Tuesday, February 22, 2005

The Prophecy of Joel

Concerning the prophecy of Joel that the spirit of the Lord would be poured out upon all flesh, Joseph Fielding Smith said:

There has never been a step taken from that day to this, in discovery or invention, where the Spirit of the Lord (that is, the spirit of which Joel spoke, the Light of Christ, not the Holy Ghost!) was not the prevailing force, resting upon the individual, which caused him to make the discovery or the invention. The world does not understand that but it is perfectly clear to me; nor did the Lord always use those who have faith, nor does he always do so today. He uses such minds as are pliable and can be turned in certain directions to accomplish his work, whether they believe in him or not. (Doctrines of Salvation 1 p.178)


Continue Reading


(Commenting on this passage in his foreword to Evolution and Mormonism, Duane Jeffery writes, "I suppose that Joseph Fielding Smith may not have meant to include Charles Darwin and evolution in this sweeping idealism, though in this particular passage he did not qualify his sentiment at all.")

When we eventually learn of "things as they really were," it will be interesting to find out which scientific advancements were specifically inspired and which were not. My impression of most science is that it is not any more inspired than any other line of work. A detective, for example, probably uses much of the same thought processes as a scientist does.

So why, in all of human history, are we so lucky to have such advancement in the sciences? I don't claim to know the whole answer but I have a couple of thoughts. First, it is interesting to note that advancements in one field of science make advancements in other fields possible. I think most of the sciences owe much to physics and engineering because they have produced equipment and instruments that have allowed exploration of new areas of research. Molecular biology could never have preceded the principles of microscopy, radioactivity, and so forth. Computers have revolutionized the world--including the sciences. So a few foundational advancements can have a broad and lasting effect.

Even more fundamental, I think, are the principles on which this nation was founded and has continued--liberty, economic freedom, commitment to education, etc. (Of course I would also include other countries that share these principles.) These principles have enabled us to live in relative peace and prosperity, which in turn has enabled us to think about greater questions than where the next meal will come from. Furthermore scientific inquiry has been largely free from political domination or religious dogma.

So I see the role of special inspiration in science mostly in the fostering of a climate where scientific research can be carried out, with a few directly inspired foundational ideas from time to time.

Continue reading...

Politics and Science

AP has a story about scientists feeling stifled in the Bush administration.

Continue Reading


Kurt Gottfried of Cornell University and the Union of Concerned Scientists said a survey of scientists in the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service found that about 42 percent said they felt pressured to not report publicly any findings that do not agree with Bush policies on endangered species.

He said almost a third of the Fish and Wildlife researchers said they were even pressured not to express within the agency any views in conflict with the Bush policies.

"This administration has distanced itself from scientific information," said Gottfried. He said this is part of a larger effort to let politics dominate pure science.

He said scientists in the Environmental Protection Agency have been pressured to change their research to keep it consistent with the Bush political position on environmental issues.

Because of such actions, he said, it has become more difficult for federal agencies to attract and retain top scientific talent. This becomes a critical issue, said Gottfried, because about 35 percent of EPA scientists will retire soon and the Bush administration can "mold the staff" of the agency through the hiring process.

I'll readily admit that scientists have their own interests--funding, career advancement, etc. And I also realize that policy makers have to weigh many factors in the decisions they make, and the recommendations of scientists may not always be top priority. But scientists should not be pressured to tailor findings in order to support political decisions. To whatever extent this happens--under any administration--it is wrong.

Continue reading...

Your Mouth is a Niche

The Panda's Thumb has an overview of dental plaque. It looks like a rather complex structure/community of microbes. There's a pot-shot at ID at the end that doesn't seem well grounded. On the other hand, if some of those microbes only colonize human mouths, then we have to start asking some questions that might make creationists squirm.

Continue reading...

Monday, February 21, 2005

Voodoo Medicine

Our family has been afflicted with conjunctivitis lately, and it has been making its way around the ward. I know your first thought is "nursery", but that doesn't seem to be the central problem in this case. Anyway, we called our daughter's pediatrician and were prescribed some eye-drops with antibiotics. Now, we don't really know whether the agent here is viral or bacterial. The ease of transmission leads me to believe it is viral, but I'm not sure. Of course if it is viral, not much can be done--you just have to wait it out.

A friend of ours decided to try a home remedy. She treated her eye with her own breast milk.



Continue Reading


It seems like some people studiously try to avoid modern medicine. I just don't understand the mentality. Otherwise reasonable people--fellow saints, no less--sometimes go wacko when it comes to medicine. It is manifested in refusals to have children vaccinated, turning to folk remedies before calling a doctor, insisting on giving birth at home with a mid-wife, buying groceries at special "organic" stores, and protesting fluoridation of water.

I can understand turning to alternative medicine when mainstream medicine doesn't seem to have an answer. And I can understand trying a home remedy in hopes of saving on medical costs. But some people seem to seek out the alternative way. I guess they must have a deep distrust of mainstream medicine--in spite of its amazing successes and praise by prophets.

Why do some people seem to wish for the days of high infant mortality, low life expectancy, and general morbidity? Is it a desire for self-sufficiency gone wrong? What about a desire to identify with the hardships of our pioneer ancestors? Is it a lack of education about science and medicine? Maybe it is just plain irrationality.

Oh by the way, I guess the breast milk didn't do much for our friend. So I recommend you call a doctor instead.

Continue reading...

Sunday, February 20, 2005

Review of Darwin's Black Box

I first read Michael Behe's book, Darwin's Black Box (DBB), while on vacation in London over 4 years ago. The book has now been available for 9 years and has been the subject of much discussion. I recently re-read much of the book so I could review it here. Although I have certainly absorbed some of my thinking from other sources, I have intentionally not read reviews of Behe's book lately so that I could exercise my own mind. Following my comments on the book I will link to other critical reviews that may add to or supercede mine.


Continue Reading


The goal of DBB is to argue for intelligent design in biology, and provide criteria whereby we may recognize it. Behe is a biochemist at Lehigh University and also a part of the Discovery Institute's Center for Science and Culture. DBB follows books written by other CSC fellows including Of Pandas and People, Darwin on Trial, and others. The apparent goal of DBB was to use science to support the philosophy presented in the previous books (which I have not read).

Behe argues that design in biology can safely be inferred if a system is irreducibly complex (IC). This means that a biological system that performs a specific task has a number of components, each of which are required in order for the system to work. He argues that if a system is IC, it could not have evolved in a step-by-step manner because it would not confer any benefits that could be selected for. Therefore someone or something with intelligence must have designed it.

Behe cites several biological systems as IC. The principal examples are: the biochemical reactions that make vision possible, the bacterial flagellum, the blood-clotting cascade, and the immune system. I will not deal with these systems directly nor will I get into detailed biological systems because others have already done so.

General Impressions:

Behe identifies himself as Catholic so he writes from the perspective of a believer in God. Had the purpose of this book been solely to communicate how he sees the hand of God in biology, I would be less critical. We are all entitled to our own opinions, impressions, and insights, and sharing them can be helpful to others. I think Behe makes a reasonably good argument that the believer need not surrender their faith in the face of science. The book could have helped to calm the conflict between science and religion. Instead, Behe (along with others) is trying to revolutionize science. Instead of calming, the book is an instrument of attack, which helps explain the vigorous response to it.

Argument from ignorance:

As has been pointed out repeatedly, a fundamental problem with IC is that it is an argument from ignorance. Instead of offering positive evidence for design, IC argues that the system under investigation could not have arisen through natural means and therefore must be designed. This is an assumption based on ignorance. Just because the mechanism of the origin of a system is not known today does not mean it will not be discovered in the future. Furthermore, once the label of "design" is applied to a biological system, it would be very difficult to remove because it will be virtually impossible to absolutely prove that a system was not designed--at least to the satisfaction of proponents of design. Also Behe writes, "Design theory has nothing to say about a biochemical or biological system unless all the components of the system are known and it is demonstrated that the system is composed of several interacting parts." To a certain extent this also requires an assumption since, although a system may be well characterized, additional components may be discovered in the future.

Moving goal posts:

Behe discusses several examples of complex biological systems where an evolutionary precursor has been proposed. He then argues that the proposal doesn't prove anything because it does not explain where the components of the system came from. This is a misleading argument because it changes the question. For example, after discussing the argument that pseudogenes are evidence of evolution, one of Behe's objections is that

"even if pseudogenes have no function, evolution has "explained" nothing about how pseudogenes arose. In order to make even a pseudo-copy of a gene, a dozen sophisticated proteins are required...Miller has not told us how any of these functions might have arisen in a Darwinian step-by-step process."
My problem here is that the origin of the proteins that make a pseudogene were not the items in question--their ultimate origin is a separate question. This is like saying that the explanation that cars come from factories doesn't really explain anything because it does not account for where the parts of the car came from. An answer to where the parts were made raises the question of where the materials came from, etc. Behe seems to like to play this game until the answer is "we don't know," at which point he invokes design.

Part of the difficulty with some of Behe's arguments is that he does not distinguish between several components of evolution. In the preface he writes that although evolution is a flexible word he uses it to mean "a process whereby life arose from non-living matter and subsequently developed entirely by natural means." This definition encompasses a number of concepts including what may be the most controversial one--abiogenesis. His lack of specificity about the evolutionary process under examination results in broad-brush arguments that are thereby weakened.

Toward the beginning of the book Behe states that he finds "the idea of common descent (that all organisms share a common ancestor) fairly convincing, and [has] no particular reason to doubt it." This statement might lead one to believe that Behe is only discussing the origin of life, and may be an attempt to diffuse criticism at the outset. However, the rest of the book does not seem to support this statement. Behe briefly discusses problems with the fossil record in manner similar to other critics of evolution (including common descent). He also includes quotations from various scientists expressing problems with evolutionary theory, although whether the context is accurate I do not know. The only real success Behe attributes to Darwinism is microevolution--even young earth creationists will concede that.

Appeal to the Masses:

It is apparent that this book is not written for the scientific community; it is written for the layperson. A cynical but not unlikely interpretation of this is that this book fits into the Discovery Institute's strategy of taking ID concepts straight to popular culture in an effort to revolutionize science without having to produce any real scientific evidence.

In order to communicate with laypersons, Behe makes extensive use of analogies. These are sometimes helpful but I believe they are ultimately a hindrance to real discussion. Any analogy will break down if pushed too far and some of Behe's analogies seem near that breaking point. For example Behe uses analogies of a mousetrap, Mount Rushmore, and a trap in the woods to make design arguments. The fundamental problem, it seems to me, is that biological systems are quite different from these examples. None of these examples are naturally common, reproduce themselves, exhibit random variation, or are subject to natural selection. In other words, none of these examples are subject to evolutionary processes--they are fundamentally different. Thus Behe's argument by analogy has severe limitations and flaws, in my opinion.

Why not embrace intelligent design?

Behe proposes a simple hypothesis: a single cell was designed billions of years ago that contained all the information necessary to produce all descended life forms. While the design portion of this hypothesis is not testable, the rest is--and I believe it fails. Having argued that flagella, the biochemical basis for vision, the blood clotting cascade, and the immune system constitute IC systems, Behe's hypothesis predicts that the genes for these systems were contained in the universal common ancestor and only turned on, as appropriate, in descendant organisms. If this were the case then we would expect to find genes for the components of these systems distributed throughout phylogenetic trees with no particular organization.

For example the RAG genes are necessary in order for the adaptive immune system to function. The RAG genes are only present in vertebrates, with the exception of jawless fish such as lampreys. The most straightforward interpretation of this is that vertebrates that existed after the split with jawless fish, acquired the RAG genes that enabled the development of the adaptive immune system in descendant organisms. (Behe might say, "You haven't explained anything because you haven't explained where the RAG genes came from." But that is a different question.)

Behe's hypothesis predicts that all organisms originally had the RAG genes but they were only retained in the vertebrates that now have immune systems. Are we to believe that the RAG genes were carried in organisms for billions of years but were ultimately lost in all organisms except those that now use them--thus giving the illusion of evolution? Are we to believe this for every proposed IC system? Aside from evolution, the only other alternative I can think of is special creation for each taxon that contains a unique IC system, and we are back to explaining the biological world with "because that's how the designer did it."

Conclusion:

The concepts of intelligent design and irreducible complexity may be useful on a personal level in the attempt to harmonize science and theology. However in my opinion they do not belong in serious scientific discourse. Although Behe characterizes molecular evolution as a moribund field, the era of comparative genomics is opening new doors of investigation. As more complete genome sequences become available it will be possible to understand the origins of more genes and biological systems. Although our ability to sequence whole genomes is impressive, a huge amount of work remains. The human, mouse, rat, and chicken genomes are the largest ones completed so far. But a much larger sampling of organisms will be needed in order to definitively answer many questions. It is therefore premature to invoke intelligent design as a force in biology.


Critiques of ID and IC:
Talk.Origins
Talkdesign

Continue reading...

Friday, February 18, 2005

Go Cougars!

Carl Zimmer has written a two-part post on eye evolution. Part 1 travels backward in time discussing how the eye may have evolved. Part 2 discusses organisms that have lost their eyes. This post mentions Brigham Young University by name in connection with the loss of vision in fleas. He links to the abstract of a paper by Michael Whiting.

Some of you will remember Whiting as the BYU professor that published a paper in Nature a couple of years ago dealing with the loss and re-gaining of wings in insects. (I don't remember which ones off hand--walking sticks maybe?)

I don't keep close tabs on research coming out of BYU, but it seemed to me like a number of the Bio-Ag faculty weren't doing much in the way of publishing good research. Maybe that is changing. At any rate, there are a few bright spots and I'm glad to see it.

(Elders quorum discussion topic: Should tithing money be facilitating research on evolution?)

Continue reading...

What Is the Point of Education Anyway?

The Panda's Thumb pointed out this article from the Tucson Weekly. It's about a 5 minute read and covers the debate over science education in Arizona.

Here's an interesting excerpt quoting Arizona Sen. Karen Johnson:


Continue Reading


To Johnson, a Christian fundamentalist, the teaching of evolution in the schools isn't simply unfair; it could be "faith-destroying," she says.

"It's hard for me to understand how evolution can get put into school science programs and get stuffed down the throats of those who don't want to hear it and who don't believe it anyway," Johnson says. "Children should choose what they want to believe. ... Science is basically the search for truth. The opposite of truth is myth. In my opinion, evolution is a myth. Those who adhere to the evolutionary theory, it's like a religion for them."

When Johnson talks to constituents, she's often struck by how few accept evolution.

"I can only find a few who think (the) theory of evolution has any merit," she says, "like professors at universities."


Yikes--I see several problems here. What is the point of education if it only confirms what we already thought? Like she said, the children are free to decide what they want to believe, but does that mean that they shouldn't be exposed to new ideas--especially those fundamental to a topic they are studying? And those darn universtiy professors--what do they know?

Although I dislike the creationist and ID attempts to insert themselves into science classes, or alternatively to have state-sponsered disclaimers about the material, I wonder somewhat about teaching evolution in high school. I mean evolution is a broad topic that, I think, needs to be taught in a careful and methodical manner in order to even be understood properly. I wonder if that can be accomplished in one--or even a few--50 min high school lectures.

On the other hand, high school should prepare students for college where they will most likely take at least one biology course. It should also help students to be able to discuss issues in society with some intelligence.

Anyway, the rest of the article is worth reading.

Continue reading...

Thursday, February 17, 2005

Human Fossils Re-Dated

Using newer dating techniques (argon dating), some Homo sapien fossils discovered in 1967 in Ethiopia have been re-evaluated and determined to be from 195,000 years ago. This puts them closer to dating estimates from genetic evidence which predict Homo sapiens emerged 200,000 years ago, and they further support the "out of Africa" theory. For more details, see here. (Also see here for a human migration map based on mitochondrial DNA.)


Continue Reading


The fossils were found 80 meters under the surface. Because the original researchers were interested in more ancient hominids, they didn't worry much about precision in dating. Then Ethiopia was closed for a while, so the site could not be examined.

Now, after visiting the discovery sites, analyzing their geology and testing rock samples with more modern dating techniques, Fleagle and colleagues report in Thursday’s issue of the journal Nature that both specimens are 195,000 years old, give or take 5,000 years.

Fleagle said the more primitive traits of Omo II may mean the two specimens came from different but overlapping Homo sapiens populations, or that they just represent natural variation within a single population.

To find the age of the skulls, the researchers determined that volcanic rock lying just below the sediment that contained the fossils was about 196,000 years old. They then found evidence that the fossil-bearing sediment was deposited soon after that time.


Although the evidence supports emergence of Homo sapiens at around 200,000 yr ago, apparently there is not evidence for true culture until 50,000 yrs ago.

Continue reading...

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP