into unanswerable questions concerning the foreknowledge of God. These kinds of questions have been kicked around for a long time by people much smarter than I am. I doubt that definitive answers are available in this life. Rather than get into philosophical speculation I want to discuss the nature of science and its limitations.

Continue Reading


Like many other fields of study, evolution is usually a study of history. Based on present experiments and observation, and on evidence from the past, scientists are able to reconstruct processes and events that have lead to conditions we see today. However just like other studies of history, reconstruction of the past is of limited use in predicting the future with precision.

Let's take climatology and meteorology as an example. If we wanted to learn about past weather conditions we would pursue several avenues of research. We would gather records that contained measurements of past weather data. We would look at things affected by weather such as agriculture. We might also look at remaining physical evidence, such as tree rings, for indications of flood, rain, or drought. All of this together would give us a good picture of what happened in past weather systems. But as we all know, it is of limited use in making specific predictions about future weather. This is because the number of variables involved are enormous. But we can ask a rhetorical question here: does God know whether it will rain on my house a year from today?

Let's look at a biological example: cancer. In many types of cancer the root genetic problem can be identified. While some people may have a predisposition to certain cancers, others apparently do not. Yet exact predictions about whether a person will get cancer cannot be made because of the enormous number of variables in play. On the predictive side, all we can do is talk in terms of probabilities.

Now let's ask some questions: Does God know who will get cancer? Does he know which particular cell will start the cancer? Does he know what the specific cause will be? Does God cause all cancers? Are all cancers a result of pure chance? If God did, from time to time, cause a person to get cancer (as a trial, for example), could we identify those instances by scientific means?

These same types of problems and questions apply not only to evolution, but other areas of biology, medicine, public health, multiple areas of physics, cosmology, astronomy, linguistics, anthropology, ecology, geography--all areas of life, really. We do not have a way to distinguish any direct role God has played in these things from natural processes, except through revelation. But since revelation is largely non-transferable, we prefer natural explanations until God specifically identifies his role. (These issues also touch on why I am not hot on the intelligent design movement.)

So let's not fret over whether life's origin and diversity is a result of chance or not. Scientists talk in terms of chance and randomness because, whether they believe it's the whole story or not, they cannot do otherwise.

[This is a cross-post from Mormons and Evolution. Clicking comments will re-direct you there.]

Comments

Continue reading...

Friday, March 11, 2005

ID in Arkansas

According to the NCSE, a bill has been introduced in the Arkansas house of representatives which,

"if enacted, the bill would require the state Department of Education to include "intelligent design" in its educational frameworks and encourage teachers in the state to include it in their lesson plans."


Since the Discovery Institute claims that they oppose teaching ID in schools (just criticisms of "Darwinsim," which leaves--what?) it will be interesting to see if they oppose this bill.

More on ID later.

Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP